- Joined
- Jul 14, 2006
- Messages
- 2,532 (0.38/day)
- Location
- People's Republic of America
System Name | It's just a computer |
---|---|
Processor | i9-14900K Direct Die |
Motherboard | MSI Z790 ACE MAX |
Cooling | 2X D5T Vario, XSPC BayRes, 2X Nemesis GTR560, NF-A14-iPPC3000PWM, NF-A14-iPPC2000PWM, IceMan DD |
Memory | TEAMGROUP FFXD548G8000HC38EDC01 |
Video Card(s) | MSI 4070 Ti Super w/Alphacool Eisblock Aurora RTX 4070TI Ventus with Backplate :13724 |
Storage | Samsung 990 PRO 1TB M.2 |
Display(s) | LG 32GK650F |
Case | Thermaltake Xaser VI |
Audio Device(s) | Auzentech X-Meridian 7.1 2G/Z-5500 |
Power Supply | Seasonic Prime PX-1300 |
Mouse | Logitech |
Keyboard | Logitech |
Software | Win11PRO |
Ofc the fines benefit the Government but it's not that Government benefits: it's that the infringing companies get penalized.
If @ all possible (via legislation, perhaps), a good chunk of such fines should be distributed to those that applied for it, via proof they were among the victims (invoices).
And subsequently, the cost of those penalties will eventually get passed on to the end consumer anyway.
I agree that repaying those actually wronged would be the fairest solution.
But you're argument is that the people that were ripped off, tax payers*, should instead pay more money in the form of taxes to pay for the imprisonment of these blue collar criminals? That doesn't make much sense to me.
The fines are a decent compromise. It takes away the thing that is currently most important to these people, their money.
However, the fines are not high enough, IMO. Samsung alone makes almost $225 Billion a year, so even if they get the maximum of $8 Billion in fines, it doesn't really deter them from continuing the practice of price fixing(obviously since this is like the 2nd or 3rd time they've been caught doing it). They need to be fined in the $100s of Billions against the company, as well as personal fines against the management people involved that is proportional to their yearly income, ~50% of their yearly income. The tiny monetary slaps on the wrist that they do right now does nothing to deter price fixing.
*The argument can be made that essentially every tax payer is a victim here, since anyone with an any modern electronic device is effectively a victim. And there likely aren't a lot of tax payers that have no modern electronic device.
How many white collar criminals are we talking about, a few dozen? A mere drop in the bucket, and, any fines would more than pay for their incarceration anyway.
You would suggest crippling fines that could potentially cause many, many workers to lose their jobs, because the company may no longer have the resources to effectively maintain their workforce?