Seagate Hit with Class Action Lawsuit over High HDD Failure Rates

ERazer · Feb 2, 2016

funny never had problems with seagate, prolly lucky :laugh:

Batou1986 · Feb 2, 2016

Confirming what I already knew

Jism · Feb 2, 2016

Ubersonic said:
Erm, so the lawsuit has no actual evidence/data to support it then? lol.

Backblaze are a bargain basement data storage company, they build file servers out of consumer HDDs and pack them into densely populated homemade enclosures that starve them of air and run ridiculously hot, their data on failure rates is no more relevant to the consumer than McLarens failure rate of Honda engines in Formula one.

All their data shows is that Seagate's consumer drives are more likely to die if subjected to stupid levels of torture which are completely incomparable to consumer usage.

Cool story, but i dont think this is true. I used to run seagate for a pretty amount of years and i can tell you the following things.

- They fail for no reason, i.e firmware broken, PCB damaged
- Always kept under low temperature conditions (less then 40 degrees operation and still failing)

I had a small business going with HDD recovery. Guess what the highest amount of disks purely by brand where? Seagate. For no reason a corrupt firmware in 8 out of 10 occasions. Sometimes a burned PCB or in worst case serious damage to heads / platter / disk itself.

Conclusion: to my opinion seagate used to produce quality drives, but the last couple of years (< 8 ) they are producing discs that have an high unusual outtage.

Yes warranty and all is included whenever a disk fails, but recovery services from seagate still costs money. And the hassle you have to get your data back...

lately i've bin buying samsung HDD's for storage. Some of them are older then 4 years and still happily running. There are better HDD manufacturers out there and seagate does not belong anymore to that.

Rowsol · Feb 2, 2016

newtekie1 said:
A better source of failure rates is this. They actually track consumer return rates. And the reality is they are pretty close together.

Thanks for the link! Interesting, it shows Seagate with the least amount of returns.

PP Mguire · Feb 2, 2016

Since 2014 I've been buying HGST but I have 12 Seagate drives that still run 24/7 without issue. The Backblaze article is bullshit and several tech sites have proved why. Little Google shows this.
I even have one of the famous 1.5TB 7200.11 drives and it works.

FordGT90Concept · Feb 2, 2016

I haven't really noticed a high failure rate from any brand. Granted, I keep my HDDs well ventilated.

myworldoftech · Feb 2, 2016

I just had a 3TB seagate fail on me a few days ago. At work most of the 3TB Seagates have failed or developed bad sectors in under a year. There is a reason drives are now being spec'd for "desktop" use and not 24/7. Limited poh and limited writes even.

The 4TB seem to be better from what ive read online. I have a few of those (knock on wood). I will get rid of all my Seagate 3TB in my File Server and just keep as emergency drives now.

It could be just that model. But then Seagate has a history of particular models with serious to critical issues. Maybe a firmware update could help.

On the other hand I have 3 Barracuda LP 2TB which I used for a year then applied a firmware update to it and they are all still going strong after 8+ years. Granted I only power it up to get data now.

Its all about money. Why make a drive that lasts forever like the good ole days. Planned obsolesence I say!

Deleted member 97545 · Feb 2, 2016

Guess WD will be sued next?

Squuiid · Feb 2, 2016

Jack1n said:
I actually found WD to be most reliable, followed by Hitachi and with Seagate being the absolutely worst.

+1
Spot on.

johnspack · Feb 3, 2016

Think most of us already knew this... why I don't have 3tb Seagates.....

FordGT90Concept · Feb 3, 2016

I have two, neither have failed.

johnspack · Feb 3, 2016

I'll pray for you! Seriously, just buy a Toshiba ect next time... reduces stress....

Jetster · Feb 3, 2016

I had three 3tb drives. No issues. But I sell my drives every three to four years

johnspack · Feb 3, 2016

I tend to run them until they die... I just threw out 3 Seagate 320gig drives that ran for 9 years in several of my boxes. I'm hoping there newer drives are better... who knows. But I'm not taking the chance with any of my newer drives.

R-T-B · Feb 3, 2016

johnspack said:
I tend to run them until they die... I just threw out 3 Seagate 320gig drives that ran for 9 years in several of my boxes. I'm hoping there newer drives are better... who knows. But I'm not taking the chance with any of my newer drives.

9 years isn't bad at all man.

johnspack · Feb 3, 2016

Heh, nope, not at all....

rtwjunkie · Feb 3, 2016

This is obviously not a Seagate fan post, because look at my specs: WD. But this lawsuit is utter bunk. They are pointing to the Backblaze testing. We had a whole thread on them last year in here, and it's not a "cool story." They actually are running their servers on consumer HDD of all types that are being run under conditions they were never designed to run, because their asses are too cheap to buy enterprise drives designed for the job.

Seagate is being given a bad rap here. They've never been my preference, but it's just a personal thing. I don't believe them to be any better or worse than WD.

EarthDog · Feb 3, 2016

Ubersonic said:
It's not really that simple, the numbers don't lie but the context does. To use a hypothetical example, imagine two watches, one can survive being submerged in water to 50 feet, the other can survive being submerged in water to 50,000 feet, that means if they are used by divers then the will be a big disparity in the failure rate, however if they are used normally by the general public then nobody will see a real difference.

That's effectively the situation here, all the drives are consumer level drives yet they are being subjected to a ridiculous amount of abuse, far beyond what any enterprise drive would normally be subjected to. The extra failure rate of the Seagate drives is irrelevant because it's not a situation any of the drives will ever encounter, it's an artificial situation created by Backblazes greed.

Thanks isn't enough...

QFT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

PP Mguire · Feb 3, 2016

Forgot to add, they've been known to use refurb drives too.

Haytch · Feb 4, 2016

Currently running 23x 2Tb Samsung drives since 2007. Never had a problem with any of them.

All Seagate and WD drives i have purchased since 2005 have failed including 4x Seagate 8Tb Archive drives.
All drives are read only once they have been filled up and are accessed on average 10 times a day.
I am still running a single WD drive from 2014, which is pretty much close to death.

All Seagate and WD external drives ever puchased by myself or a customer ended up being a refurbished drive. In most cases of 2Tb external drives, it was a failed 3Tb drive slapped into an enclosure and marked as 2Tb.

Back in the day, when WD got flooded and the prices went up, the boss decided to purchase as many external drives that were still being sold by retailers such as Officeworks at their lowest price around Australia, remove the enclosures and sell them as internal drives for customers computer systems. Every single drive ended up being a refurbished drive, around 10,000+ units.

My current brand of choice is Hitachi, but my advice is to ALWAYS have a backup of your important data regardless of brand.

Patriot · Feb 4, 2016

bubbly1724 said:
Guess WD will be sued next?

iirc that is just the raw numbers... Seagate numbers went down because they didn't replace the failed seagate drivers with seagates... and the WD drives are older and gradually starting to fail...
Hitachi isn't made since they were bought by WD... so those are 2010 drives...
HGST weren't being bought because they are expensive... small samples size on those.

Toshiba has the tools from hitachi due to WD purchase of hitachi.
I tend to buy toshiba, every seagate drive I have bought has died... ever WD red drive I have bought has died.

Patriot · Feb 4, 2016

rtwjunkie said:
This is obviously not a Seagate fan post, because look at my specs: WD. But this lawsuit is utter bunk. They are pointing to the Backblaze testing. We had a whole thread on them last year in here, and it's not a "cool story." They actually are running their servers on consumer HDD of all types that are being run under conditions they were never designed to run, because their asses are too cheap to buy enterprise drives designed for the job.

Seagate is being given a bad rap here. They've never been my preference, but it's just a personal thing. I don't believe them to be any better or worse than WD.

It is just an uninformed post. Most enterprise customers.... don't pay for enterprise drives SMB do.
Doesn't change the fact that seagate drives are fragile. WD green/red are shit.

The volume requirements of the industry require cheaper drives where failure is the norm.

newtekie1 · Feb 4, 2016

Patriot said:
iirc that is just the raw numbers...

Look at the left side of the graph, it is failure percentage, not raw numbers. The Seagate numbers went down because they stopped buying the models they found out had problems with their RAID controllers.

rtwjunkie said:
They actually are running their servers on consumer HDD of all types that are being run under conditions they were never designed to run, because their asses are too cheap to buy enterprise drives designed for the job.

Plus what they call a failure isn't actually the drive failing, it is just the RAID controller saying the drive is failed. The drive could still be perfectly functional.

rtwjunkie · Feb 4, 2016

Patriot said:
It is just an uninformed post. Most enterprise customers.... don't pay for enterprise drives SMB do.
Doesn't change the fact that seagate drives are fragile. WD green/red are shit.

Uninformed, huh? :rolleyes:

I suggest you look into the stories that have been done on their use of anything available. There are a number of them. Backblaze's method of supplying drives to their servers is way outside the norm.

I'll leave some of it up. The Backblaze story is real. They even admitted to the internal report which leaked. What is questionable is there are no set testing standards to do a study. This is outlined quite well here:
http://www.enterprisestorageforum.c...ng-a-disk-drive-how-not-to-do-research-1.html
And for a well-written synopsis:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/02/17/backblaze_how_not_to_evaluate_disk_reliability/
And even Tom's has a good evaluation of the lawsuit and then deeper background into the Backblaze figures in relation to it:
http://www.tomshardware.com/news/seagate-hdd-failure-lawsuit-3tb,31118.html
Tweaktown's teardown of their methods, which show the results mean nothing:
http://www.tweaktown.com/articles/6...bility-myth-the-real-story-covered/index.html

I agree Greens are fragile, if not used properly. Used in an external drive, which is not constantly accessed, ie used for storage, I have had great success with them. That is the ideal situation for their idle down. The problems with Greens most people have is they are constantly accessing them, which is usually right after it idled down, since it's a short time period for it to do so. This causes the load/unload count to rise abnormally.

My experience with Reds though is completely different than yours. I've got 9 Reds in my home server that run 24/7, and have been for over 3 years straight. Yes, they are coming up on their max hours, but otherwise, not a thing is wrong with them.

Processor	R9 5950x
Motherboard	Asus x570 Crosshair VIII Formula
Cooling	EK 360mm AIO D-RGB
Memory	G.Skill Trident Z Neo 2x16gb (CL16@3800MHz)
Video Card(s)	PNY GeForce RTX 3090 24GB
Storage	Samsung 970 EVO Plus 1TB NVMe \| Intel 660p 2TB NVMe
Display(s)	Acer Predator XB323QK 4K 144Hz
Case	Corsair 5000D Airflow
Audio Device(s)	Objective2 Amp/DAC \| GoXLR \| AKG K612PRO \| Beyerdynamic DT880\| Rode Pod Mic
Power Supply	Corsair AX 850w
Mouse	Razer DeathAdder Elite V2
Keyboard	Corsair K95 Platinum RGB "Cherry MX Brown"
VR HMD	Oculus Rift
Software	Window 11 Pro

Processor	Ryzen 5900X
Motherboard	ASUS Prime X470 Pro
Cooling	Arctic liquid freezer II 240
Memory	2 x 16 Gb Gskill Trident Z 3600 Mhz
Video Card(s)	MSI Ventus 3060 Ti OC
Storage	Samsung 960 EVO 500 Gb / 860 EVO 1 Tb
Display(s)	Dell S2719DGF
Case	Lian Li Lancool II Mesh
Audio Device(s)	Soundblaster Z
Power Supply	Corsair RM850x
Mouse	Logitech G703
Keyboard	Logitech G513
Software	Win 11

Processor	12100
Video Card(s)	1650 Super
Case	Coolermaster Ammo 533
Mouse	G403
Keyboard	Sidewinder x4

System Name	Univac SLI Edition
Processor	Intel Xeon 1650 V3 @ 4.2GHz
Motherboard	eVGA X99 FTW K
Cooling	EK Supremacy EVO, Swiftech MCP50x, Alphacool NeXXos UT60 360, Black Ice GTX 360
Memory	2x16GB Corsair Vengeance LPX 3000MHz
Video Card(s)	Nvidia Titan X Tri-SLI w/ EK Blocks
Storage	HyperX Predator 240GB PCI-E, Samsung 850 Pro 512GB
Display(s)	Dell UltraSharp 34" Ultra-Wide (U3415W) / (Samsung 48" Curved 4k)
Case	Phanteks Enthoo Pro M Acrylic Edition
Audio Device(s)	Sound Blaster Z
Power Supply	Thermaltake 1350watt Toughpower Modular
Mouse	Logitech G502
Keyboard	CODE 10 keyless MX Clears
Software	Windows 10 Pro

System Name	BY-2021
Processor	AMD Ryzen 7 5800X (65w eco profile)
Motherboard	MSI B550 Gaming Plus
Cooling	Scythe Mugen (rev 5)
Memory	2 x Kingston HyperX DDR4-3200 32 GiB
Video Card(s)	AMD Radeon RX 7900 XT
Storage	Samsung 980 Pro, Seagate Exos X20 TB 7200 RPM
Display(s)	Nixeus NX-EDG274K (3840x2160@144 DP) + Samsung SyncMaster 906BW (1440x900@60 HDMI-DVI)
Case	Coolermaster HAF 932 w/ USB 3.0 5.25" bay + USB 3.2 (A+C) 3.5" bay
Audio Device(s)	Realtek ALC1150, Micca OriGen+
Power Supply	Enermax Platimax 850w
Mouse	Nixeus REVEL-X
Keyboard	Tesoro Excalibur
Software	Windows 10 Home 64-bit
Benchmark Scores	Faster than the tortoise; slower than the hare.

Seagate Hit with Class Action Lawsuit over High HDD Failure Rates

ERazer

Batou1986

Jism

Rowsol

PP Mguire

FordGT90Concept

"I go fast!1!11!1!"

myworldoftech

Deleted member 97545

Guest

Squuiid

johnspack

Here For Good!

FordGT90Concept

"I go fast!1!11!1!"

johnspack

Here For Good!

Jetster

johnspack

Here For Good!

R-T-B

johnspack

Here For Good!

rtwjunkie

PC Gaming Enthusiast

EarthDog

PP Mguire

Haytch

Patriot

Patriot

newtekie1

Semi-Retired Folder

rtwjunkie

PC Gaming Enthusiast

System Name	System2 Blacknet , System1 Blacknet2
Processor	System2 Threadripper 1920x, System1 2699 v3
Motherboard	System2 Asrock Fatality x399 Professional Gaming, System1 Asus X99-A
Cooling	System2 Noctua NH-U14 TR4-SP3 Dual 140mm fans, System1 AIO
Memory	System2 64GBS DDR4 3000, System1 32gbs DDR4 2400
Video Card(s)	System2 GTX 980Ti System1 GTX 970
Storage	System2 4x SSDs + NVme= 2.250TB 2xStorage Drives=8TB System1 3x SSDs=2TB
Display(s)	1x27" 1440 display 1x 24" 1080 display
Case	System2 Some Nzxt case with soundproofing...
Audio Device(s)	Asus Xonar U7 MKII
Power Supply	System2 EVGA 750 Watt, System1 XFX XTR 750 Watt
Mouse	Logitech G900 Chaos Spectrum
Keyboard	Ducky
Software	Archlinux, Manjaro, Win11 Ent 24h2
Benchmark Scores	It's linux baby!

System Name	Juliette // My HTPC
Processor	Intel i7 9700K // AMD Ryzen 5 5600G
Motherboard	ASUS Prime Z390X-A // ASRock B550 ITX-AC
Cooling	Noctua NH-U12 Black // Stock
Memory	Corsair DDR4 3600 32gb //G.SKILL Trident Z Royal Series 16GB (2 x 8GB) 3600
Video Card(s)	ASUS RTX4070 OC// ASUS RTX 4060 OC
Storage	Samsung 970 EVO NVMe 1Tb, Intel 665p Series M.2 2280 1TB // Samsung 1Tb SSD
Display(s)	ASUS VP348QGL 34" Quad HD 3440 x 1440 // 55" LG 4K SK8000 Series
Case	Seasonic SYNCRO Q7// Silverstone Granada GD05
Audio Device(s)	Focusrite Scarlett 4i4 // HDMI to Samsung HW-R650 sound bar
Power Supply	Seasonic SYNCRO 750 W // CORSAIR Vengeance 650M
Mouse	G903 and a Master Mouse MM710/No mouse, MS game copntroller
Keyboard	EVGA / Logitech K400
Software	Windows 11 Pro // Windows 10 Pro

System Name	Pioneer
Processor	Ryzen R9 9950X
Motherboard	GIGABYTE Aorus Elite X670 AX
Cooling	Noctua NH-D15 + A whole lotta Sunon and Corsair Maglev blower fans...
Memory	64GB (4x 16GB) G.Skill Flare X5 @ DDR5-6000 CL30
Video Card(s)	XFX RX 7900 XTX Speedster Merc 310
Storage	Intel 905p Optane 960GB boot, +2x Crucial P5 Plus 2TB PCIe 4.0 NVMe SSDs
Display(s)	55" LG 55" B9 OLED 4K Display
Case	Thermaltake Core X31
Audio Device(s)	TOSLINK->Schiit Modi MB->Asgard 2 DAC Amp->AKG Pro K712 Headphones or HDMI->B9 OLED
Power Supply	FSP Hydro Ti Pro 850W
Mouse	Logitech G305 Lightspeed Wireless
Keyboard	WASD Code v3 with Cherry Green keyswitches + PBT DS keycaps
Software	Gentoo Linux x64 / Windows 11 Enterprise IoT 2024

Processor	Core i9-9900k
Motherboard	ASRock Z390 Phantom Gaming 6
Cooling	All air: 2x140mm Fractal exhaust; 3x 140mm Cougar Intake; Enermax ETS-T50 Black CPU cooler
Memory	32GB (2x16) Mushkin Redline DDR-4 3200
Video Card(s)	ASUS RTX 4070 Ti Super OC 16GB
Storage	1x 1TB MX500 (OS); 2x 6TB WD Black; 1x 2TB MX500; 1x 1TB BX500 SSD; 1x 6TB WD Blue storage (eSATA)
Display(s)	Infievo 27" 165Hz @ 2560 x 1440
Case	Fractal Design Define R4 Black -windowed
Audio Device(s)	Soundblaster Z
Power Supply	Seasonic Focus GX-1000 Gold
Mouse	Coolermaster Sentinel III (large palm grip!)
Keyboard	Logitech G610 Orion mechanical (Cherry Brown switches)
Software	Windows 10 Pro 64-bit (Start10 & Fences 3.0 installed)

System Name	_Speedforce_ (Successor to Strike-X, 4LI3NBR33D-H, Core-iH7 & Nemesis-H)
Processor	Intel Core i9 7980XE (Lapped) @ 5.2Ghz With XSPC Raystorm (Lapped)
Motherboard	Asus Rampage VI Extreme (XSPC Watercooled) - Custom Heatsinks (Lapped)
Cooling	XSPC Custom Water Cooling + Custom Air Cooling (From Delta 220's TFB1212GHE to Spal 30101504&5)
Memory	8x 8Gb G.Skill Trident Z RGB 4266MHz @ 4667Mhz (2x F4-4266C17Q-32GTZR)
Video Card(s)	3x Asus GTX1080 Ti (Lapped) With Customised EK Waterblock (Lapped) + Custom heatsinks (Lapped)
Storage	1x Samsung 970 EVO 2TB - 2280 (Hyper M.2 x16 Card), 7x Samsung 860 Pro 4Tb
Display(s)	6x Asus ROG Swift PG348Q
Case	Aerocool Strike X (Modified)
Audio Device(s)	Creative Sound BlasterX AE-5 & Aurvana XFi Headphones
Power Supply	2x Corsair AX1500i With Custom Sheilding, Custom Switching Unit. Braided Cables.
Mouse	Razer Copperhead + R.A.T 9
Keyboard	Ideazon Zboard + Optimus Maximus. Logitech G13.
Software	w10 Pro x64.
Benchmark Scores	pppft, gotta see it to believe it. . .

System Name	[H]arbringer
Processor	4x 61XX ES @3.5Ghz (48cores)
Motherboard	SM GL
Cooling	3x xspc rx360, rx240, 4x DT G34 snipers, D5 pump.
Memory	16x gskill DDR3 1600 cas6 2gb
Video Card(s)	blah bigadv folder no gfx needed
Storage	32GB Sammy SSD
Display(s)	headless
Case	Xigmatek Elysium (whats left of it)
Audio Device(s)	yawn
Power Supply	Antec 1200w HCP
Software	Ubuntu 10.10
Benchmark Scores	http://valid.canardpc.com/show_oc.php?id=1780855 http://www.hwbot.org/submission/2158678 http://ww

Processor	Intel Core i7 10850K@5.2GHz
Motherboard	AsRock Z470 Taichi
Cooling	Corsair H115i Pro w/ Noctua NF-A14 Fans
Memory	32GB DDR4-3600
Video Card(s)	RTX 2070 Super
Storage	500GB SX8200 Pro + 8TB with 1TB SSD Cache
Display(s)	Acer Nitro VG280K 4K 28"
Case	Fractal Design Define S
Audio Device(s)	Onboard is good enough for me
Power Supply	eVGA SuperNOVA 1000w G3
Software	Windows 10 Pro x64