Windows 95 UI which is considered
the pinnacle of GUI/UX was developed by actual scientists, engineers, psychologists and specialists in human vision and behavior. Almost all apps using classic Windows 95 controls are
extremely easy to recognize and interact with because they are visual, have simple shapes and depth, have a good contrast and resemble certain things in the real world.
E.g. here's classic Windows 95:
What's special about this old outdated design? It effing works, period!
- You immediately see what's clickable and what's not
- Checkboxes state is readable
- Controls which are active and passive are easily recognizable
- Buttons looks like actual buttons
- Can be easily controlled from the keyboard and there shortcuts for various controls
Windows 8 UI which is widely considered
the worst UI design ever was designed by wanna-be designers with zero education, knowledge and background in designing anything.
Now I don't even want to post anything "modern" because it's just poor unadulterated crap. You start working with Android/iOS/Windows 10 and you immediately get lost. What's text and what are controls? What's the state of checkboxes? Is it to the left or to the right? What's with active being colored and passive being grayish? How can you even read it? And don't get me started on gestures, the short for "undiscoverable crap for hippies".
Let's look at this MODERN design crap.
- Tell me which parts of this image are clickable (controls) and which are text? Is there any indication of which is which?
- Tell me, the use Wi-Fi toggle in the picture (it's actually an effing checkbox) is now on or off?
- Why is everything so low contrast?
And the redesign offered in this topic is the same W8/W10 modern crap which is mainly appreciated by the people who do not understand design.