you mean oc3d? yea...seen that. I do not agree and all other reviews out there do not agree either. I am baffled how that can be considered an objective review...
That review helped me more than yours, even if he went overboard.
You are trying to be objective beyond the call of duty, not trying to insult manufacturer or whatnot. You gave both Define R3 & NZXT H2 same score(9.1 and editors choice), now why can't you make up your mind? Why can't you tell me which one is better in your opinion?
Yes, you may argue that for some people hot swap is more important than lets say case finish, or effectives of silencing foam or cooling. But you should just make up your damn mind when it comes to scoring and not make every feature equal to other!
If the whole build quality is great like you claim in pros or H2, then how come it does not surpass R3 in score? It got usb3 on front, it got hot swap, it got fan controller on front, more fans, hotswap fans... It should kick R3's ass in $100 range.
After 6 months sale of R3 and H2 on newegg, have a look on feedbacks and see if they are also scored there equally.
I know you probably want to be acting as impartial journalists, only reporting facts, but if I want just list of features stated without any brain activity involved I will just go look at rodney reynolds's videos.
/edit
Also who is right? In your review its aluminium on front doors, in his its plastic.