Mushkin XP2-6400 4GB CL4 Kit  Review 5

Mushkin XP2-6400 4GB CL4 Kit Review

Value & Conclusion »

Test Setup

Test System
CPU:Intel E6300 Conroe
1.86 GHz, 2 MB Cache
Motherboard:ASUS P5Q Intel P45
Video Card:PowerColor X800XL Pro 16 PCI-E
Hard disk:Samsung P80 80 GB
Power Supply:Ultra V-Power 450W
Software:Windows XP SP2, Catalyst 8.3

Performance & Overclocking


Mushkin has programmed the DIMMs with three SPD timings. The first to adhere to JEDEC standards at 266 and 400 MHz, while the last one is an EPP profile. As you can see the memory is set to run at 4-4-4-12-2T and 2.05V.

The first thing that was done when benchmarking this kit, it was set at the intended CL rating and the advertised voltage of 2.0V. Running the memory at this voltage worked flawlessly. To keep a common base, the CPU multiplier was lowered from 7x to 6x and the CPU to memory divider was kept at 1:1. Using a 400 MHz FSB means that the memory runs at the intended 800 MHz, while the CPU is running at an healthy overclocked speed of 2.4 GHz. The CPU manages over 3.2 GHz, so there is still plenty of overclocking headroom.

Pushing the memory at this CL rating and 2.0V, it managed to go up to 864 MHz. A very healthy overclock at default settings. Raising the voltage, we did expect to get even more out of the memory. But even with 2.4V, we only managed to tickle a few MHz extra out of the kit. Looks like it does not scale well with voltage. The next step meant lowering the voltage to 1.8V. which is default value by JEDEC standards. The memory only managed 762 MHz, but raising it to 1.9V, we were able to break the 800 MHz barrier easily. It manages just basically the same maximum speed at 1.9V as it does at 2.4V.

The next benchmark run was done at CL3-3-3-10. Starting at 1.8V and 667 MHz at 1:1 divider, yielded a booting system, which was not quite stable. Lowering the speed down to 660 MHz then translated in a rock solid system. Between 1.8 and 2.4V are only 36 MHz. This means that the memory maxes out at 696 MHz with CL3. Looks like this memory does not hold any surprises at all, which is a bit dissapointing.

The last benchmark run was done at CL5-5-5-15. This is where it really shines. Starting with 1.8V, we managed to push it all the way to 1022 MHz. This is very respectable for a 4GB kit at default JEDEC voltage. Raising the voltage to 2.0V yielded very little improvements - too little to make any real impact. Oddly enough, raising it beyond 2.0V yielded an unstable system for anything above 992 MHz. So at high voltage, the memory does not nearly go as far as with 2.0V. Even setting the dividers higher, did not yield any better results. The mainboard is capable of delivering 500 MHz FSB, which would translate to a 3 GHz CPU speed, thus this is not the limiting factor as well.

Mushkin XP2-6400 CL4-4-4-12 4GB Kit
CPU Clock
Memory Ratio
Memory
Speed
Memory
Timings
Everest
Read
Everest
Write
Everest
Latency
Quake 3
Timedemo
3DMark
2001SE
SuperPi
Mod 1M
6 x 330 1:1 330 MHz 3-3-3-10 1.8V 5899 MB/s 5261 MB/s 89.8 ns 553.4 fps 23720 27.53 s
6 x 333 1:1 333 MHz 3-3-3-10 2.0V 5943 MB/s 5306 MB/s 89.2 ns 550.5 fps 23706 27.37 s
6 x 348 1:1 348 MHz 3-3-3-10 2.4V 6207 MB/s 5534 MB/s 85.5 ns 575.1 fps 24289 26.28 s
6 x 381 1:1 481 MHz 4-4-4-12 1.8V 6617 MB/s 6060 MB/s 80.7 ns 616.4 fps 25385 24.07 s
6 x 400 1:1 400 MHz 4-4-4-12 1.9V 6636 MB/s 6360 MB/s 79.1 ns 636.0 fps 25906 23.04 s
6 x 431 1:1431 MHz 4-4-4-12 2.0V 7164 MB/s 6868 MB/s 76.1 ns 670.6 fps 26806 21.32 s
6 x 436 1:1436 MHz4-4-4-12 2.4V 7206 MB/s 6930 MB/s 75.5 ns 671.6 fps 26966 21.12 s
6 x 425 5:6510 MHz5-5-5-15 1.8V 7581 MB/s 6759 MB/s 72.8 ns 652.2 fps 26845 21.53 s
6 x 430 5:6516 MHz5-5-5-15 2.1V 7641 MB/s 6838 MB/s 71.9 ns 700.0 fps 27067 21.25 s



As you can see in the graph above, the memory does not act ideally with increased voltage. This only reflects our kit and your mileage may vary.
Next Page »Value & Conclusion
View as single page
Jul 24th, 2024 05:31 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts