https://linustechtips.com/main/topic/692471-cant-enable-sli-gtx-970/
Some 970's from EVGA just will not SLI, I remember reading it when i bought my second one a while back and worried whilst waiting for it to be delivered, check the cards part number
There are three versions of the GTX 970: A blower-style cooler with a short circuit board, an ACX cooler with a full size circuit board, and an updated version of the GTX 970, SSC, and FTW models. The three styles of GTX 970s will not function in SLI together. See the chart below to see which cards will function together in SLI. Cards in the same column will function in SLI together. A card from one column will not work in SLI with a card from another column.
Blower Style ACX Style GTX 970, FTW, and SSC
04G-P4-1970-KR 04G-P4-0972-KR 04G-P4-3973-KR
04G-P4-1972-KR 04G-P4-0974-KR 04G-P4-3974-KR
04G-P4-1976-KR 04G-P4-2972-KR 04G-P4-3975-KR
04G-P4-2973-KR 04G-P4-3978-KR
04G-P4-2974-KR 04G-P4-4975-KR
04G-P4-2975-KR 04G-P4-3979-KF
04G-P4-3979-KB
04G-P4-2976-KR
04G-P4-2977-KR
04G-P4-2978-KR
04G-P4-2979-KR
Check your model number on the EVGA - may be related.