Are you sure that they're just inactive? Shouldn't the CPU have a lot more L3 cache if that were the case? Honestly, it's probably a mixture of the silicon lottery and some other configuration issue. Some motherboards are better at overclocking than others, particular when it comes to skt2011 chips. The RIVE is known for being pretty good at overclocking and the Sabertooth is known for being a rock solid motherboard, but doesn't overclock as well. The P9X79 Deluxe like I have falls somewhere in between, but has a beefy VRM setup.
Exactly right, Asus for their faults and issues over the years I USED to think were far overpriced and a mobo was a mobo, give or take. However, since now owning my first Asus board which was the RIVE IV and now RIVE black and can honestly say especially for a platform that was known for pushing board to limits (because socket 2011 was literally revolutionary at the time and blew everything else away) The Asus boards are worth every penny...especially considering not one I bought was new lol, all were used or first one from Newegg that got me started was a return and I think had couple dead memory channels from time I got it, ironically I only could afford to fill the 2 channels that worked, so never noticed till later.
Aquinus assessment is spot on, succinctly put. I haven't had the two other boards but I've read this thread, others, and reviews and Sabertooth is very solid but OC'ing just wasn't it's thing, the Deluxe another solid board with great VRM and lots of features, and decent/good at OC'ing, and RIVE/RIVE black definitely were designed to OC about as well as the platform allows.
ALSO, in regards to 8 core XEONS vs the 6 core consumer chips from what I understand they are two totally different pieces of silicon, the 1680 is actually the chip with a few cores disabled I believe and for whatever reason Intel decided to unlock multiplier on it, the 39 and 49 series chips have everything enabled on them if they are the 3960x or 4960x, not sure if the 3930/4930 have couple things disabled but I believe that is the case as well. Don't quote me on this but I'm fairly certain this is the case and I will look into it and let you know, because now you got me wondering.