- Joined
- Oct 15, 2006
- Messages
- 14,730 (2.21/day)
- Location
- Missoula, MT, USA
System Name | Kursah's Gaming Rig 2018 (2022 Upgrade) - Ryzen+ Edition | Gaming Laptop (Lenovo Legion 5i Pro 2022) |
---|---|
Processor | R7 5800X @ Stock | i7 12700H @ Stock |
Motherboard | Asus ROG Strix X370-F Gaming BIOS 6203| Legion 5i Pro NM-E231 |
Cooling | Noctua NH-U14S Push-Pull + NT-H1 | Stock Cooling |
Memory | TEAMGROUP T-Force Vulcan Z 32GB (2x16) DDR4 4000 @ 3600 18-20-20-42 1.35v | 32GB DDR5 4800 (2x16) |
Video Card(s) | Palit GeForce RTX 4070 JetStream 12GB | CPU-based Intel Iris XE + RTX 3070 8GB 150W |
Storage | 4TB SP UD90 NVME, 960GB SATA SSD, 2TB HDD | 1TB Samsung OEM NVME SSD + 4TB Crucial P3 Plus NVME SSD |
Display(s) | Acer 28" 4K VG280K x2 | 16" 2560x1600 built-in |
Case | Corsair 600C - Stock Fans on Low | Stock Metal/Plastic |
Audio Device(s) | Aune T1 mk1 > AKG K553 Pro + JVC HA-RX 700 (Equalizer APO + PeaceUI) | Bluetooth Earbuds (BX29) |
Power Supply | EVGA 750G2 Modular + APC Back-UPS Pro 1500 | 300W OEM (heavy use) or Lenovo Legion C135W GAN (light) |
Mouse | Logitech G502 | Logitech M330 |
Keyboard | HyperX Alloy Core RGB | Built in Keyboard (Lenovo laptop KB FTW) |
Software | Windows 11 Pro x64 | Windows 11 Home x64 |
I was thinking, we've had a few headphone/headset threads out there, and yet we don't have a good reference thread. So that's what this thread will be dedicated to, is what headphones/headsets you've used for gaming purposes, what you liked/disliked, what you replaced them with, what source/sound card you're using, etc. We might not have an audio section yet, but this thread could be helpful to many looking to get better sound or replace their busted headsets. Please no arguements, flaming, trolling, thread-crapping of any sort, if there is any it will be reported immediately to the moderation staff. This thread is to help others and post your experiences, everyone has a different ear for different sounds, games, movies and music, so don't expect because you had a good experience everyone will with the same setup.
THIS thread was created not just for me to write my own experiences, but for you to also add your experiences, whether or not a pair of heaphones or gaming headset has already been reviewed, add your experiences and opinoins of them and others, share with the community here and others just stopping by or lurking in the background! Donate to this thread and make it something for viewers to find a valuable resource in an area that's not nearly covered enough on TPU, sure there are other places to look, but I've seen nothing like this thread elsewhere and would like to see it be a useful thread worth keeping around.
Here's my post format for each headphone/headset I've owned, you don't gotta use it if you don't want to, just something I've done for a while so it's habit.
TPU Member Submitted Reviews!
Username
|
Product Review
|
Review Link
Frederik S | TPU's Headphone Reviews | http://techpowerup.com/reviews/?q_reviews=&p=1&pp=all&order=date&category=Headphones
Sir_Real | Silverline 5.1 Headset 751B | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1491208&postcount=4
Mussels | Sennheiser HD555 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1491246&postcount=6
Spaceman Spiff | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1491599&postcount=10
ourfpshero | Denon AH-D2000 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1508572&postcount=24
toxirau | Steelsound 4H | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1508589&postcount=25
ste2425 | Philips SBC HPI95 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1509752&postcount=34
ourfpshero | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1510234&postcount=35
ourfpshero | Beyerdynamic dt770 pro 80 ohm | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1511699&postcount=40
Frederik S | Sennheiser HD595 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1512048&postcount=41
-1nf1n1ty- | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1513070&postcount=43
ourfpshero | DBI Pro-700 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1519997&postcount=51
bigtye | Beyerdynamic DT234 Pro | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1524749&postcount=58
Wartz | Razer Barracuda | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1528446&postcount=62
Duffman | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1534596&postcount=66
MKmods | Medusa 5.1 Home Edition | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1544490&postcount=75
MKmods | JVC HA-RX700 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1547359&postcount=81
Kantastic | Creative Fatal1ty HS-1000 USB | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1579153&postcount=90
DrPepper | Plantronics Gamecom | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1667293&postcount=95
suraswami | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1698225&postcount=111
Kantastic | Sennheiser PC151 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1711394&postcount=114
pjladyfox | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1743217&postcount=124
AddSub | Niko HP-650 (Discontinued) | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1753514&postcount=128
cdawall | JVC HA G770 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1757644&postcount=134
tigger | Plantronics .Audio 450 (Discontinued) | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1805648&postcount=143
imperialreign | Razer Barracuda HP-1 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1806048&postcount=150
I'll start with what I can remember:
Logitech Headset w/boom mic - -
The Good:
This was my first pair of gaming headsets, back in 2006 iirc. Had 40mm drivers, in-line volume and mic mute controls. Issue one, was the small rotary style volume would bind, I had to dissassemble the in-line unit many times...the rotary was actually warped, I had to grind it down...and after too long it eventually caused a short issue. The final straw was when I lost all sound due to the volume control. Though they did last me about 14 months before finally failing.
Note: The model linked is the replacement for the model I originally purchased, which is no longer available. I have not personally tested the replacement model.
Summary: Spend a little more on a much better quality Plantronics product.
Plantronics .Audio 350 (iirc) w/boom mic - -
The Good:
Purchased these the day the logitechs failed, I wanted to try something different. I had actually purchased a couple other logitech headsets and returned them, and tried a different brand I'd never heard of which was Plantronics. Similar setup, on-ear pads, was much more comfortable, the boom mic was semi-flexible and folded, had in-line volume control and mic mute. I never had an issue with these, in fact I still have them. They were very consistent in performance, but definately not the best out there. For a cheap headset, the durability is 2nd to none though. I expected it to be weaker because of it's 99% plastic build, and they've been through some rough times without so much as a couple of scratches. Though if I ever need a backup pair, and since I don't wear glasses they're somewhat comfy for about 1-2 hours, I'm golden, and since they were about 20 bucks I don't feel bad about storing them as a backup set.
Summary: One of the best sub-$30 headsets I've ever had the pleasure of owning.
LTB Magnum 5.1 AC97 - -
The Good:
I had high hopes for these, they were by far the most I'd ever spent on a gaming headset, but they features 5.1, 3 speakers in each cup. The front was also the sub, then center and surround...the amp was built into the cups, the mic was built into the lh cup, no boom though..it picked up everything...very bad for gaming and comms. There was also volume and mute buttons on the side of the LH cup, it had 4 3.5mm jacks + USB for amp power. They were ok, but nothing amazing, and eventually my first pair decided to lose the RH cup audio. Sent in for RMA, the 2nd set failed in 2 weeks all together, sent that set in, the 3rd set lasted me about a year and eventually had an issue where it'd lose the LH front channel and I'd have to smack the cup to get sound back. They were a pain to dissassemble, they got hot and uncomfortable after an hour or two, and were only good for gaming, though the positional audio left a lot to be desired. I hope noone else was as stupid as I was and gave these a shot...definately a big waste of money and time. Gave this pair to my fiance, she hated the random muting, and they pushed on her glasses so she couldn't use them much...but she wasn't gaming too much at the time so she was fine with them.
Summary: Not worth $20 on a good day. Absolute crap in comparison to others whether 5.1 or not in it's price-range.
Turtle Beach Ear Force HPA2 5.1 Rv.1 w/Wall Plug Power 2112 - -
The Good:
My first experience with these was at a friends' house, he'd just downloaded the CoD4 demo and wanted me to check it out. I tried them on, they were comfy, the removable mic boom was perfect, the cups fit around my ears, the pads were very soft and nicely padded, and the sound was amazing, crisp hi's and booming lows. Made for a great experience in gaming and music. They feature 4 speakers per cup, front, center, rear, sub. They also feature in-line amplifier w/volume control and level control for each channel. They had 4x3.5mm jacks for audio connections and a wall-plug 120v for powering the amp. The LED on the amp unit itself was an annoyance, I usually taped over it. I ended up tossing these at a friend when he bought my x-fi xtreme music, his sound card went out and his dog chewed up his headset...perfect reason for me to replace them...only issue...I bought the same headset again because I was so content with it's performance in gaming, music and movies. Sound placement was great, overall I was really happy...though they were open backed, which meant sound leaked out and I could hear my fiance nagging at me.
Summary: Decent first try by Turtle Beach, though no longer in production.
Turtle Beach Ear Force HPA2 5.1 Rv.2 w/USB Power 2114 - -
The Good:
Well, I ordered up my new set as I mentioned above, when I recieved them, I was kinda curious how well the USB would power the amp in comparison to the wall-plug style. Nothing else physically seemed to have changed...I hooked them up to my new x-fi (found another xtreme music I had gotten to replace the one I sold, again, solid performer, found one cheap). I was amazed, the output was louder, clearer, the bass seemed to punch a little harder and go lower. Nothing else beyond that changed, the soundstage was still decent, or what I considered great at the time. I ran these for a long time before my fiance finally killed the LTB's and took these from me before I got home from work. But she loved them, they sounded way better, they didn't cause pain w/her glasses on...I don't have eye issues yet, so that's not an issue for me, but that gave me good reason to upgrade...I couldn't go for the HPA2's a 3rd time. So I considered other options, see this thread: Considering New Headset
What ended up happening was me going for a decent pair of headphones for something new. But I also wanted to note that the Razer HP-1's are based on the HPA2, but from what I've read and researched are more expensive with a crappier amplifier and lesser quality. Not saying that's necessarily true, but I did find quite a bit about it while researching.
Summary: 2nd revision of HPA2's are a joy to listen to for music, movies and gaming, matched with a decent sound card they can really shine. 5.1 is decent from a good source, plenty of bass. Definately worth a serious look for those that feel they "require" a "true 5.1" gaming headset.
JVC HA-RX700 Headphones - -
The Good:
I wasn't sure what to expect, but if you read my considering new headset thread, I found a few threads that praised these cheap $33 shiped (at the time of this writing) pair of headphones as competing with much more expensive cans. There was a lot of good info, some mods, and they were half the price of the HPA2's so I figured I'd give them a go. Needless to say, I was blown away. Everything sounded better, they were comfortable, they went much louder, they had much lower bass that you felt, the mids and hi's were much more pronounced and identifiable...I noticed stuff in music I'd never heard before, sounds in games were clear and crisp. I had read that I could emulate 5.1 sound to my headphones using the CMMS-3D of my X-Fi. Naturally I had to compare this to my "true" 5.1 headset as the JVC's had 1 speaker per cup...and there were many headsets that were using 5.1/7.1 emulation I was very skeptical. Here's how you do it, go into Windows Control panel, Sound, speakers, set to 5.1. Then go into X-Fi control panel, game mode, headphone or 2.1 output, cmms-3d on. Set the game to either windows default or 5.1, and voila, now CMMS-3d will emulate 5.1 channels to your headphone...I gave it a shot in CoD4 and I was extremely suprised. The soundstage was huge in comparison to the HPA2's, sounds had distance to them, their placement was easily matching the HPA2's if not easier to locate, I was amazed. So far, I can't believe I spent so much on gaming headsets when a decent pair of headphones would do the trick.
So how did I use a mic you ask? Because this pair of headphones is my gaming headset you see...all I did was get about 8ft of 3.5mm cable, routed it along my headphone cable round the desk, and zip-tied the end to the top support of the LH earcup, then I ordered a non-lock style boom mic for a Turtle Beach HPA2 (in replacement parts), plugged it in and had the crisp recording and adjustability of the HPA2 without much hassle at all, many also use a Zalman clip on cable mic too...but i did prefer the HPA2 mic, even though I failed to mention it above, it records clearly and cuts out a decent amount of background noise...though it will pickup some voices if they're a couple feet from ya, but aside from that, communication is great through that style of mic, and I wanted to keep it that way. Overall, this is the BEST gaming headset I've ever owned, it meets or beats the HPA2's in every aspect, from bass/mids/hi's to gaming, movies, you name it. I would definately recommend this to anyone that doesn't want to spend an arm and a leg on a gaming headset, even with the extra cable and mic I was under $50. But one word of caution, they don't sound too good from onboard unless it has a decent EQ...it'll need a healthy V shaped EQ at that. I am now currently running an Auzen X-Fi Forte that has an integrated heapdhone amp, which was a nice improvement over my X-Fi Xtreme Music, but even the old creative X-Fi trumped the onboard of my P5Q Deluxe AD2000 and GB P35-DS3L ALC885 onboard, no contest and it was VERY noticable. So having an add-in sound card is the way to go, and adding amplification be it a home reciever, headphone amp, amp/dac or sound card is greatly helpful and makes these headphones really shine.
I did a couple of mods to mine, added some foam under the cusions not only for added comfort but it also increased the sound stage a bit and let the bass extend while letting it be more defined. I also did the felt removal mod to help clear up the mids/hi's, both were extremely easy to do and took no time at all to complete, but are not necessary at all to enjoy this set.
Summary: For $33, you can't lose. They beat every gaming headset I've listened to in everything with the right source and features that is. Easy to drive, and a ton of information out there on them. I forgot why I wanted gaming headsets after owning these.
JVC HA-DX3 Headphones - -
The Good:
I wanted to see where I could go next from the RX700's, the DX3's seemed to be a fairly popular choice, they have good specs, solid build quality, metal cups, and are extremely comfortable. They actually look a tad similar to the build of the Turtle Beach HPA2's but better. On the sound front they definately bring out the mids and hi's, but I noticed right away there wasn't much on the bass front even with the same EQ-ing I used on the RX700's. Now the DX3's are 90 ohms compared to the 700's 48ohms (iirc), so they are a tad harder to drive. Frankly I feel this is the design of the DX3's, they're meant for more detail to be brought out and that does mean attenuating the bass down a bit.
On the gaming front they have a larger soundstage than the RX700's, placement seems a little better, but not leaps and bounds. But overall they sound extremely good, but at this point I don't feel they were worth the retail price necessarily. Though many will definately enjoy them, and in fact I do...what suprised me most after getting these was just how good the RX700's truly are. TBH, save your money and try the RX700 first, both are good, but at least to me the 700's are easier and more enjoyable to listen to, even if less comfortable. One last note is that they leak more sound due to the cloth earpads, more comfort must mean more sound leak, oh well I still enjoy them! But when it comes down to just grabbing a pair of headphones to use, I reach for the RX700's almost every time.
Summary: Very nice pair of headphones, not quite worth the money imo, but they bring out a lot of detail are very enjoyable for gaming, extremely comfortable for many hours of use. Wait till you can find them for around $70-80 imo.
Now I've tried more than I've purchased including a few more plantronics, turtle beaches, logitechs, skull candy, bose, sony, etc...but I really only wanted to comment on the ones I owned and had a decent amount of use on. I hope this thread grows and can help many others while in search of something new, I may change the format to add more info/links, I haven't decided yet, but I figured I'd get the ball rollin and see what you guys come up with, what are you using? How do you like it? What else have you used/owned? Post it up here!
Denon AH-D2000 Headphones - -
The Good:
Well I loved the DX3's comfort and overall higher quality sound, but loved the RX700's value and serious and punchy bass with an overall good sound...but I wanted both. I now realize that will cost over $200 new, a little under used. But...is it an amazing experience...at least to me. I'm no audiophile, but I really enjoy something that can provide what I'm looking for, and that responds well to my setup. Granted I have a sound card with a heapdhone amp built-in...it's not the best but was much, much less than any close competitor at the time I purchased it. Either rate, the Auzen Forte is great for all I do...plus it was affordable...yet could better push my headphones via amp without needing an external amp that was uber expensive and more clutter. For me it works well, for some, a true amp will definitely win, and others on-board is as good as they'll ever go.
Onto the headphones, they're definitely upscale. They feel better, higher quality overall, they use a separate wire for each can, a thick main cable with plenty of length for routing, and overall impressed me. I try them on...seeing the pleather and expecing an RX-700 type experience..I was surprised...they were MORE comfortable than my DX3's...something I really didn't expect. Then I fire up some tunes, set my basic EQ setup (heavy bass, slight bump on 2-4k, and flat on the rest) and was blown away. They don't hit quite as hard as the 700's..but hits hard and has a much lower, more realistic bass. Plus clear mids and hi's was exactly what I was looking for. Too bad it cost more than the previous two headphones new, combined...for a used pair of these. But hell they sound great.
So I hop into a game, CMMS-3d on..ready to go..had to turn up TS a little and winamp ( like to run tunes while gaming and bs-ing). I was not too impressed...it wasn't horrible..but placement seemed a little off and the sounds were just odd in tone. So I turned of CMMS-3d, left windows in 5.1, game in 5.1 and Control Panel in Headphone mode, and was amazed. The soundstage kicked ass for a closed can...blew away both the DX3's and RX700's, yet none are crappy...and all were better to my ears than pretty much every gaming headset I've ever tried. Racing, Strategy, FPS area ll genres I "primarily" play...though not much beyond any 3 of them. Needless to say I gotta say this pair of headphones is amazing to my ears driven by my setup. Many say they're bass heavy, but imo that's with a good amp...even a setup like mine needs EQ to extract bass from these or any headphone/headset I've used. But I can get more bass than I'd ever want really easily that goes very, very loud and low.
Summary: Best pair of headphones I've used yet, gaming rocks, comfortable, great sound, great bass, easy to tune with EQ, a lot of good...but at the end of the day...they need to be cheaper because the RX700's do a bang-up job competing. But while the Denon's may be a "little" better in all areas, it's a noticable improvement and a much more refined sound, along with a larger sound stage for gaming. If you got money to blow get these, if you are just getting into headphones for headsets...start out cheaper, especially if you don't have a sound card yet. Get the RX700 and an X-Fi Xtreme Music or Audio or similar in another brand that has a solid EQ, feature set and output level, or if you have bucks and want good sound a better Auzen or Asus with an integrated headphone amp or dedicated amp using digital out from on-board with these headphones and you'll be set for a long time to come...but you will pay for it dearly (imo, there are some uber expensive headphones, cards and amps...this is more for the mainstream gamer...and for that my setup imo is higher end...$100+ sound card and $200+ pair of headphones is hella expensive...that's half a solid budget PC gaming build!).
Grizzly Buds Ear Buds
(Formerly Ironbuds, successful Kickstarter for the most part)
The Good:
The Review:
I backed the original Ironbuds and received my cheaply painted wood encased pair that came with adapters, extra buds, tips, and a case. Was blown away by the bass they produced, but they always lacked a clear midrange and treble was just okay. They made good buds for workouts because they were modular and came apart under accidents. But only about a year in the cable had a seperation at the left connector and when I tried to order a new cable they were out of stock and could only tell me they were waiting on suppliers. Not very impressed, but at least they replied.
Enter the Grizzly Buds in 2014, and they seem to be trying to change face. The new model has aluminum housings, and much higher quality standards for near the same price, without the extras of course. I haven't needed to order any spare parts, everything seems much better built and more solid though. The sound improved tremendously.
One thing both pairs have in common? They're easy to drive! Every device from smartphones to my little Sansa MP3 player to my Aune T1 dac/amp, to my Denon AVR-1613 receiver, they scale well. The Grizzly Buds scale much much better though.
The bass, as much as your ear drums and EQ can handle. I've tried to find the end or limits...without too much permanent damage and haven't found it. Do be warned, you will reach a point where the bass starts to overpower the rest of it before you find clipping...at least that's my findings. The mids and treble are so much better than the Ironbuds that its almost astounding. One will toss those first gen units after listening to these.
I've mostly listened to sub-$100 buds, and these compete with all of them to me. The buds are large and heavy, but sound great. I was even impressed with how well they were for gaming, the soundstage is clearly limited but it pulls out the excitement of all the aural goodness that modern games provide. Which is nice if you have a significant other that hates hearing your music and games or you prefer isolation.
On that note, isolation is great too, sure with no volume you can hear someone you have to pay more attention because it will be muted as most ear buds do. Honestly I'm glad I gave these guys a second shot, these earbuds have been fantastic, durable, and strong. They have complemented my full size headphones greatly and are my go-to when I want the best sound I can have without big ass headphones on my dome. Sure I could likely find better if I really wanted to look and had the money, but with these I'm content.
Summary: Good and cheap if you're willing to take a risk on an unknown name.
HiFiMan HE-400
The Good:
The Review:
Well I bought these in December 2013, and have loved them ever since. Best $300+ headphone I've ever owned or listened to. Just been blown away by the planar magnetic experience. The speed of the drivers, the response, the clarity and detail all just amazing. Makes my D2000's feel lazy, makes everything else seem a little shrouded.
While some complain of the weight, I never really minded it and the memory foam pad on the headband was okay...though the newer strap design on the 400i and 560 is MUCH more comfortable. The earpads from those headphones will transfer to these and many report massively improved comfort, some also buy a snap-on headband pad from Amazon to increase comfort.
When I first listened to these, I pretty much HAD to listen to my entire music collection all over again. It sounded like I had missed so much...like all my songs were new. Sounds in games I never noticed. Soundstage that was wide and vast, yet crisp and focused. The bass, while not as low as the D2000's, the bass seems to have more punch and still reaches very very low. Doesn't ever overpower the rest. Vocals and instruments sound amazing, as do gunshots and explosions and the amazing ship noises in Elite Dangerous and Star Citizen. Battles in SupCom or PA are truly epic and vast. Movies are also amazing.
The caveat? Open headphones are for limited applications. I've listened to these HE-400's almost daily since I bought them, and they are in great shape. The painted "L" on the left adjuster faded off almost right away but the R has remained. Beyond that, I had a cracked cable shield that was replaced under warranty, and the longest period I went in between listening to these. Living with someone whom is noise sensitive, especially when they're trying to sleep and I'm only 10 feet away means I can't enjoy these at a comfortable volume. These are best when you have the house to yourself or the others don't mind what you're listening to you. It will be loud outside and inside of these phones. The only isolation you'll get from these when listening to them is volume. Beyond there there's a couple of foam pieces a metal grid and the planar membrane and magnets separating you from the outside.
I have sadly decided to sell these because I cannot enjoy them as much as I wanted to, except for as I write this because everyone's gone and my Aune T1 is warmed up!
I will miss these headphones and look forward to finding one with isolation that can reproduce even 2/3 the sound these did. While I still enjoy my D2000's, they really do pale in comparison to these. Really everything else I've listened to or owned has paled in comparison to these. The 400i's are supposed to be better, more comfortable, easier to drive and lighter, but with less bass. Ymmv.
From what I've found, which my experience and reach is limited due to budget and where I live, these are the best headphones in this price-range if you can be alright with the open design. I consider myself a basshead still, not as hardcore as I once was but these produce more than I need and are easy to EQ up for that need. These also are more sensitive to different DACs and AMPs than I was used to. These show the most notable difference between the Aune T1 and Denon AVR-1613. While the T1 hit a little harder, the Denon reached lower and sounded smoother overall. Was an interesting find. Enjoy losing your free time if you have a large music collection, you'll want to hear it all. Be warned, crappy quality will sound crappy as these headphones expose everything. Still worth every penny.
Summary: Amazing experience. If you can find comfort with them, they're worth it!
AKG K553 Pro - - Link 1 - Link 2 - Link 3
The Good:
The Bad:
The Review:
Where to start...I pretty much covered some important points above. These are very enjoyable for closed cans...I had to give up my favored pair of HE400's due to the noisier environment I was in. I needed something closed, fast, clear and capable of decent bass. I searched high and low, even tried a $400 pair of Oppo PM-3's factory direct. They were good, but not $400 good to me and didn't fit my needs nor comfort level.
I kept passing the Massdrop on these AKG K553's and I had missed and at one point regretted missing the AKG 7XX deal until I couldn't listen to open-backs anymore. I decided for the price ($120 at the time of drop), I'd bite and resell if I didn't enjoy them. Well they're still on my head and I just ordered a spare pair off the most recent Massdrop...the fifth drop this pair has seen on Massdrop since launching last April/May.
For the price I am amazed and content. They sound great and so much more open than they should...while still being able to keep an amazing level of passive noise isolation. Though they don't clamp too tight on your head that can be adjusted by slightly bending the head band...frankly after letting the pads wear-in a bit I feel they're plenty fine.
These are also very easy to fit for comfort in my opinion. Which helps greatly with the sound...even allowing some tuning. Tilt the cup forward and you'll get more mid and treble and lowered bass...tilt back to reverse the effect.
While being easy to drive from my cell phone and Sansa MP3 player, they really shine being powered from my Aune T1 with a bassier EQ tune. The only range really lacking without EQ is bass...and honestly this is the only headphone I can actually listen to and enjoy without EQ-ing. Because the mid and treble have some meat and depth and are fun to enjoy. Add bass, and you can easily keep that and add some thump and boom.
These headphones will vibrate on your head too...I've yet to find them distort either. They will crank very loud and also are able to run nice and quiet while being clear.
I enjoy gaming with these, and really enjoy it. The imaging is very good for the games I play the immersion is very much there. Music sounds amazing, but crappy recordings are like the HE400's and will be rougher...but the K553 Pro's are a little more forgiving being less analytical.
Overall, after months and months with these K553's I'm extremely content and feel no need to upgrade. They have the right kind(s) of bass and sound for me, easy to tune for different needs, comfortable, lightweight and affordable. The only other headphones I purchased spares of were my JVC HA-RX700s (sold the backup pair after 7-8 years on my shelf in the package...original pair still going strong), Sony XB-500's (kids use one pair, she has the other pair), and now these.
I cannot recommend these enough for someone wanting more without spending an arm and a leg. Will these beat $400-500 headphones? Likely not...but they won't beat up your wallet either. For what they can provide with the crisp and floaty treble, clear and accurate mids and very capable thuderous-when-equalized-and-amped bass...in audio alone they win. In comfort they win again, and then isolation too...top notch. These aren't for everyone, but for me they did what I needed...replaced my HE-400's with isolation, without losing all the speed and detail my other headphones did. Winning!
Now replacing the ear pads is a different story, I searched high and low before contacting Harmon support...only to wait several days for a response. The cost was around $34 shipped for a replacement pair. They are purchased individually. I bought spares just to have...my original pads are still in excellent shape with no sign of giving out at all. Harmon support was easy to work with and easy to order from, albeit there was a shipping mistake and they sent one wrong pad (doh!), they immediately replied to my contact and worked to make it right. Better than I can say for other vendors I've purchased various products from.
The hinges also turn 180 degrees which allow these to lay flat...I do this every day when I'm done listening to them..and the hinges are solid, no sign of give. Same with the frame and the whole kit...solid and feels well built and engineered. I have no worries of these breaking or failing any day soon. But should they...my spare pair would be here soon!
My worry? She will finally try them out and find she really likes them...the real reason I have a spare pair!
Summary: Excellent value on Massdrop, excellent sub-$200 headphone period. If you want an open sounding, closed headphone that has far better than average isolation...look no further. If you don't mind playing with an EQ to get the sound you seek, these are an excellent option!
Now I've tried more than I've purchased including a few more plantronics, turtle beaches, logitechs, skull candy, bose, sony, etc...but I really only wanted to comment on the ones I owned and had a decent amount of use on. I hope this thread grows and can help many others while in search of something new, I may change the format to add more info/links, I haven't decided yet, but I figured I'd get the ball rollin and see what you guys come up with, what are you using? How do you like it? What else have you used/owned? Post it up here!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
THIS thread was created not just for me to write my own experiences, but for you to also add your experiences, whether or not a pair of heaphones or gaming headset has already been reviewed, add your experiences and opinoins of them and others, share with the community here and others just stopping by or lurking in the background! Donate to this thread and make it something for viewers to find a valuable resource in an area that's not nearly covered enough on TPU, sure there are other places to look, but I've seen nothing like this thread elsewhere and would like to see it be a useful thread worth keeping around.
Here's my post format for each headphone/headset I've owned, you don't gotta use it if you don't want to, just something I've done for a while so it's habit.
TPU Member Submitted Reviews!
Frederik S | TPU's Headphone Reviews | http://techpowerup.com/reviews/?q_reviews=&p=1&pp=all&order=date&category=Headphones
Sir_Real | Silverline 5.1 Headset 751B | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1491208&postcount=4
Mussels | Sennheiser HD555 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1491246&postcount=6
Spaceman Spiff | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1491599&postcount=10
ourfpshero | Denon AH-D2000 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1508572&postcount=24
toxirau | Steelsound 4H | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1508589&postcount=25
ste2425 | Philips SBC HPI95 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1509752&postcount=34
ourfpshero | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1510234&postcount=35
ourfpshero | Beyerdynamic dt770 pro 80 ohm | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1511699&postcount=40
Frederik S | Sennheiser HD595 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1512048&postcount=41
-1nf1n1ty- | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1513070&postcount=43
ourfpshero | DBI Pro-700 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1519997&postcount=51
bigtye | Beyerdynamic DT234 Pro | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1524749&postcount=58
Wartz | Razer Barracuda | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1528446&postcount=62
Duffman | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1534596&postcount=66
MKmods | Medusa 5.1 Home Edition | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1544490&postcount=75
MKmods | JVC HA-RX700 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1547359&postcount=81
Kantastic | Creative Fatal1ty HS-1000 USB | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1579153&postcount=90
DrPepper | Plantronics Gamecom | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1667293&postcount=95
suraswami | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1698225&postcount=111
Kantastic | Sennheiser PC151 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1711394&postcount=114
pjladyfox | Multiple Review | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1743217&postcount=124
AddSub | Niko HP-650 (Discontinued) | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1753514&postcount=128
cdawall | JVC HA G770 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1757644&postcount=134
tigger | Plantronics .Audio 450 (Discontinued) | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1805648&postcount=143
imperialreign | Razer Barracuda HP-1 | http://forums.techpowerup.com/showpost.php?p=1806048&postcount=150
Code:
[B ]Headphone[/B] - Smiley Rating - [I ]Mini-review[/I]
I'll start with what I can remember:
Logitech Headset w/boom mic - -
The Good:
- Affordable
- In-Line Volume/Mic Mute
- Integrated Mic
- Easy to drive
- Chincy Volume Control
- Mic pics up too much background noise
- You get what you pay for, read: crap
- Uncomfortable after about an hour
This was my first pair of gaming headsets, back in 2006 iirc. Had 40mm drivers, in-line volume and mic mute controls. Issue one, was the small rotary style volume would bind, I had to dissassemble the in-line unit many times...the rotary was actually warped, I had to grind it down...and after too long it eventually caused a short issue. The final straw was when I lost all sound due to the volume control. Though they did last me about 14 months before finally failing.
Note: The model linked is the replacement for the model I originally purchased, which is no longer available. I have not personally tested the replacement model.
Summary: Spend a little more on a much better quality Plantronics product.
Plantronics .Audio 350 (iirc) w/boom mic - -
The Good:
- Affordable
- Decent sound for the price
- Decent Mic for the price
- In line volume and mic mute
- Good durability
- Uncomfortable after about 1-2hrs, on ear style headphones
Purchased these the day the logitechs failed, I wanted to try something different. I had actually purchased a couple other logitech headsets and returned them, and tried a different brand I'd never heard of which was Plantronics. Similar setup, on-ear pads, was much more comfortable, the boom mic was semi-flexible and folded, had in-line volume control and mic mute. I never had an issue with these, in fact I still have them. They were very consistent in performance, but definately not the best out there. For a cheap headset, the durability is 2nd to none though. I expected it to be weaker because of it's 99% plastic build, and they've been through some rough times without so much as a couple of scratches. Though if I ever need a backup pair, and since I don't wear glasses they're somewhat comfy for about 1-2 hours, I'm golden, and since they were about 20 bucks I don't feel bad about storing them as a backup set.
Summary: One of the best sub-$30 headsets I've ever had the pleasure of owning.
LTB Magnum 5.1 AC97 - -
The Good:
- 5.1 Audio Placement is OK
- Volume/Mute controls on LH Cup
- Mic integrated to LH cup
- 5.1 Audio Placement is OK
- Mic picks up EVERYTHING
- Chincy build quality, chincy sound quality
- Overpriced for what you get
- Ears get hot and uncomfortable after about an hour
- Crap durability
I had high hopes for these, they were by far the most I'd ever spent on a gaming headset, but they features 5.1, 3 speakers in each cup. The front was also the sub, then center and surround...the amp was built into the cups, the mic was built into the lh cup, no boom though..it picked up everything...very bad for gaming and comms. There was also volume and mute buttons on the side of the LH cup, it had 4 3.5mm jacks + USB for amp power. They were ok, but nothing amazing, and eventually my first pair decided to lose the RH cup audio. Sent in for RMA, the 2nd set failed in 2 weeks all together, sent that set in, the 3rd set lasted me about a year and eventually had an issue where it'd lose the LH front channel and I'd have to smack the cup to get sound back. They were a pain to dissassemble, they got hot and uncomfortable after an hour or two, and were only good for gaming, though the positional audio left a lot to be desired. I hope noone else was as stupid as I was and gave these a shot...definately a big waste of money and time. Gave this pair to my fiance, she hated the random muting, and they pushed on her glasses so she couldn't use them much...but she wasn't gaming too much at the time so she was fine with them.
Summary: Not worth $20 on a good day. Absolute crap in comparison to others whether 5.1 or not in it's price-range.
Turtle Beach Ear Force HPA2 5.1 Rv.1 w/Wall Plug Power 2112 - -
The Good:
- True 5.1 in a headset
- 4 speakers per cup, front, center, surround, sub
- In-line Amp with master volume and level controls for each channel
- Very comfortable for many hours of use
- Plenty of bass, works well with onboard and add-in sound cards
- Boom mic records loud and clear, removable and adjustable
- Decent durability
- Needs an extra power connection for amplifier (this model needs 120v connection)
- Can rattle at louder volumes, generally louder than one should listen to
- LED on Amp can be very annoying
- Surround sound is good, but not amazing
- Prices constantly changing, I've seen them as low as $50 and over $100...not worth more than $60-$70
- Open back design allows sound in and out.
My first experience with these was at a friends' house, he'd just downloaded the CoD4 demo and wanted me to check it out. I tried them on, they were comfy, the removable mic boom was perfect, the cups fit around my ears, the pads were very soft and nicely padded, and the sound was amazing, crisp hi's and booming lows. Made for a great experience in gaming and music. They feature 4 speakers per cup, front, center, rear, sub. They also feature in-line amplifier w/volume control and level control for each channel. They had 4x3.5mm jacks for audio connections and a wall-plug 120v for powering the amp. The LED on the amp unit itself was an annoyance, I usually taped over it. I ended up tossing these at a friend when he bought my x-fi xtreme music, his sound card went out and his dog chewed up his headset...perfect reason for me to replace them...only issue...I bought the same headset again because I was so content with it's performance in gaming, music and movies. Sound placement was great, overall I was really happy...though they were open backed, which meant sound leaked out and I could hear my fiance nagging at me.
Summary: Decent first try by Turtle Beach, though no longer in production.
Turtle Beach Ear Force HPA2 5.1 Rv.2 w/USB Power 2114 - -
The Good:
- Improved sound over original HPA2 model
- USB power means less wiring mess, easier to get connected and going
- True 5.1 in a headset
- Same great mic, loud and clear, adjustable, removable
- Comfortable for many hours of use
- In-line amp w/volume and level controls
- Decent durability
- Amp LED is annoying
- Can rattle at higher volumes with too much bass
- Surround sound is good, but not amazing
- Prices can be all over the place
- Open back design allows sound in and out.
Well, I ordered up my new set as I mentioned above, when I recieved them, I was kinda curious how well the USB would power the amp in comparison to the wall-plug style. Nothing else physically seemed to have changed...I hooked them up to my new x-fi (found another xtreme music I had gotten to replace the one I sold, again, solid performer, found one cheap). I was amazed, the output was louder, clearer, the bass seemed to punch a little harder and go lower. Nothing else beyond that changed, the soundstage was still decent, or what I considered great at the time. I ran these for a long time before my fiance finally killed the LTB's and took these from me before I got home from work. But she loved them, they sounded way better, they didn't cause pain w/her glasses on...I don't have eye issues yet, so that's not an issue for me, but that gave me good reason to upgrade...I couldn't go for the HPA2's a 3rd time. So I considered other options, see this thread: Considering New Headset
What ended up happening was me going for a decent pair of headphones for something new. But I also wanted to note that the Razer HP-1's are based on the HPA2, but from what I've read and researched are more expensive with a crappier amplifier and lesser quality. Not saying that's necessarily true, but I did find quite a bit about it while researching.
Summary: 2nd revision of HPA2's are a joy to listen to for music, movies and gaming, matched with a decent sound card they can really shine. 5.1 is decent from a good source, plenty of bass. Definately worth a serious look for those that feel they "require" a "true 5.1" gaming headset.
JVC HA-RX700 Headphones - -
The Good:
- Amazing value! Current market is around $33 shipped
- Sounds better than many gaming headsets for much cheaper
- Easy to drive with onboard and add-in sound cards
- Can provide plenty of bass, while still providing good mids and hi's
- Utilizing sound card 3D emulation tech such as CMMS-3D or Dolby Headphone can creat a solid 5.1 gaming experience that easily competes with true 5.1 gaming headsets
- Comfortable for hours of use
- Decent build quality, they feel and sound much more expensive than they will cost you
- Ears can get hot, sore and sweaty after a few hours, very cheap mods are available due to large support for these in the gamer/listener communites
- Not a true 5.1 may be a con for some that don't have proper sound card technology, or feel emulated 5.1 isn't good enough...though I recommend doing what I did and actually comparing both side-by-side
- Availability due to popularity can make finding these a challenge at times
I wasn't sure what to expect, but if you read my considering new headset thread, I found a few threads that praised these cheap $33 shiped (at the time of this writing) pair of headphones as competing with much more expensive cans. There was a lot of good info, some mods, and they were half the price of the HPA2's so I figured I'd give them a go. Needless to say, I was blown away. Everything sounded better, they were comfortable, they went much louder, they had much lower bass that you felt, the mids and hi's were much more pronounced and identifiable...I noticed stuff in music I'd never heard before, sounds in games were clear and crisp. I had read that I could emulate 5.1 sound to my headphones using the CMMS-3D of my X-Fi. Naturally I had to compare this to my "true" 5.1 headset as the JVC's had 1 speaker per cup...and there were many headsets that were using 5.1/7.1 emulation I was very skeptical. Here's how you do it, go into Windows Control panel, Sound, speakers, set to 5.1. Then go into X-Fi control panel, game mode, headphone or 2.1 output, cmms-3d on. Set the game to either windows default or 5.1, and voila, now CMMS-3d will emulate 5.1 channels to your headphone...I gave it a shot in CoD4 and I was extremely suprised. The soundstage was huge in comparison to the HPA2's, sounds had distance to them, their placement was easily matching the HPA2's if not easier to locate, I was amazed. So far, I can't believe I spent so much on gaming headsets when a decent pair of headphones would do the trick.
So how did I use a mic you ask? Because this pair of headphones is my gaming headset you see...all I did was get about 8ft of 3.5mm cable, routed it along my headphone cable round the desk, and zip-tied the end to the top support of the LH earcup, then I ordered a non-lock style boom mic for a Turtle Beach HPA2 (in replacement parts), plugged it in and had the crisp recording and adjustability of the HPA2 without much hassle at all, many also use a Zalman clip on cable mic too...but i did prefer the HPA2 mic, even though I failed to mention it above, it records clearly and cuts out a decent amount of background noise...though it will pickup some voices if they're a couple feet from ya, but aside from that, communication is great through that style of mic, and I wanted to keep it that way. Overall, this is the BEST gaming headset I've ever owned, it meets or beats the HPA2's in every aspect, from bass/mids/hi's to gaming, movies, you name it. I would definately recommend this to anyone that doesn't want to spend an arm and a leg on a gaming headset, even with the extra cable and mic I was under $50. But one word of caution, they don't sound too good from onboard unless it has a decent EQ...it'll need a healthy V shaped EQ at that. I am now currently running an Auzen X-Fi Forte that has an integrated heapdhone amp, which was a nice improvement over my X-Fi Xtreme Music, but even the old creative X-Fi trumped the onboard of my P5Q Deluxe AD2000 and GB P35-DS3L ALC885 onboard, no contest and it was VERY noticable. So having an add-in sound card is the way to go, and adding amplification be it a home reciever, headphone amp, amp/dac or sound card is greatly helpful and makes these headphones really shine.
I did a couple of mods to mine, added some foam under the cusions not only for added comfort but it also increased the sound stage a bit and let the bass extend while letting it be more defined. I also did the felt removal mod to help clear up the mids/hi's, both were extremely easy to do and took no time at all to complete, but are not necessary at all to enjoy this set.
Summary: For $33, you can't lose. They beat every gaming headset I've listened to in everything with the right source and features that is. Easy to drive, and a ton of information out there on them. I forgot why I wanted gaming headsets after owning these.
JVC HA-DX3 Headphones - -
The Good:
- Extremely Comfortable
- Nice Build Quality
- Very well defined mids and treble, brings out more detail
- Can provide decent bass but it's more boom than punch
- Utilizing sound card 3D emulation tech such as CMMS-3D or Dolby Headphone can create a solid emulated 5.1 gaming experience that competes with true 5.1 gaming headsets
- At $100, I feel they're overpriced for what they provide
- Bass quantity and detail may be dissapointing going from an HA-RX700 or similar headphone, not completely lacking, but it has a more boomy bass that is just present enough to notice which might be perfect for some
- Not a true 5.1 may be a con for some that don't have proper sound card technology, or feel emulated 5.1 isn't good enough...though I recommend doing what I did and actually comparing both side-by-side
I wanted to see where I could go next from the RX700's, the DX3's seemed to be a fairly popular choice, they have good specs, solid build quality, metal cups, and are extremely comfortable. They actually look a tad similar to the build of the Turtle Beach HPA2's but better. On the sound front they definately bring out the mids and hi's, but I noticed right away there wasn't much on the bass front even with the same EQ-ing I used on the RX700's. Now the DX3's are 90 ohms compared to the 700's 48ohms (iirc), so they are a tad harder to drive. Frankly I feel this is the design of the DX3's, they're meant for more detail to be brought out and that does mean attenuating the bass down a bit.
On the gaming front they have a larger soundstage than the RX700's, placement seems a little better, but not leaps and bounds. But overall they sound extremely good, but at this point I don't feel they were worth the retail price necessarily. Though many will definately enjoy them, and in fact I do...what suprised me most after getting these was just how good the RX700's truly are. TBH, save your money and try the RX700 first, both are good, but at least to me the 700's are easier and more enjoyable to listen to, even if less comfortable. One last note is that they leak more sound due to the cloth earpads, more comfort must mean more sound leak, oh well I still enjoy them! But when it comes down to just grabbing a pair of headphones to use, I reach for the RX700's almost every time.
Summary: Very nice pair of headphones, not quite worth the money imo, but they bring out a lot of detail are very enjoyable for gaming, extremely comfortable for many hours of use. Wait till you can find them for around $70-80 imo.
Now I've tried more than I've purchased including a few more plantronics, turtle beaches, logitechs, skull candy, bose, sony, etc...but I really only wanted to comment on the ones I owned and had a decent amount of use on. I hope this thread grows and can help many others while in search of something new, I may change the format to add more info/links, I haven't decided yet, but I figured I'd get the ball rollin and see what you guys come up with, what are you using? How do you like it? What else have you used/owned? Post it up here!
Denon AH-D2000 Headphones - -
The Good:
- Extremely Comfortable
- Nice Build Quality
- Well defined on all channels
- Can provide amazing bass with plenty of depth and punch
- Well driven off of a regular sound card or sound card w/headphone amp
- Best closed can I've used in movies, music and gaming
- No need for CMMS-3D, stereo mode works amazingly well..better sound stage and quality over all previous headphones
- At $200+, I feel they're overpriced for what they provide overall, it's more about comfort, and a little extra in all areas...but at the same time is sweeeet
- Need to mess with more stuff to get games, music and teamspeak to work well together
- Not a true 5.1 may be a con for some, also seems to perform in CMMS-3D worse than previous heapdhones.
- Honestly, the JVC HARX700's are a close competitor...if you spend a little to mod the 700's...while the D2000's are amazing, they're not +$170 amazing.
Well I loved the DX3's comfort and overall higher quality sound, but loved the RX700's value and serious and punchy bass with an overall good sound...but I wanted both. I now realize that will cost over $200 new, a little under used. But...is it an amazing experience...at least to me. I'm no audiophile, but I really enjoy something that can provide what I'm looking for, and that responds well to my setup. Granted I have a sound card with a heapdhone amp built-in...it's not the best but was much, much less than any close competitor at the time I purchased it. Either rate, the Auzen Forte is great for all I do...plus it was affordable...yet could better push my headphones via amp without needing an external amp that was uber expensive and more clutter. For me it works well, for some, a true amp will definitely win, and others on-board is as good as they'll ever go.
Onto the headphones, they're definitely upscale. They feel better, higher quality overall, they use a separate wire for each can, a thick main cable with plenty of length for routing, and overall impressed me. I try them on...seeing the pleather and expecing an RX-700 type experience..I was surprised...they were MORE comfortable than my DX3's...something I really didn't expect. Then I fire up some tunes, set my basic EQ setup (heavy bass, slight bump on 2-4k, and flat on the rest) and was blown away. They don't hit quite as hard as the 700's..but hits hard and has a much lower, more realistic bass. Plus clear mids and hi's was exactly what I was looking for. Too bad it cost more than the previous two headphones new, combined...for a used pair of these. But hell they sound great.
So I hop into a game, CMMS-3d on..ready to go..had to turn up TS a little and winamp ( like to run tunes while gaming and bs-ing). I was not too impressed...it wasn't horrible..but placement seemed a little off and the sounds were just odd in tone. So I turned of CMMS-3d, left windows in 5.1, game in 5.1 and Control Panel in Headphone mode, and was amazed. The soundstage kicked ass for a closed can...blew away both the DX3's and RX700's, yet none are crappy...and all were better to my ears than pretty much every gaming headset I've ever tried. Racing, Strategy, FPS area ll genres I "primarily" play...though not much beyond any 3 of them. Needless to say I gotta say this pair of headphones is amazing to my ears driven by my setup. Many say they're bass heavy, but imo that's with a good amp...even a setup like mine needs EQ to extract bass from these or any headphone/headset I've used. But I can get more bass than I'd ever want really easily that goes very, very loud and low.
Summary: Best pair of headphones I've used yet, gaming rocks, comfortable, great sound, great bass, easy to tune with EQ, a lot of good...but at the end of the day...they need to be cheaper because the RX700's do a bang-up job competing. But while the Denon's may be a "little" better in all areas, it's a noticable improvement and a much more refined sound, along with a larger sound stage for gaming. If you got money to blow get these, if you are just getting into headphones for headsets...start out cheaper, especially if you don't have a sound card yet. Get the RX700 and an X-Fi Xtreme Music or Audio or similar in another brand that has a solid EQ, feature set and output level, or if you have bucks and want good sound a better Auzen or Asus with an integrated headphone amp or dedicated amp using digital out from on-board with these headphones and you'll be set for a long time to come...but you will pay for it dearly (imo, there are some uber expensive headphones, cards and amps...this is more for the mainstream gamer...and for that my setup imo is higher end...$100+ sound card and $200+ pair of headphones is hella expensive...that's half a solid budget PC gaming build!).
Grizzly Buds Ear Buds
(Formerly Ironbuds, successful Kickstarter for the most part)
The Good:
- Affordable @ $35.
- Modular, so you can replace either bud or the cable easily.
- Replacement parts fairly priced.
- Easy to drive.
- Great bass.
- Decent mids and treble.
- Sounds great out MP3 players and dedicated amps.
- Cable keeps kinks from shipping for a long time.
- Strong chemical smell for weeks after new.
- Company not well known, and so-so customer service previous to Grizzly Buds.
- Limited soundstage (par for the course with this design).
The Review:
I backed the original Ironbuds and received my cheaply painted wood encased pair that came with adapters, extra buds, tips, and a case. Was blown away by the bass they produced, but they always lacked a clear midrange and treble was just okay. They made good buds for workouts because they were modular and came apart under accidents. But only about a year in the cable had a seperation at the left connector and when I tried to order a new cable they were out of stock and could only tell me they were waiting on suppliers. Not very impressed, but at least they replied.
Enter the Grizzly Buds in 2014, and they seem to be trying to change face. The new model has aluminum housings, and much higher quality standards for near the same price, without the extras of course. I haven't needed to order any spare parts, everything seems much better built and more solid though. The sound improved tremendously.
One thing both pairs have in common? They're easy to drive! Every device from smartphones to my little Sansa MP3 player to my Aune T1 dac/amp, to my Denon AVR-1613 receiver, they scale well. The Grizzly Buds scale much much better though.
The bass, as much as your ear drums and EQ can handle. I've tried to find the end or limits...without too much permanent damage and haven't found it. Do be warned, you will reach a point where the bass starts to overpower the rest of it before you find clipping...at least that's my findings. The mids and treble are so much better than the Ironbuds that its almost astounding. One will toss those first gen units after listening to these.
I've mostly listened to sub-$100 buds, and these compete with all of them to me. The buds are large and heavy, but sound great. I was even impressed with how well they were for gaming, the soundstage is clearly limited but it pulls out the excitement of all the aural goodness that modern games provide. Which is nice if you have a significant other that hates hearing your music and games or you prefer isolation.
On that note, isolation is great too, sure with no volume you can hear someone you have to pay more attention because it will be muted as most ear buds do. Honestly I'm glad I gave these guys a second shot, these earbuds have been fantastic, durable, and strong. They have complemented my full size headphones greatly and are my go-to when I want the best sound I can have without big ass headphones on my dome. Sure I could likely find better if I really wanted to look and had the money, but with these I'm content.
Summary: Good and cheap if you're willing to take a risk on an unknown name.
HiFiMan HE-400
The Good:
- One of the most affordable planar magnetic headphones.
- Very well built, tough, durable, feel almost industrial.
- Detachable cable.
- One of the bassiest open headphones I've ever heard!
- Really benefit from amplification and EQ.
- Pleather and Velour pads available.
- Premium sounds that rivals much more expensive headphones.
- Amazing speed and seperation of instruments in music or sounds in games due to planar technology.
- Did I mention the amazing bass?
- Clear, crisp and energetic mid and treble. Brings out new details in every sound played.
- Amazing soundstage, games like Elite Dangerous really benefit from this, so does music.
- Heavy, and can be uncomfortable after a couple hours or so.
- Extremely open for open headphones, no isolation, at all, whatsoever.
- I dislike the mini-ST style cable connections at each cup. But it is effective.
- Harder to drive than many other headphones, especially if you expect decent bass response an amp is required.
The Review:
Well I bought these in December 2013, and have loved them ever since. Best $300+ headphone I've ever owned or listened to. Just been blown away by the planar magnetic experience. The speed of the drivers, the response, the clarity and detail all just amazing. Makes my D2000's feel lazy, makes everything else seem a little shrouded.
While some complain of the weight, I never really minded it and the memory foam pad on the headband was okay...though the newer strap design on the 400i and 560 is MUCH more comfortable. The earpads from those headphones will transfer to these and many report massively improved comfort, some also buy a snap-on headband pad from Amazon to increase comfort.
When I first listened to these, I pretty much HAD to listen to my entire music collection all over again. It sounded like I had missed so much...like all my songs were new. Sounds in games I never noticed. Soundstage that was wide and vast, yet crisp and focused. The bass, while not as low as the D2000's, the bass seems to have more punch and still reaches very very low. Doesn't ever overpower the rest. Vocals and instruments sound amazing, as do gunshots and explosions and the amazing ship noises in Elite Dangerous and Star Citizen. Battles in SupCom or PA are truly epic and vast. Movies are also amazing.
The caveat? Open headphones are for limited applications. I've listened to these HE-400's almost daily since I bought them, and they are in great shape. The painted "L" on the left adjuster faded off almost right away but the R has remained. Beyond that, I had a cracked cable shield that was replaced under warranty, and the longest period I went in between listening to these. Living with someone whom is noise sensitive, especially when they're trying to sleep and I'm only 10 feet away means I can't enjoy these at a comfortable volume. These are best when you have the house to yourself or the others don't mind what you're listening to you. It will be loud outside and inside of these phones. The only isolation you'll get from these when listening to them is volume. Beyond there there's a couple of foam pieces a metal grid and the planar membrane and magnets separating you from the outside.
I have sadly decided to sell these because I cannot enjoy them as much as I wanted to, except for as I write this because everyone's gone and my Aune T1 is warmed up!
I will miss these headphones and look forward to finding one with isolation that can reproduce even 2/3 the sound these did. While I still enjoy my D2000's, they really do pale in comparison to these. Really everything else I've listened to or owned has paled in comparison to these. The 400i's are supposed to be better, more comfortable, easier to drive and lighter, but with less bass. Ymmv.
From what I've found, which my experience and reach is limited due to budget and where I live, these are the best headphones in this price-range if you can be alright with the open design. I consider myself a basshead still, not as hardcore as I once was but these produce more than I need and are easy to EQ up for that need. These also are more sensitive to different DACs and AMPs than I was used to. These show the most notable difference between the Aune T1 and Denon AVR-1613. While the T1 hit a little harder, the Denon reached lower and sounded smoother overall. Was an interesting find. Enjoy losing your free time if you have a large music collection, you'll want to hear it all. Be warned, crappy quality will sound crappy as these headphones expose everything. Still worth every penny.
Summary: Amazing experience. If you can find comfort with them, they're worth it!
AKG K553 Pro - - Link 1 - Link 2 - Link 3
The Good:
- Easy to adjust and lightweight means they're easy to make comfortable.
- Large cushions with large opening for big ears like mine equals more comfort.
- Responds very nicely to amplification and equalization. If you want more bass, it is easy to find.
- Clear and open sound, very surprising for a closed headphone.
- Excellent passive isolation, better than any other closed can I've ever owned.
- Massdrop prices insanely good, still going in 2016 too! But even MSRP for these is absolutely worth it.
- Easy enough to drive on portable devices too.
- Replaceable ear pads.
- One of the few headphones I can enjoy w/o EQ. The mids and treble are very enjoyable with an open presence.
- Easy to get all the bass you need with amplification and EQ-ing.
The Bad:
- Thin padding on top can cause some slight pain if adjusted too tight, some folks feel the need to slightly bend the frame inward to allow for more pressure on the cups. This will improve bass quantity.
- Does not feature a detachable cable like some other strong contenders in its price range do.
- Can sound flat and empty without EQ, barely any bass.
- If you want to replace the factory pads you gotta contact Harmon-Kardon support as of 4/2016.
The Review:
Where to start...I pretty much covered some important points above. These are very enjoyable for closed cans...I had to give up my favored pair of HE400's due to the noisier environment I was in. I needed something closed, fast, clear and capable of decent bass. I searched high and low, even tried a $400 pair of Oppo PM-3's factory direct. They were good, but not $400 good to me and didn't fit my needs nor comfort level.
I kept passing the Massdrop on these AKG K553's and I had missed and at one point regretted missing the AKG 7XX deal until I couldn't listen to open-backs anymore. I decided for the price ($120 at the time of drop), I'd bite and resell if I didn't enjoy them. Well they're still on my head and I just ordered a spare pair off the most recent Massdrop...the fifth drop this pair has seen on Massdrop since launching last April/May.
For the price I am amazed and content. They sound great and so much more open than they should...while still being able to keep an amazing level of passive noise isolation. Though they don't clamp too tight on your head that can be adjusted by slightly bending the head band...frankly after letting the pads wear-in a bit I feel they're plenty fine.
These are also very easy to fit for comfort in my opinion. Which helps greatly with the sound...even allowing some tuning. Tilt the cup forward and you'll get more mid and treble and lowered bass...tilt back to reverse the effect.
While being easy to drive from my cell phone and Sansa MP3 player, they really shine being powered from my Aune T1 with a bassier EQ tune. The only range really lacking without EQ is bass...and honestly this is the only headphone I can actually listen to and enjoy without EQ-ing. Because the mid and treble have some meat and depth and are fun to enjoy. Add bass, and you can easily keep that and add some thump and boom.
These headphones will vibrate on your head too...I've yet to find them distort either. They will crank very loud and also are able to run nice and quiet while being clear.
I enjoy gaming with these, and really enjoy it. The imaging is very good for the games I play the immersion is very much there. Music sounds amazing, but crappy recordings are like the HE400's and will be rougher...but the K553 Pro's are a little more forgiving being less analytical.
Overall, after months and months with these K553's I'm extremely content and feel no need to upgrade. They have the right kind(s) of bass and sound for me, easy to tune for different needs, comfortable, lightweight and affordable. The only other headphones I purchased spares of were my JVC HA-RX700s (sold the backup pair after 7-8 years on my shelf in the package...original pair still going strong), Sony XB-500's (kids use one pair, she has the other pair), and now these.
I cannot recommend these enough for someone wanting more without spending an arm and a leg. Will these beat $400-500 headphones? Likely not...but they won't beat up your wallet either. For what they can provide with the crisp and floaty treble, clear and accurate mids and very capable thuderous-when-equalized-and-amped bass...in audio alone they win. In comfort they win again, and then isolation too...top notch. These aren't for everyone, but for me they did what I needed...replaced my HE-400's with isolation, without losing all the speed and detail my other headphones did. Winning!
Now replacing the ear pads is a different story, I searched high and low before contacting Harmon support...only to wait several days for a response. The cost was around $34 shipped for a replacement pair. They are purchased individually. I bought spares just to have...my original pads are still in excellent shape with no sign of giving out at all. Harmon support was easy to work with and easy to order from, albeit there was a shipping mistake and they sent one wrong pad (doh!), they immediately replied to my contact and worked to make it right. Better than I can say for other vendors I've purchased various products from.
The hinges also turn 180 degrees which allow these to lay flat...I do this every day when I'm done listening to them..and the hinges are solid, no sign of give. Same with the frame and the whole kit...solid and feels well built and engineered. I have no worries of these breaking or failing any day soon. But should they...my spare pair would be here soon!
My worry? She will finally try them out and find she really likes them...the real reason I have a spare pair!
Summary: Excellent value on Massdrop, excellent sub-$200 headphone period. If you want an open sounding, closed headphone that has far better than average isolation...look no further. If you don't mind playing with an EQ to get the sound you seek, these are an excellent option!
Now I've tried more than I've purchased including a few more plantronics, turtle beaches, logitechs, skull candy, bose, sony, etc...but I really only wanted to comment on the ones I owned and had a decent amount of use on. I hope this thread grows and can help many others while in search of something new, I may change the format to add more info/links, I haven't decided yet, but I figured I'd get the ball rollin and see what you guys come up with, what are you using? How do you like it? What else have you used/owned? Post it up here!
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Last edited: