Thanks for a great review - this is really a segment of the PSU market that needs all the reviewer attention it can get, seeing how these PSUs are what most PC builders really ought to be buying (given that most gaming PCs consume <200W under gaming loads).
One question,
@crmaris: have you considered adding high current transient load testing to your PSU testing suite, in response to the behaviour of current GPUs? That would be an immensely valuable test IMO. Your current 50% load transient test obviously covers this somewhat, but the big concern would be someone with a power hungry GPU tipping power draw over the rated output of the PSU - which isn't too unreasonable these days. Something like a simple pass/fail test at 70% load + a 20A 12V spike would be rather interesting to see (even if most PSUs would no doubt fail!).