Hi, everyone, google brought me here after finding this thread of a similar issue: https://www.techpowerup.com/forums/...ddenly-have-errors-bsod-startup.315391/page-2
Seeing that thread was both recent and active with educated replies I wanted to post my situation: I debated on posting in that thread but thought maybe it’d be best to make my own. Apologies in advance for the length of this post btw!
SPECS:
CPU: AMD Ryzen 5900x
Mobo: ASUS ROG Crosshair VIII Dark Hero x570
RAM: 4x Corsair Vengeance RGB PRO 8GB (32gb total) DDR4 3000MHz C15
Video Card: MSI RTX 4090
PSU: EVGA 1300w G2
Various fans, AIO, multiple HDD + SSD + 2x m.2 drives.
A few months ago (early August) I started having an issue where after rebooting my PC Windows wouldn’t load, it would just hang at the spinning dots prior to Windows actually loading and do the same thing with the “repair” start up after a failed boot. The dots would either spin infinitely (I once left it on overnight to see if it would eventually boot: woke up to it still spinning) or the dots would freeze after a few seconds.
I tried reinstalling Windows, however the same issue would occur when booting the Windows installer from USB. I also tried (in no particular order)… disconnecting all HDD/SSD + removing non-boot m.2s as well as changing the port used for my boot m.2, disconnecting all USB devices except my keyboard (also trying a different USB for the keyboard), taking out all 4 RAM sticks and trying them 1 at a time, resetting CMOS, removing the motherboards battery to reset CMOS, and probably 5 other things I don’t remember. There were no Q Code errors.
I had the idea to flash the BIOS and lo-and-behold the system booted! After a few reboots the problem reoccurred but reflashing the BIOS (to the same version already installed) would fix the issue and I’d be able to get into Windows each time (simply resetting CMOS would not work, only a BIOS flash would). Windows would be completely stable once in, gaming and everything else was also fine. All voltages good, temperatures great, etc.
I thought “must be a motherboard issue” so I checked my mobo warranty to see if it is still covered, called ASUS, got an RMA. Installed the new mobo, problem seemed to have mostly gone away: could reboot the system without needing to flash the BIOS each time, once in a while Windows would lock on boot like before but after a manual restart it would load fine (no need to flash the BIOS or troubleshoot). I replaced the motherboard with the RMA in mid-September.
Flash forward to 2 weeks ago, problem began again; did the BIOS flash trick from before and it worked. Yesterday my PC needed to reboot after an app update (I should mention I rarely turn off or reboot my PC outside of software/OS updates and/or issues arising ) but flashing the BIOS didn’t work this time (I tried multiple times). On one of the reboot attempts I received no video signal for POST and had a Q Code (I can’t remember but I want to say “0d” which (regardless of if it was actually 0d or not) when I googled indicated a memory training or initializing issue), even after getting a video signal again by reseating the RAM I eventually received another Q Code that indicated RAM as well as a blue screen during a Windows boot attempt that stated “Driver_PNP_WatchDog” stop code. This time, I remembered that I had an old pair of 2400mhz Geil Ripjaw DDR4 from an old X99 build in storage. Plugged it in, system booted right up. “Okay”, I thought, “one of the Corsair sticks must be bad”, so I took the Geil out and put two of the Corsair in DIMMs 2 and 4, system booted properly, put the remaining two back into 1 and 3, previous boot issue occurred, removed 2 and 4 to confirm and still had the boot issue. I proceeded to remove the two Corsair RAM sticks still in the system and replace it with the two Corsair sticks that booted, still using DIMMs 1 and 3 to confirm that it’s not a DIMM issue… no boot. “Oh… a bad DIMM?” so I moved those two sticks back to 2 & 4… no boot again. “Did I somehow mix up the Corsair sticks?” switched to my other two, still DIMMs 2 & 4, no boot… Back to the Geil, booted no problem. Restarted the computer from Windows 3+ times with no issue with the Geil installed.
I went ahead and ordered 2x 32gb DDR4 3600mhz C18 RAM to replace these 4x Corsair sticks as I’m wondering if running 4x sticks with such low latency (C15) caused the IMC to burn out the sticks overtime. However, I’ve had this RAM since August 2019 with no issues running all 4 in an X99 mobo for quad channel before upgrading to and moving all 4 sticks to the current X570 AM4 build approximately a year later in August of 2020. There’s been no issues until a few months ago. RAM was always run with its XMP/DOCP profile active in BIOS.
I’d love some thoughts on this as 4x sticks of DDR4 that have been fine for roughly 4 years suddenly going bad seems, at best, highly improbable.
Seeing that thread was both recent and active with educated replies I wanted to post my situation: I debated on posting in that thread but thought maybe it’d be best to make my own. Apologies in advance for the length of this post btw!
SPECS:
CPU: AMD Ryzen 5900x
Mobo: ASUS ROG Crosshair VIII Dark Hero x570
RAM: 4x Corsair Vengeance RGB PRO 8GB (32gb total) DDR4 3000MHz C15
Video Card: MSI RTX 4090
PSU: EVGA 1300w G2
Various fans, AIO, multiple HDD + SSD + 2x m.2 drives.
A few months ago (early August) I started having an issue where after rebooting my PC Windows wouldn’t load, it would just hang at the spinning dots prior to Windows actually loading and do the same thing with the “repair” start up after a failed boot. The dots would either spin infinitely (I once left it on overnight to see if it would eventually boot: woke up to it still spinning) or the dots would freeze after a few seconds.
I tried reinstalling Windows, however the same issue would occur when booting the Windows installer from USB. I also tried (in no particular order)… disconnecting all HDD/SSD + removing non-boot m.2s as well as changing the port used for my boot m.2, disconnecting all USB devices except my keyboard (also trying a different USB for the keyboard), taking out all 4 RAM sticks and trying them 1 at a time, resetting CMOS, removing the motherboards battery to reset CMOS, and probably 5 other things I don’t remember. There were no Q Code errors.
I had the idea to flash the BIOS and lo-and-behold the system booted! After a few reboots the problem reoccurred but reflashing the BIOS (to the same version already installed) would fix the issue and I’d be able to get into Windows each time (simply resetting CMOS would not work, only a BIOS flash would). Windows would be completely stable once in, gaming and everything else was also fine. All voltages good, temperatures great, etc.
I thought “must be a motherboard issue” so I checked my mobo warranty to see if it is still covered, called ASUS, got an RMA. Installed the new mobo, problem seemed to have mostly gone away: could reboot the system without needing to flash the BIOS each time, once in a while Windows would lock on boot like before but after a manual restart it would load fine (no need to flash the BIOS or troubleshoot). I replaced the motherboard with the RMA in mid-September.
Flash forward to 2 weeks ago, problem began again; did the BIOS flash trick from before and it worked. Yesterday my PC needed to reboot after an app update (I should mention I rarely turn off or reboot my PC outside of software/OS updates and/or issues arising ) but flashing the BIOS didn’t work this time (I tried multiple times). On one of the reboot attempts I received no video signal for POST and had a Q Code (I can’t remember but I want to say “0d” which (regardless of if it was actually 0d or not) when I googled indicated a memory training or initializing issue), even after getting a video signal again by reseating the RAM I eventually received another Q Code that indicated RAM as well as a blue screen during a Windows boot attempt that stated “Driver_PNP_WatchDog” stop code. This time, I remembered that I had an old pair of 2400mhz Geil Ripjaw DDR4 from an old X99 build in storage. Plugged it in, system booted right up. “Okay”, I thought, “one of the Corsair sticks must be bad”, so I took the Geil out and put two of the Corsair in DIMMs 2 and 4, system booted properly, put the remaining two back into 1 and 3, previous boot issue occurred, removed 2 and 4 to confirm and still had the boot issue. I proceeded to remove the two Corsair RAM sticks still in the system and replace it with the two Corsair sticks that booted, still using DIMMs 1 and 3 to confirm that it’s not a DIMM issue… no boot. “Oh… a bad DIMM?” so I moved those two sticks back to 2 & 4… no boot again. “Did I somehow mix up the Corsair sticks?” switched to my other two, still DIMMs 2 & 4, no boot… Back to the Geil, booted no problem. Restarted the computer from Windows 3+ times with no issue with the Geil installed.
I went ahead and ordered 2x 32gb DDR4 3600mhz C18 RAM to replace these 4x Corsair sticks as I’m wondering if running 4x sticks with such low latency (C15) caused the IMC to burn out the sticks overtime. However, I’ve had this RAM since August 2019 with no issues running all 4 in an X99 mobo for quad channel before upgrading to and moving all 4 sticks to the current X570 AM4 build approximately a year later in August of 2020. There’s been no issues until a few months ago. RAM was always run with its XMP/DOCP profile active in BIOS.
I’d love some thoughts on this as 4x sticks of DDR4 that have been fine for roughly 4 years suddenly going bad seems, at best, highly improbable.
Last edited: