You know, I've always had this thought about BF3 and now hopefully I can get some closure on it now that Wrigley's comment made me remember:
Does anybody know exactly how the Knifing Mechanics work in this game???
A little background: I have over 500 knife kills. I'm not really asking out of ignorance, more out of frustration.
- Why exactly is it that I can walk up behind somebody, get a dogtag knife kill with the "F" key (currently bound to the side of my mouse, as it should be) and then suddenly enter an invisible 50/50 coin toss deciding if I'll come out of the animation armed with my Knife or with my Weapon?! You have to be facing and in range of the models "sweet spot". Crosshairs have to be placed correctly.
- Why exactly is it that I can walk up behind somebody, get a dogtag knife kill with the "F" key and then suddenly enter an invisible lockdown mode where I can no longer get a knife kill with the "F" key without switching weapons at least twice?! Cool down period.
- Why exactly is it that I can walk up behind somebody, get a dogtag knife kill with the "F" key, come out of the animation with my Knife armed, have my Knife arm raise onscreen when I approach another target from behind, yet Left Click refuses to do anything?! I'm gonna attest this to a ghosting. When this has happen to me its due to keyboard ghosting.
- Why when I bring the enemy close right before stabbing them, I don't have short-range VOIP in order to whisper "I'm Batman" into their ear before I make them an unknown soldier casualty! Reayth wrote a very angry letter to DICE bitching about the lack of proximity talk in BF3 for this exact reason.
As an intelligent adult gamer, I can understand even a little cooldown period for the knifing animations so that you can't just Alien vs Predator your way through a 4 man squad in 7 seconds. (Gods forbid BF becomes even more Modern Warfarish than it already is!) What I can't understand is the huge variability in what happens between getting a knife kill and what happens immediately afterward.
Inquiring minds must know!~