The thing about Aris is that I find his reviews to be overly critical over the little details.
It depends on what you perceive as a small detail. The truth is usually hidden in those details which might look small to you, but according to my expert opinion, they aren't.
Very critical is also to know what you are doing, when you conduct a PSU review and have calibrated equipment. Especially the latter can lead to highly inaccurate results. Also the more tests you conduct the more things you can find about a product. Some chose to only conduct a small number of tests, which is the easiest way. I chose to do as many as possible to have a complete picture of the product and provide accurate information to my readers.
About the Fractal Design PSUs, yes they are good and this is why they received a 3.5/5 in Tom's which is a high rating for my standards. I cannot overlook though the high OCP on all rails which can lead to serious problems, the very low efficiency with 2% load and with light loads in general, the not efficient 5VSB rail, the high inrush with 230V etc.
If all the above seem like small details to you, then clearly you need to study more on PSUs.