want me to list the installer bugs and problems I have found, or the number of windows installer's there are out there
Windows
NSIS (Nullsoft Scriptable Install System)
Actual Installer
Advanced Installer
CreateInstall
CreateInstall Light
CreateInstall Free
DeployMaster
DreamShield(free deployment tool for .NET Framework based applications)
Excelsior Installer
Excelsior Delivery
Inno Setup
InstallAware
InstallBuilder
Install Creator (Pro) (formerly Install Maker (Pro))
InstallShield
Installer VISE
Instyler Setup
MSI Package Builder
QSetup
Scriptlogic Desktop Authority MSI Studio
SetupBuilder Developer Edition
SetupBuilder Professional Edition
Setup Factory
Tarma ExpertInstall 3
Tarma Installer 5
Windows Installer(to many versions to list)
Wise Installation Studio 7
Wise Installation Express 7
Wise Package Studio
WiX
wyBuild & wyUpdate written in C#
Mac OS X
Installer for Mac OS X, from Apple Inc.
Iceberg for Mac OS X
Remote Install Mac OS X
VISE X by MindVision Software
so each of them has multi installers, mac having the least(thanks to apple being very strict on what they allow on osx)
windows has a shitload if different installers, and if you hit a bugged installer, good luck tracking down the problem and fixing it or for that matter getting the company behind it to fix it.
At least with linux, If you cant fix it yourself, most times you can ask in IRC or on a forum and have help very quickly to get the problem fixed with a spicific installer.
example from today, i grabbed the latist opera10 installer for windows and linux, couldnt get the linux installer to work, went on irc, and somebody helped me edit the install script file to fix the error(took like 30sec, just had to change one line of text) and bam worked no problem.
yet i have a STACK of windows apps that WONT INSTALL on any windows version but XP without hacking the hell out of them(no i dont mean they wont install on server, they also wont install on 2k or vista because there are bugs/flaws in the installer)
Linux is far from perfect, but its not as bad as it use to be, at least when you run into a wall, you can ask for help and most times, somebody will help you, with windows, good luck getting a proprietary installer issue fixed, even by the people who made the damn thing!!!
Hell MICROSOFT cant even fix the zunesuit's vista x64 installer so it works without hacking the registry(ask DarkNova or anybody else running x64 vista/7 with a zune) and THEY MAKE THE DAMN INSTALLER AND SOFTWARE IN IT!!!!
if it was Linux, you could pop open the install package, find the install script and fix it, but its windows, and its locked down so you cant edit the installer to fix the damn bugs
Windows is GREAT when it works(like I said, I
LOVE my 2008) but its not flawless, and when stuff like an installer is borked, most times you will be flying blind trying to fix it :/
And as I have said, I agree they need one unified click and install system, BUT not a copy of windows click and install system.
P.S. have any of you ever used the Xandros app manager/store? wish windows installer/manager was as friendly and easy to use!!!