Monday, September 5th 2022

Resizable-BAR a Must for Arc "Alchemist," Stick with Other Vendors if you Lack it: Intel

The PCI resizable-BAR feature is an absolute must for Intel Arc "Alchemist" graphics cards to perform as advertised, to the extent that Intel recommends sticking to "other vendors" (NVIDIA, AMD), for those on machines that lack resizable-BAR or prefer it disabled. In our testing of the Arc A380, we found a big performance gap between resizable-BAR being enabled and disabled. The company said that while it is working on driver optimizations that improve performance for machines lacking resizable-BAR, its general advice for those on older platforms is to stick with other vendors.

Resizable-BAR enables the software to see the entire video memory of a graphics card as a single large addressable block, rather than through 256 MB apertures. AMD and NVIDIA's driver architectures have optimized their memory-management to cope with these apertures through the advent of PCI-Express, but Intel Arc hasn't. Its memory-management model relies on large bursts of memory transfers, for which it needs resizable-BAR. The performance penalty for lacking it could be as high as 40 percent. In related news, Intel Graphics confirmed that the Arc A770 will be available both in 16 GB and 8 GB memory variants at launch—which is still slated for Soonuary, 2022.
Sources: PCGH, DigitalFoundry (YouTube), VideoCardz
Add your own comment

53 Comments on Resizable-BAR a Must for Arc "Alchemist," Stick with Other Vendors if you Lack it: Intel

#51
Rob6502TPU
RedBearIntel mentioned Resizable BAR as a requirement for optimal performance several months ago, even before the first ARC GPUs were released and testing promptly confirmed the performance degradation without ReBAR. The ironic thing is that it mostly hits people on older (before the series 400 mobos) Intel platforms, maybe Intel thinks it will prompt them to upgrade?
Your post basically explains why I don't believe it was a design feature. Tom & Ryan need to eplain how all the game developers will update their memory management for Re-BAR on old titles.
Posted on Reply
#52
maxfly
maxflyThe mb in question is an Asus ROG Crosshair VII Hero wifi. He knew going in that it didn't support rebar but spoke to an Asus engineer that said there was a possibility. So he gave it a try but failed.

And yes he's wise enough to know how to update the bios to the latest version...
He tested the a380 in his i5 rig and still couldn't get it to work as the primary gpu. Returning the gpu as defective. Rebars reputation saved!
Posted on Reply
#53
ThrashZone
Hi,
Thanks for the warning intel I'd pass even if it weren't a requirement though.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Jul 15th, 2024 20:09 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts