Am I old? (rhetorical, please don't answer) But I prefer to see the game rather than graphs.
Nah, this is a bit like RGB, its fun to watch for five minutes, and then you're off doing the things you actually want to do.
At least, that's how it works for me. Stats are cool n all, but I dont play benchmarks. Any overlays and other nonsense I eventually end up disabling. I even like Nvidia's Ansel feature for example, but I still don't feel the urge to reinstall GFE just to have that available, because I hate those extra bars, the pop ups they produce, and the clutter in what is supposed to be an audiovisual experience
without crap flying across like its TV. I do use RTSS/Afterburner... with a shortcut tied to the OSD, I only pop it open if I have any sort of information need on those stats. Which is... barely.
Another thing I don't do, but did try a few times is recording gameplay. But I can see how people feel its a thing to do. The idea of 'performing' definitely shines through, I could recognize some of that buzz I felt when DJ'ing in front of crowds. Even if only a sliver of it
But maybe WE are old
I can imagine people have wildly differing playstyles altogether and there are certainly a number of game types where recording and frequent stat checking are feasible, useful, fun etc. So it IS nice to have it all one place...
But this is an MS game bar. I'll repeat that. A Microsoft. Game. Bar. Part of the same set of services that contains GameDVR. From the company that did GFWL. Need I continue. I smell a recipe for frequently returning disaster here, its not like these overlays are not full of hurdles when it comes to in-game (cheat) detection and stuff - and its not like MS has any kind of nice track record regarding cross compatiblity either with their W10 updates.
Bottom line... not even with a ten foot pole.