Value and Conclusion
This is a two-in-one product review that has been incorporated into a de-lidding awareness and testing article. As such, there are three things to cover here: whether or not to de-lid the Intel Core i7-7700k, how good is the Aquacomputer Dr. Delid Tool, and how good is the Rockit 88 de-lid tool with the re-lid kit.
I do not think anyone will disagree with me when I say it is well worth de-lidding for the much better heat transfer from the CPU die to the IHS, which in turn greatly increases the heat dissipation away from the CPU. This makes the CPU run significantly cooler no matter the means of cooling and helps justify higher-end cooling even more. There is also the potential extra overclock available here, and so one must instead ask why not de-lid? For most, the loss of CPU warranty will automatically be a deal breaker. Nothing has changed in the last few years as far as this goes, and if anything, the absolute prices of CPUs have increased further (
although not as much with inflation considered), thus making the risk of losing a ~$350 part not seem worth it. The complexity of de-lidding is gone, however. No more is the vice or blade method worth it, especially with the thinner PCBs of the Intel 6th Generation architecture (Skylake) and onward. I am also seeing some retailers offer a rental program for such de-lidding tools, and yet others who offer de-lidding services as well with some form of replacement warranty included. For enthusiasts who want more than what the current CPUs allow, and who can not stand the fans on their cooler running fast to try and cool down the CPU further, these are all lucrative options, and I personally will de-lid all my non-soldered CPUs if supported by similar tools. Let us now examine the two products individually.
- Lower cost for de-lidding and re-lidding tools
- Elegant one-piece construction
- Uniform rotational force applied for de-lidding
- Included manual could be more detailed
Aqua Computer came to the party later, but as is the case with its products, this is a more elegant one-piece solution that adopts the company's design scheme. The Dr. Delid tool is a complete package and allows the end user to de-lid in a fool-proof manner, and also re-lid the IHS back on. It is easier to use and takes less time as a result of fewer parts being involved. For those looking at de-lidding only, this would be my recommendation, and with Aqua Computer having clarified that I had the centering tool for the re-lid in its incorrect orientation, my main complaint with the re-lid is now gone as well. As such, there is in my opinion nothing to really keep you from making the purchase as long as you examine the manual and follow my guide on page 2 for further help.
For the price point and simple design, the Aqua Computer Dr. Delid tool gets the Editor's Choice award from me.
Rockit Cool Rockit 88
- The Rockit 88 de-lid tool costs $28-$30, with the re-lid kit costing an additional $8 from the Rockit Cool webshop.
- Greatly detailed online manuals and videos
- Good customization options available
- Lower cost for de-lid-only tool
- Precise re-lid alignment tool and spyder
- Comes with tools to help prep and clean the die as well
- Takes longer to de-lid and re-lid relative to the other option
On the other end of the spectrum lies Rockit Cool. With no reputation or history behind it, and it basically being a one-man-managed operation, Rockit Cool had to get the community involved from the get go to make the Rockit 88 a successful product. The company's involvement in the community and its detailed manuals and emails back and forth to help guide individual customers are just as useful as a fool-proof product that minimizes user error by as much as possible. If you are looking for a tool to de-lid yourself, then understand that there are other available solutions - from inexpensive 3D-printed rotary tools to modular, CNC-machined tools that support different CPU sockets with the use of different base plates. Among all the competition, the Rockit 88 remains one of the most popular solutions in the market, and for good reason. It also gets the top award from me.