In Win Commander III 600 W Review 0

In Win Commander III 600 W Review

Ripple Measurements »

Advanced Transient Response Tests

In these tests, we monitor the response of the PSU in two different scenarios. First, a transient load (10 A at +12V, 5 A at 5V, 5 A at 3.3V, and 0.5 A at 5VSB) is applied to the PSU for 200 ms while the latter is working at a 20% load state. In the second scenario, the PSU, while working at 50% load, is hit by the same transient load. In both tests, we measure the voltage drops that the transient load causes using our oscilloscope. The voltages should remain within the regulation limits as defined by ATX specifications. We must stress here that the above tests are crucial since they simulate transient loads that a PSU is very likely to handle (e.g., booting a RAID array, an instant 100% load of CPU/VGAs, etc.) We call these tests "Advanced Transient Response Tests", and they are designed to be very tough to master, especially for PSUs with capacities lower than 500 W.

Advanced Transient Response 20%
VoltageBeforeAfterChangePass/Fail
12 V12.227V12.107V0.98%Pass
5 V5.112V5.039V1.43%Pass
3.3 V3.420V3.299V3.54%Pass
5VSB5.028V4.993V0.70%Pass


Advanced Transient Response 50%
VoltageBeforeAfterChangePass/Fail
12 V12.187V12.064V1.01%Pass
5 V5.085V5.020V1.28%Pass
3.3 V3.400V3.323V2.26%Pass
5VSB4.994V4.952V0.84%Pass


Only during the first test did a rail, the 3.3V one, deviate by 3%. Deviations were kept low on all other rails. The +12V rail only deviated by close to 1% in both cases, which is a very good performance given the unit's medium capacity. All in all, the PSU performed very well, proving that it will easily handle all real-life dynamic loads.


Below, you will find the oscilloscope screenshots that we took during Advanced Transient Response Testing.

Transient Response at 20% Load



Transient Response at 50% Load



Turn-On Transient Tests

We measure the response of the PSU in simpler scenarios of transient loads - during the power-on phase of the PSU - in the next set of tests. In the first test, we turn the PSU off, dial the maximum current that the 5VSB can output, and then switch on the PSU. In the second test, we dial the maximum load that +12V can handle, and we start the PSU while it is in standby mode. In the last test, while the PSU is completely switched off (we cut off power or switch off the PSU's on/off switch), we dial the maximum load that the +12V rail can handle before switching the PSU on from the loader and restoring power. The ATX specification states that recorded spikes on all rails should not exceed 10% of their nominal values (e.g., +10% for 12V is 13.2V and for 5V is 5.5V).



The slope ramps up smoothly with no spikes or voltage overshoots on the 5VSB rail, while the +12V rail makes a small step in both cases. During the "PSU OFF TO FULL 12V" test, we also measured a spike at 12.58V, a high value which, however, is much lower than the 13.2V limit; it won't cause any problems.
Next Page »Ripple Measurements
View as single page
Nov 28th, 2024 14:56 EST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts