SSDs More Reliable than HDDs: Backblaze Study

damric · May 7, 2021

I have been using the cloud for my bulk storage for nearly a decade and SSDs as my only storage for nearly as long. Now all I use are NVMe drives.

bug · May 7, 2021

Wirko said:
For some additional fun: you want to salvage data as Windows admin, but don't have access to some user's folder. Well, you're the admin, you can add privileges to yourself ... but no, you can't because privileges are stored as NTFS metadata on the drive, and the drive is read-only.

I'm not even sure you can mount a NTFS partition as read-only. You have to work some magic first and Idk whether that works on a read-only drive.

AsRock · May 7, 2021

Nater said:
Skimmed the article and the thread. Reactions:

Duh.

Unsalvageable? When SSD's "die" from wear don't they go into a read only mode...you can get your data, you just can't write to it anymore.

And old? I think I could go out and fire up my OCZ Vertex 3 240GB SSD based system (that's been off for a good 2 years) and it would work fine. That machine is a solid 10 years old and was on nearly 24/7 for a good 8 years.

Well do not count on them being readable, none of the 3 have been readable after failing for me.

anachron said:
I think we have installed around 500-600 SSD at work, we had a single SSD failure in the last 5 years, and we are using very low priced one for working station, as the datas are on the servers anyway. In the same time we had a lot of HDD with bad sectors inducing low performances or just failing. Indeed the chance to recover the data on an HDD are higher, but the difference in reliability seems to be quite sensible from my experience.

Edit : for the record, we have around 1000 computers, so it's half HDD, half SSD in the inventory. HDD are on average older than SSD since we only buy SSD for the last 2-3years, but we still had more HDD failure in the same lifespan than SSD.

Glad for ya, just not the case for me. Kinda like different HDD brands people seem to have a go to brand and one they would keep away from.

Wirko · May 7, 2021

SSDs are highly tolerant to electrical faults using capacitor banks

Is this really a requirement for datacenter SSDs? If a major electrical failure/blackout/brownout occurs in a datacenter, I guess there would be much more to worry about than corrupt filesystems on some SSDs.

WhitetailAni · May 7, 2021

I guess that my 11-year-old Crucial M4 128GB that's on 89% life after 11 years of being a Windows boot drive is unusual? I've never had any problems with data loss on it.

bug said:
I'm not even sure you can mount a NTFS partition as read-only. You have to work some magic first and Idk whether that works on a read-only drive.

It's VERY easy. Just mount a drive in macOS as NTFS. You can't write to an NTFS drive in macOS unless you pay Paragon Software $20 for NTFS for Mac.

Minus Infinity · May 7, 2021

For my precious 4TB and growing photo collection I'm using HDD's. I have 2 sets of backup, one via NAS, one portable drive as well as having two separate computers that each have a copy of the collection. I would gladly swap to an affordable 8TB SSD but not willing to pay more than about 25% more premium. That's not going to happen for. along time, so HDD's are still important to me.

DragonFox · May 8, 2021

Wirko said:
For some additional fun: you want to salvage data as Windows admin, but don't have access to some user's folder. Well, you're the admin, you can add privileges to yourself ... but no, you can't because privileges are stored as NTFS metadata on the drive, and the drive is read-only.

Actually; clone the disk first, then manipulate the clone as necessary.

arbiter · May 8, 2021

Backblaze finds that the AFR of HDDs across brands, stands at 10.56%. In the same period, SSDs across brands lodged an AFR of a stunning 0.58%.

This study is complete trash. The fact you read the avg age column where SSD's were only 1 year old vs 4 year old HDD. That is like complaing a New car off the lot with a 4 year old car in and comparing them in maintenance costs but claiming its cheaper for 1 year old car.

claes · May 8, 2021

RealKGB said:
You can't write to an NTFS drive in macOS unless you pay Paragon Software $20 for NTFS for Mac.

NTFS 3G

FUSE extends macOS by adding support for user space file systems - osxfuse/osxfuse

github.com

Unfortunately both options are sketchy since NTFS is closed, but at least this one is free

noel_fs · May 9, 2021

well would be pretty fucking weird if they started failing within 1 year, give it 2 atleast.

ymbaja · May 9, 2021

AusWolf said:
Wait a minute... what about the column "Average age"? Does this data mean that 0.65% of SSDs failed after a year, while 6.04% of HDDs failed after 4 years of operation? That isn't really a fair comparison.

Yeah I noticed that too.. you can kinda extrapolate out that the sdds are still more reliable from the data given, but it’s sure not apples to apples.

AusWolf · May 9, 2021

ymbaja said:
Yeah I noticed that too.. you can kinda extrapolate out that the sdds are still more reliable from the data given, but it’s sure not apples to apples.

Not exactly. Just because 0.65% of SSDs failed after a year, you can't say that 0.65 x 4 = 2.6% will fail after 4 years. Might be more, might be less.

ExcuseMeWtf · May 9, 2021

AusWolf said:
Not exactly. Just because 0.65% of SSDs failed after a year, you can't say that 0.65 x 4 = 2.6% will fail after 4 years. Might be more, might be less.

If you keep failure rate constant over the years (a bit of a bold assumption), formula would for failure rate would be (1 - (1 - p)^n), where p is annual failure rate and n is number of years passed. So a little under 2.6% actually.

80251 · May 9, 2021

Nater said:
Skimmed the article and the thread. Reactions:

Duh.

Unsalvageable? When SSD's "die" from wear don't they go into a read only mode...you can get your data, you just can't write to it anymore.

And old? I think I could go out and fire up my OCZ Vertex 3 240GB SSD based system (that's been off for a good 2 years) and it would work fine. That machine is a solid 10 years old and was on nearly 24/7 for a good 8 years.

I had an NVME Crucial 250GiB SSD once, it was unfortunately installed right under my 980Ti and when it died, it died suddenly, without warning and completely. The data was inaccessible.

AusWolf · May 9, 2021

ExcuseMeWtf said:
If you keep failure rate constant over the years (a bit of a bold assumption), formula would for failure rate would be (1 - (1 - p)^n), where p is annual failure rate and n is number of years passed. So a little under 2.6% actually.

That's the problem. Failure rate isn't constant through time, therefore the data presented in the article is unreliable to base any assumption upon.

Tardian · May 10, 2021

Vanny said:
What are hard drives?

I waited but everyone missed the opportunity. What are hard drives? They contain the material in hidden files that gets you there. ;-)

Wirko · May 10, 2021

arbiter said:
This study is complete trash. The fact you read the avg age column where SSD's were only 1 year old vs 4 year old HDD. That is like complaing a New car off the lot with a 4 year old car in and comparing them in maintenance costs but claiming its cheaper for 1 year old car.

The study comes with all the details and warnings. You only get trash when you try to make a TL;DR from it.

System Name	Main
Processor	Ryzen 5950x
Motherboard	B550 PG Velocita
Cooling	Water
Memory	Ballistix
Video Card(s)	RX 6900XT
Storage	T-FORCE CARDEA A440 PRO
Display(s)	MAG401QR
Case	QUBE 500
Audio Device(s)	Logitech Z623
Power Supply	LEADEX V 1KW
Mouse	Cooler Master MM710
Keyboard	Huntsman Elite
Software	11 Pro
Benchmark Scores	https://hwbot.org/user/damric/

Processor	Intel i5-12600k
Motherboard	Asus H670 TUF
Cooling	Arctic Freezer 34
Memory	2x16GB DDR4 3600 G.Skill Ripjaws V
Video Card(s)	EVGA GTX 1060 SC
Storage	500GB Samsung 970 EVO, 500GB Samsung 850 EVO, 1TB Crucial MX300 and 2TB Crucial MX500
Display(s)	Dell U3219Q + HP ZR24w
Case	Raijintek Thetis
Audio Device(s)	Audioquest Dragonfly Red :D
Power Supply	Seasonic 620W M12
Mouse	Logitech G502 Proteus Core
Keyboard	G.Skill KM780R
Software	Arch Linux + Win10

Processor	i5-6600K
Motherboard	Asus Z170A
Cooling	some cheap Cooler Master Hyper 103 or similar
Memory	16GB DDR4-2400
Video Card(s)	IGP
Storage	Samsung 850 EVO 250GB
Display(s)	2x Oldell 24" 1920x1200
Case	Bitfenix Nova white windowless non-mesh
Audio Device(s)	E-mu 1212m PCI
Power Supply	Seasonic G-360
Mouse	Logitech Marble trackball, never had a mouse
Keyboard	Key Tronic KT2000, no Win key because 1994
Software	Oldwin

System Name	Desktop-TJ84TBK
Processor	Ryzen 5 3600
Motherboard	Asus ROG Strix B350-F Gaming
Cooling	ARCTIC Liquid Freezer II 120mm, Noctua NF-F12
Memory	B-Die 2x8GB 3200 CL14, Vengeance LPX 2x8GB 3200 CL16, OC'd to 3333 MT/s C16-16-16-32 tRC 48
Video Card(s)	PNY GTX 690
Storage	Crucial MX500 1TB, MX500 500GB, WD Blue 1TB, WD Black 2TB, WD Caviar Green 3TB, Intel Optane 16GB
Display(s)	Sceptre M25 1080p200, ASUS 1080p74, Apple Studio Display M7649 17"
Case	Rosewill CRUISER Black Gaming
Audio Device(s)	SupremeFX S1220A
Power Supply	Seasonic FOCUS GM-750
Mouse	Kensington K72369
Keyboard	Razer BlackWidow Ultimate 2013
Software	Windows 10 Home 64-bit, macOS 11.7.8
Benchmark Scores	are good

Processor	i7-13700k
Motherboard	Asus Tuf Gaming z790-plus
Cooling	Coolermaster Hyper 212 RGB
Memory	Corsair Vengeance RGB 32GB DDR5 7000mhz
Video Card(s)	Asus Dual Geforce RTX 4070 Super ( 2800mhz @ 1.0volt, ~60mhz overlock -.1volts)
Storage	1x Samsung 980 Pro PCIe4 NVme, 2x Samsung 1tb 850evo SSD, 3x WD drives, 2 seagate
Display(s)	Acer Predator XB273u 27inch IPS G-Sync 165hz
Power Supply	Corsair RMx Series RM850x (OCZ Z series PSU retired after 13 years of service)
Mouse	Logitech G502 hero
Keyboard	Logitech G710+

SSDs More Reliable than HDDs: Backblaze Study

damric

bug

AsRock

TPU addict

Wirko

WhitetailAni

Minus Infinity

DragonFox

New Member

arbiter

claes

NTFS 3G

noel_fs

ymbaja

AusWolf

ExcuseMeWtf

80251

AusWolf

Tardian

Wirko

System Name	boomer--->zoomer not your typical millenial build
Processor	i5-760 @ 3.8ghz + turbo ~goes wayyyyyyyyy fast cuz turboooooz~
Motherboard	P55-GD80 ~best motherboard ever designed~
Cooling	NH-D15 ~double stack thot twerk all day~
Memory	16GB Crucial Ballistix LP ~memory gone AWOL~
Video Card(s)	MSI GTX 970 ~~GOLDEN EDITION~~ RAWRRRRRR
Storage	500GB Samsung 850 Evo (OS X, *nix), 128GB Samsung 840 Pro (W10 Pro), 1TB SpinPoint F3 ~best in class
Display(s)	ASUS VW246H ~best 24" you've seen FULL HD 1O80PP SLAPS~
Case	FT02-W ~the W stands for white but it's brushed aluminum except for the disgusting ODD bays; cries
Audio Device(s)	A LOT
Power Supply	850W EVGA SuperNova G2 ~hot fire like champagne~
Mouse	CM Spawn ~cmcz R c00l seth mcfarlane darawss~
Keyboard	CM QF Rapid - Browns ~fastrrr kees for fstr teens~
Software	integrated into the chassis
Benchmark Scores	9999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999999

Processor	Ryzen 5700X
Motherboard	Gigabyte B550 Arous Elite V2
Cooling	Thermalright PA120
Memory	Kingston FURY Renegade 3600Mhz @ 3733 tight timings
Video Card(s)	Sapphire Pulse RX 6800
Storage	36TB
Display(s)	Samsung QN90A
Case	be quiet! Dark Base Pro 900
Audio Device(s)	Khadas Tone Pro 2, HD660s, KSC75, JBL 305 MK1
Power Supply	Coolermaster V850 Gold V2
Mouse	Roccat Burst Pro
Keyboard	Dogshit with Otemu Brown
Software	W10 LTSC 2021

System Name	Nebulon B
Processor	AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D
Motherboard	MSi PRO B650M-A WiFi
Cooling	be quiet! Dark Rock 4
Memory	2x 24 GB Corsair Vengeance DDR5-4800
Video Card(s)	AMD Radeon RX 6750 XT 12 GB
Storage	2 TB Corsair MP600 GS, 2 TB Corsair MP600 R2
Display(s)	Dell S3422DWG, 7" Waveshare touchscreen
Case	Kolink Citadel Mesh black
Audio Device(s)	Logitech Z333 2.1 speakers, AKG Y50 headphones
Power Supply	Seasonic Prime GX-750
Mouse	Logitech MX Master 2S
Keyboard	Logitech G413 SE
Software	Bazzite (Fedora Linux) KDE

System Name	Work in progress
Processor	AMD Ryzen 5 3600
Motherboard	Asus PRIME B350M-A
Cooling	Wraith Stealth Cooler, 4x140mm Noctua NF-A14 FLX 1200RPM Case Fans
Memory	Corsair 16GB (2x8GB) CMK16GX4M2A2400C14R DDR4 2400MHz Vengeance LPX DIMM
Video Card(s)	GTX 1050 2GB (for now) 3060 12GB on order
Storage	Samsung 860 EVO 500GB, Lots of HDD storage
Display(s)	32 inch 4K LG, 55 & 48 inch LG OLED, 40 inch Panasonic LED LCD
Case	Cooler Master Silencio S400
Audio Device(s)	Sound: LG Monitor Built-in speakers (currently), Mike: Marantz MaZ
Power Supply	Corsair CS550M 550W ATX Power Supply, 80+ Gold Certified, Semi-Modular Design
Mouse	Logitech M280
Keyboard	Logitech Wireless Solar Keyboard K750R (works best in summer)
VR HMD	none
Software	Microsoft Windows 10 Home 64bit OEM, Captur 1 21
Benchmark Scores	Cinebench R20: 3508 (WIP)