@xvi- you can pick up a Xig Gaia for $20-30 and put those temps back down pretty easy. The mounting allows for the standard front-rear fan setup rather than the up-down setup of the old S1283.... it's an easy install too
They do make an adapter to turn the old cooler 90 degrees for about $10 but the mounting interferes with the VRM caps on a lot of the newer boards.
That adapter is the Crossbow and I have it. It basically turns any AM2/AM3 mount in to a LGA775 bolt-through mount. I have it mounted in the "normal" direction with the idea that the exhaust will blow out the large fan at the top. I think the problem right now is that my CPU fan isn't attached and is just sitting on the heatsink blowing the wrong direction (down). I can't turn it right side up because the blades will hit the heatsink. Yes, I plan on fixing this soon. I don't think I'll be able to go back to my push/pull config since the 8-pin CPU power comes up in to the cooler's area.
On top of that, I ran out of AS5 and had to use normal silica paste. Despite that, it shouldn't go from 35c load to 60c load just because I'm using different goop. I suspect it's not applied properly.
This is all supposed to be temporary until I find a way to mount my radiator to something and get my loop going.
Did a quick test before I left for work. The below screenshot is with ~70f (21c-ish?) ambient temps. It made it to 62c before I suspended all tasks and left for work.
I'll zip-tie a few fans around it properly when I get home today. If I can't get a push/pull, I think I'll bring back my Ultra Kaze 3000. That should drop it down enough to join the Mother's Day Crunching festivities.