• Welcome to TechPowerUp Forums, Guest! Please check out our forum guidelines for info related to our community.

Marvell Ordered to Pay $1.17 Billion in Damages to University for Patent Infringment

btarunr

Editor & Senior Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
47,194 (7.56/day)
Location
Hyderabad, India
System Name RBMK-1000
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 5700G
Motherboard ASUS ROG Strix B450-E Gaming
Cooling DeepCool Gammax L240 V2
Memory 2x 8GB G.Skill Sniper X
Video Card(s) Palit GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER GameRock
Storage Western Digital Black NVMe 512GB
Display(s) BenQ 1440p 60 Hz 27-inch
Case Corsair Carbide 100R
Audio Device(s) ASUS SupremeFX S1220A
Power Supply Cooler Master MWE Gold 650W
Mouse ASUS ROG Strix Impact
Keyboard Gamdias Hermes E2
Software Windows 11 Pro
Storage and application processor maker Marvell Technology has been ordered by a Federal Jury in the US state of Pennsylvania to pay a local university $1.17 billion in damages for patent-infringement. Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) developed and patented a technology that "increases the accuracy with which hard disk drive circuits read data from high-speed magnetic disks," which Marvell has been found to be infringing. Why $1.17 billion? Because these chips are an indispensable component in modern mechanical hard disk drives, made by both Seagate and WD, among others.

If and when US District Court Judge Nora Barry Fischer agrees with the Jury ruling that Marvell's infringements of CMU's patents are "willful," the fine could triple, according to K&L Gates. The jury found that Marvell sold "billions" of chips carrying the University's technology. What makes this verdict important for the PC industry is that since Marvell's HDD components are widely incorporated in HDDs across various brands, should CMU seek a sales-ban, it could potentially affect HDD production the way last year's unfortunate floods in Thailand did.



View at TechPowerUp Main Site
 

btarunr

Editor & Senior Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
47,194 (7.56/day)
Location
Hyderabad, India
System Name RBMK-1000
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 5700G
Motherboard ASUS ROG Strix B450-E Gaming
Cooling DeepCool Gammax L240 V2
Memory 2x 8GB G.Skill Sniper X
Video Card(s) Palit GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER GameRock
Storage Western Digital Black NVMe 512GB
Display(s) BenQ 1440p 60 Hz 27-inch
Case Corsair Carbide 100R
Audio Device(s) ASUS SupremeFX S1220A
Power Supply Cooler Master MWE Gold 650W
Mouse ASUS ROG Strix Impact
Keyboard Gamdias Hermes E2
Software Windows 11 Pro
Many Thanks to FordGT90Concept for the tip.
 
Joined
Sep 8, 2012
Messages
830 (0.19/day)
Location
Sydney, Australia
System Name The White Breeze||Medion Akoya Ultrabook
Processor i7-3770k||Core i5-3317U
Motherboard MSI Z77 MPOWER||Laptop?
Cooling Custom TEC waterloop||Laptop?
Memory 16GB Kingston HyperX @ 2133MHz||8GB SDRAM
Video Card(s) 2X SLI MSI GeForce GTX 680 Lightning||Intel 4000
Storage Corsair GT 120GB, WD Caviar Black 1TB||500GB HDD with 32gb MSATA cache
Display(s) Samsung U28D590D 4k||14" LED
Case NZXT Switch 810||Laptop shell?
Audio Device(s) Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi surround pro 5.1||Dolby Home Theatre V4
Power Supply Seasonic XP-860 Platinum||Laptop Power Brick
Software Windows 7||Windows 8
The university obviously needs a renovation. Marvell is royally screwed.
 

btarunr

Editor & Senior Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
47,194 (7.56/day)
Location
Hyderabad, India
System Name RBMK-1000
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 5700G
Motherboard ASUS ROG Strix B450-E Gaming
Cooling DeepCool Gammax L240 V2
Memory 2x 8GB G.Skill Sniper X
Video Card(s) Palit GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER GameRock
Storage Western Digital Black NVMe 512GB
Display(s) BenQ 1440p 60 Hz 27-inch
Case Corsair Carbide 100R
Audio Device(s) ASUS SupremeFX S1220A
Power Supply Cooler Master MWE Gold 650W
Mouse ASUS ROG Strix Impact
Keyboard Gamdias Hermes E2
Software Windows 11 Pro
$1.17 billion can run the university for a decade.
 

Aquinus

Resident Wat-man
Joined
Jan 28, 2012
Messages
13,162 (2.82/day)
Location
Concord, NH, USA
System Name Apollo
Processor Intel Core i9 9880H
Motherboard Some proprietary Apple thing.
Memory 64GB DDR4-2667
Video Card(s) AMD Radeon Pro 5600M, 8GB HBM2
Storage 1TB Apple NVMe, 4TB External
Display(s) Laptop @ 3072x1920 + 2x LG 5k Ultrafine TB3 displays
Case MacBook Pro (16", 2019)
Audio Device(s) AirPods Pro, Sennheiser HD 380s w/ FIIO Alpen 2, or Logitech 2.1 Speakers
Power Supply 96w Power Adapter
Mouse Logitech MX Master 3
Keyboard Logitech G915, GL Clicky
Software MacOS 12.1
The university obviously needs a renovation. Marvell is royally screwed.

At the cost of the hard drive market? Their greed will piss off consumers yet again if hard drive prices return to where they were after the flooding. Patent or no patent, if they decide to try to pursue a sales ban, all they're doing is hurting the market. It would be a smarter move to try and collect on it, rather then halt it.
$1.17 billion can run the university for a decade.
Who wants to bet that administration will get a raise in 2013? :wtf:
 
Joined
Sep 8, 2012
Messages
830 (0.19/day)
Location
Sydney, Australia
System Name The White Breeze||Medion Akoya Ultrabook
Processor i7-3770k||Core i5-3317U
Motherboard MSI Z77 MPOWER||Laptop?
Cooling Custom TEC waterloop||Laptop?
Memory 16GB Kingston HyperX @ 2133MHz||8GB SDRAM
Video Card(s) 2X SLI MSI GeForce GTX 680 Lightning||Intel 4000
Storage Corsair GT 120GB, WD Caviar Black 1TB||500GB HDD with 32gb MSATA cache
Display(s) Samsung U28D590D 4k||14" LED
Case NZXT Switch 810||Laptop shell?
Audio Device(s) Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi surround pro 5.1||Dolby Home Theatre V4
Power Supply Seasonic XP-860 Platinum||Laptop Power Brick
Software Windows 7||Windows 8
At the cost of the hard drive market? Their greed will piss off consumers yet again if hard drive prices return to where they were after the flooding. Patent or no patent, if they decide to try to pursue a sales ban, all they're doing is hurting the market. It would be a smarter move to try and collect on it, rather then halt it.

Who wants to bet that administration will get a raise in 2013? :wtf:
Well, this is the world we live in now. The market will still live, the SSD market still hasn't overtaken fully, so hdd's may still live on, the price of HDD's should settle after a year or so.
 
Joined
Jun 23, 2011
Messages
396 (0.08/day)
System Name potato
Processor Ryzen 9 5950X
Motherboard MSI MAG B550 Tomahawk
Cooling Custom WC Loop
Memory 2x16GB G.Skill Trident Z Neo 3600
Video Card(s) RTX3090
Storage 512GB, 2TB NVMe + 2TB SATA || 32TB spinning rust
Display(s) XIAOMI Curved 34" 144Hz UWQHD
Case be quiet dark base pro 900
Audio Device(s) Edifier R1800T, Logitech G733
Power Supply Corsair HX1000
Mouse Logitech G Pro
Keyboard Logitech G913
Software win 11 amd64
and then what? marvell files bankruptcy protection?
 
Joined
Jun 19, 2008
Messages
1,555 (0.26/day)
Location
Shepparton, Victoria, Australia
System Name Toaster!
Processor Intel Core i7 10700KF @ 3.8/5.1GHZ
Motherboard ASUS Prime Z490-P Motherboard
Cooling Noctua NH-D15 CPU cooler.
Memory G.Skill Trident Z RGB 64GB (4x16GB) 3600MHz CL16 DDR4
Video Card(s) ASUS ROG Strix GeForce RTX 3090 OC 24GB
Storage Samsung 970 PRO M.2 NVMe SSD 1TB
Display(s) Asus ROG PG43UQ 4K UHD 144Hz G-Sync HDR 43in + 2 x ASUS VG258Q FHD 144Hz Freesync 25in Monitor
Case Corsair Obsidian 900D
Audio Device(s) EPOS Sennheiser GSX 1000 V2 amplifier + EPOS Gaming GSP 601 Headset
Power Supply Corsair AX1000 Titanium Modular
Mouse Razer Deathadder
Keyboard Corsair K70.
Software ALL HAIL WINDOWS 10.
Benchmark Scores Old system: http://www.3dmark.com/fs/6805248

Aquinus

Resident Wat-man
Joined
Jan 28, 2012
Messages
13,162 (2.82/day)
Location
Concord, NH, USA
System Name Apollo
Processor Intel Core i9 9880H
Motherboard Some proprietary Apple thing.
Memory 64GB DDR4-2667
Video Card(s) AMD Radeon Pro 5600M, 8GB HBM2
Storage 1TB Apple NVMe, 4TB External
Display(s) Laptop @ 3072x1920 + 2x LG 5k Ultrafine TB3 displays
Case MacBook Pro (16", 2019)
Audio Device(s) AirPods Pro, Sennheiser HD 380s w/ FIIO Alpen 2, or Logitech 2.1 Speakers
Power Supply 96w Power Adapter
Mouse Logitech MX Master 3
Keyboard Logitech G915, GL Clicky
Software MacOS 12.1
Well, this is the world we live in now. The market will still live, the SSD market still hasn't overtaken fully, so hdd's may still live on, the price of HDD's should settle after a year or so.

I don't want to pay 250 USD for a replacement 1TB drive if one in my RAID fails. It's ludacris.
This made my night.

You know it's true and quite frankly it's disgusting.
 
Joined
Sep 8, 2012
Messages
830 (0.19/day)
Location
Sydney, Australia
System Name The White Breeze||Medion Akoya Ultrabook
Processor i7-3770k||Core i5-3317U
Motherboard MSI Z77 MPOWER||Laptop?
Cooling Custom TEC waterloop||Laptop?
Memory 16GB Kingston HyperX @ 2133MHz||8GB SDRAM
Video Card(s) 2X SLI MSI GeForce GTX 680 Lightning||Intel 4000
Storage Corsair GT 120GB, WD Caviar Black 1TB||500GB HDD with 32gb MSATA cache
Display(s) Samsung U28D590D 4k||14" LED
Case NZXT Switch 810||Laptop shell?
Audio Device(s) Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi surround pro 5.1||Dolby Home Theatre V4
Power Supply Seasonic XP-860 Platinum||Laptop Power Brick
Software Windows 7||Windows 8
So does anyone know how they calculate these patents to be worth $1.17B?
They probably just work out, how much the little thing is worth, then multiply it by the amount of them sold.
 
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
4,876 (0.80/day)
Location
Joplin, Mo
System Name Ultrabeast GX2
Processor Intel Core 2 Duo E8500 @ 4.0GHZ 24/7
Motherboard Gigabit P35-DS3L
Cooling Rosewill RX24, Dual Slot Vid, Fan control
Memory 2x1gb 1066mhz@850MHZ DDR2
Video Card(s) 9800GX2 @ 690/1040
Storage 750/250/250/200 all WD 7200
Display(s) 24" DCLCD 2ms 1200p
Case Apevia
Audio Device(s) 7.1 Digital on-board, 5.1 digital hooked up
Power Supply 700W RAIDMAXXX SLI
Software winXP Pro
Benchmark Scores 17749 3DM06
They probably just work out, how much the little thing is worth, then multiply it by the amount of them sold.

Probably much more complex than that, but that is the general idea.
 

btarunr

Editor & Senior Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Oct 9, 2007
Messages
47,194 (7.56/day)
Location
Hyderabad, India
System Name RBMK-1000
Processor AMD Ryzen 7 5700G
Motherboard ASUS ROG Strix B450-E Gaming
Cooling DeepCool Gammax L240 V2
Memory 2x 8GB G.Skill Sniper X
Video Card(s) Palit GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER GameRock
Storage Western Digital Black NVMe 512GB
Display(s) BenQ 1440p 60 Hz 27-inch
Case Corsair Carbide 100R
Audio Device(s) ASUS SupremeFX S1220A
Power Supply Cooler Master MWE Gold 650W
Mouse ASUS ROG Strix Impact
Keyboard Gamdias Hermes E2
Software Windows 11 Pro
So does anyone know how they calculate these patents to be worth $1.17B?

Billions of chips were sold that are based on the infringing patent. I'm pretty sure each chip fetched Marvell at least $1?
 
Joined
May 3, 2010
Messages
1,092 (0.21/day)
Location
Essex, England
Processor Ryzen 5900X OC 5150Mhz
Motherboard Asus ROG Crosshair VIII Formula
Cooling Custom EKWB for CPU, VRM's & GPU with 2x 480mm Rads
Memory Gskill TridentZ 3600 Mhz C17
Video Card(s) Powercolor RX 6900XT Liquid Devil Ultimate
Storage Samsung 970 Evo Plus 2TB x 2 Raid0
Display(s) MSI Optix MAG272CQR 27 1440p x2
Case Corsair 1000D
Audio Device(s) onboard 7.1 HD Audio
Power Supply Seasonic PRIME Ultra 1300w PSU
Mouse Logitech G300s
Keyboard Logitech G19s
Software Windows 10 64Bit
Benchmark Scores R20 : 9329 Timespy: 21455
okay, just my two cents,

Firstly, I hope prices don't rise, I use A LOT of HDD's for working n stuff so I don't want to raise prices.

It seems there is still problems as to whether or not the patent was infringed, if it was, I say good on the CMU, at the end of the day they are loosing out on the money from others using their projects. However, saying that I hope if the case stands up that CMU and Marvell reach a settlement inc royalties on the products rather than a complete sales ban on the item.
 

Kreij

Senior Monkey Moderator
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
13,817 (2.13/day)
Location
Cheeseland (Wisconsin, USA)
$1.17 billion can run the university for a decade.

In 2006 CMU dumped over 300 million into R&D. I'm pretty sure they could burn through a billion in a year considering the number of affiliate campuses they have.
That being said, if CMU wins all of the appeals (which will come) I hope that they use the money for more R&D and not just to pad a bunch of tenured professors' wallets.
 

Aquinus

Resident Wat-man
Joined
Jan 28, 2012
Messages
13,162 (2.82/day)
Location
Concord, NH, USA
System Name Apollo
Processor Intel Core i9 9880H
Motherboard Some proprietary Apple thing.
Memory 64GB DDR4-2667
Video Card(s) AMD Radeon Pro 5600M, 8GB HBM2
Storage 1TB Apple NVMe, 4TB External
Display(s) Laptop @ 3072x1920 + 2x LG 5k Ultrafine TB3 displays
Case MacBook Pro (16", 2019)
Audio Device(s) AirPods Pro, Sennheiser HD 380s w/ FIIO Alpen 2, or Logitech 2.1 Speakers
Power Supply 96w Power Adapter
Mouse Logitech MX Master 3
Keyboard Logitech G915, GL Clicky
Software MacOS 12.1
I hope that they use the money for more R&D

I don't if they just sit on the patents and do nothing with them except try to extort money from other companies that most likely legitimately developed their own technology. What CMU is doing is research, I see no development to attempt and actually build what these patents cover on their end...
 
Joined
Apr 1, 2011
Messages
155 (0.03/day)
Billions of chips were sold that are based on the infringing patent. I'm pretty sure each chip fetched Marvell at least $1?

Yes but those chips implemented many many other patents also, not just those infringing ones.
 

Kreij

Senior Monkey Moderator
Joined
Feb 6, 2007
Messages
13,817 (2.13/day)
Location
Cheeseland (Wisconsin, USA)
I don't if they just sit on the patents and do nothing with them except try to extort money from other companies that most likely legitimately developed their own technology. What CMU is doing is research, I see no development to attempt and actually build what these patents cover on their end...

I pretty sure that CMU would happily allow people to license their IP.
If the courts rule that Marvell willfully and intentionally used CMU's IP without compensating them for it, then that was their bad, not CMU's.

Just my opinion. :)
 
Last edited:
Joined
Sep 4, 2005
Messages
658 (0.09/day)
schools spend a crap-load of money on research, I went to GT and they spend about $650 million in 2011 for research, mostly from the government tho and doesn't see the light of day. We even have patents on graphene and such and when i walked through the labs they were funded either by big names like Intel and IBM or the US government which has its own very secure facilities.

I mean this is why they research, to get patents, i mean they do allow the use of them, this is just like long term investments.

Obviously there is enough evidence for them to say it was infringed and willfully at that, that willfully part is a big deal, if they can prove that, then it is pretty bad for marvell. But there are other controllers for HDDs, Marvell's is probably either cheap or very good, my guess would be cheap.

Also the issue is that I bet one of the CMU original engineers who thought of this found this in their controller, and that really got him going, because universities aren't like apple, suing everyone for everything, however in this case the evidence must have been very strong. Or CMU is going bankrupt lol.
 
Joined
Feb 26, 2008
Messages
4,876 (0.80/day)
Location
Joplin, Mo
System Name Ultrabeast GX2
Processor Intel Core 2 Duo E8500 @ 4.0GHZ 24/7
Motherboard Gigabit P35-DS3L
Cooling Rosewill RX24, Dual Slot Vid, Fan control
Memory 2x1gb 1066mhz@850MHZ DDR2
Video Card(s) 9800GX2 @ 690/1040
Storage 750/250/250/200 all WD 7200
Display(s) 24" DCLCD 2ms 1200p
Case Apevia
Audio Device(s) 7.1 Digital on-board, 5.1 digital hooked up
Power Supply 700W RAIDMAXXX SLI
Software winXP Pro
Benchmark Scores 17749 3DM06
Patent squatting at its best. It is starting to be big money these days.

Exactly how bad would things be if the patent system simply didn't exist? (this is a serious question)

I know some of the obvious outcomes, but it is pretty much just being abused for patent infringement.

Todays patent system has turned into a game of monopoly. When manufacturing a product, there is a chance that you might accidentally land on the wrong block and end up going bankrupt owing someone money, with no fault of your own.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Nov 4, 2005
Messages
11,966 (1.72/day)
System Name Compy 386
Processor 7800X3D
Motherboard Asus
Cooling Air for now.....
Memory 64 GB DDR5 6400Mhz
Video Card(s) 7900XTX 310 Merc
Storage Samsung 990 2TB, 2 SP 2TB SSDs, 24TB Enterprise drives
Display(s) 55" Samsung 4K HDR
Audio Device(s) ATI HDMI
Mouse Logitech MX518
Keyboard Razer
Software A lot.
Benchmark Scores Its fast. Enough.
I like the pic of the burned out drive board.


I disagree with this as.

Jury of "peers" of normal mouth breathers who "can't their ifone doesn't do it" on facebook, VS anyone with any sort of technical background.
 
Joined
Sep 4, 2005
Messages
658 (0.09/day)
Patent squatting at its best. It is starting to be big money these days.

Exactly how bad would things be if the patent system simply didn't exist? (this is a serious question)

I know some of the obvious outcomes, but it is pretty much just being abused for patent infringement.

Todays patent system has turned into a game of monopoly. When manufacturing a product, there is a chance that you might accidentally land on the wrong block and end up going bankrupt owing someone money, with no fault of your own.

If it didn't exist then you would have much less drive towards innovation as the the drive to produce new technology by universities and companies would be much less. Cheap ripoffs of technology that took years to make would appear on a much greater scale. But that isn't the big issue, the big issue would be less innovation.
 
Joined
Oct 19, 2008
Messages
3,165 (0.54/day)
System Name White Theme
Processor Intel 12700K CPU
Motherboard ASUS STRIX Z690-A D4
Cooling Lian Li Galahad Uni w/ AL120 Fans
Memory 32GB DDR4-3200 Corsair Vengeance
Video Card(s) Gigabyte Aero 4080 Super 16GB
Storage 2TB Samsung 980 Pro PCIE 4.0
Display(s) Alienware 38" 3840x1600 (165Hz)
Case Lian Li O11 Dynamic EVO White
Audio Device(s) 2i2 Scarlett Solo + Schiit Magni 3 AMP
Power Supply Corsair HX 1000 Platinum
That is an incredibly dodgy move by Marvell, although I'll remain a skeptic and say that this is just another excuse to spike HDD prices up as it's gone down by alot this last month.
 
Top