Again, while true, noise is very subjective. Not everyone cares. Some people don't mind extra noise as long as it's not jet engine levels. I'm one of those people. I care more about temps than noise.
Every GPU out there can get good temperatures, you just have to deal with the noise. If that is your criteria then generally the MSRP models are fine. The more expensive models may OC better, but generally not by much to be worth the money. 1-2 frame rates won't be enough to make a real world difference.
Again, that's subjective. Example; Not a problem for me. Granted, I like the smaller size of the Twin Edge so that's is my preferred model anyway. However, the $50 extra is not something that would dissuade me from the Trinity.
It really comes down to price and cooling performance, of which noise is a primary factor. At $600 this would have easily been the best 4070 Super on the market. Some may have been slightly better, but the price jump generally not worth it when you can get a 4070ti Super for $50 or so more.
At $650, there are a few competing models from MSI, Gigabyte, etc. so this becomes a "meh" product. At $600 it would have blown the competition away. Maybe this is better than MSI, Gigabyte, etc. offerings at $650 though.
Noise is important because that is where the value of choosing a specific model comes in. If noise was not a consideration, all of these GPUs would perform fine. You can set the fans to 80-90% fan speed and all will cool sufficiently. If you don't care about noise, it more or less comes down to which is cheaper and which brand/warranty you trust the most because they all perform the same otherwise.
I'm not a fan of Gigabyte, so the suggestion of the Windforce is just not in the list of possible cards, personally.
Fair enough, but for other people it is a worthy comparison especially given the price. I wouldn't recommend Western Digital because they steal items and don't give refunds. But I assume many people would still like to see how they perform compared to other companies products like Samsung, Crucial, etc.