Do you realize that that other software could do something like checksum test, or try to run same test few times, while HDTune takes the first result value ?
@Swamp Monster: no, the drive is not having problem. Look at those values. Spin up time of 677248117 seconds ?
This screen simply shows unreliable data transfer, which results in scrambled and stupid SMART data => sign of the errors in data transfers.
[H]@RD5TUFF: your point being ? It's not like Asus, Gigabyte or MSI is any different in this situation. Show me your "quality product" with P67/H67 chipset not having this issue.
Huh ? Actually, ASUS is last of the big ones. MSI and Gigabyte stopped selling and asked shops not to sell their motherboards yesterday morning. ASUS is doing it only today.
And to the ones who think this is overreacting - no, it is not. It is simply more cost effective for them not to sell...