- Joined
- Apr 24, 2020
- Messages
- 2,745 (1.59/day)
Never could get into the Fate series since I despise temperamental goodie-two-shoe characters like Emiya Shiro, so I fear the whole Fate series would somehow revolve around him. Never got past the first volume of the manga. Type-Moon's other work; Tsukihime's Tohno Shiki & Arcueid Brunstein was a total 180 though. They were cool, calm & collected. My fav type of personality. And so I was thrilled when Shiki beat Shiro in battle during the crossover.
Emiya Shiro is the worst part of the Fate series. It stays interesting despite him, and Fate/Stay Night is his "most goodie two-shoes" you'll see him. The general arc follows the "Would you kill 1 person to save 10 people??" question across three acts (plus the excellent Fate/Zero prequel)
* Fate/Stay Night serves as the naive introduction. It introduces Shiro's simple philosophy: "Save as many people as possible" (aka: save all 11 people), even at great personal cost. However, Shiro never actually comes into a paradox situation. This is on purpose: this series serves as an introduction to Shiro. Shiro is the weakest by far in this arc. Fortunately, Saber picks up the slack.
* Fate / Unlimited Blade Works has Shiro come into direct confrontation with the question. I don't know how to say it without major spoilers, so I'll leave it vague. Furthermore, some level of death and sacrifice becomes necessary for Shiro to live through this arc. The overall challenge is greater, the paradox is revealed, character deaths happen, but Shiro ultimately is victorious.
Major spoilers:
Archer is Emiya Shiro from the future, and Archer is tired of being summoned as a Hero. The only time a hero is called is to kill people. Does Shiro still want to become a hero, despite the literal mountain of corpses that stand in his way? Even in death, Shiro will only be resummoned over, and over, and over to save the world from evildoers, being forced to spill blood to save the world.
Rin used her gem to replace Shiro's heart in the 1st episode (when Lancer skewered Shiro). But Rin uses the same gem as her summoning implement: because the gem constitutes a heroic artifact, it allows Rin to summon the heroic spirit Emiya Shiro (Archer class). There's a time paradox involved, but there's no doubt that Rin's gem is Shiro's heart, and therefore a highly attuned summoning artifact. (Akin to Shiro's Avalon gift from his father: connecting Shiro to Pendragon / Saber).
Rin used her gem to replace Shiro's heart in the 1st episode (when Lancer skewered Shiro). But Rin uses the same gem as her summoning implement: because the gem constitutes a heroic artifact, it allows Rin to summon the heroic spirit Emiya Shiro (Archer class). There's a time paradox involved, but there's no doubt that Rin's gem is Shiro's heart, and therefore a highly attuned summoning artifact. (Akin to Shiro's Avalon gift from his father: connecting Shiro to Pendragon / Saber).
* Fate / Heaven's Feel is a tragic story where Shiro give up upon his ideals. Instead of saving as many people as possible, Shiro chooses one person above all else he wants to save. At first its through inaction, but I expect that the 3rd movie (haven't seen it yet) will have a fight which Shiro must get past: spilling the blood of one character he cares about to save another he cares more about.
--------
Fate/Zero explores Kiritsugu, who never considered himself a heroic figure. Kiritsugu constantly faces the "kill 1 person to save 10 people" choice, and commits larger, and larger atrocities in an effort to make the best moral choice. By all accounts, Kiritsugu is a full blown magical-terrorist whose collateral damage is horrifying. But given the alternative, I think the audience understands Kiritsugu's decisions.
Last edited: