So rather unsurprisingly, its the same talking points as people used for / against Portal RTX. Who woulda thunk?
Well I don't know, one could'a thunk that in the past seven years we made some actual progress, but people are still trying to get to grips with what is supposed to be a simpler workflow where you can just plonk your lighting in the scenes. Anything in motion is still a blurry mess despite four major version updates of DLSS and anywhere it is used without extra special Nvidia TLC.
And people clearly don't like that a whole lot. They're
still awaiting the promises made to be fulfilled. It is quite similar to what I've been seeing and saying about it.
What you see here is people
identifying stagnation, versus other people saying its really happening 'but not quite there'.
The gist is: its not there yet, seven years in.
Forever in beta.
Frighteningly similar to crypto, too, where some gear suppliers get filthy rich and everyone else is led to believe they'll get rich someday later. And just like in crypto you have the adamant believers that need to downplay all counter arguments to their world vision to stay sane - they call others frustrated to hide their own all-in stance on some promise out of some marketing blurb about how a company has been working on this for decades and its the next best thing - they are
invested, not just with money, but pride and ego.
I'll leave to each individual to decide for themselves where they sit on that spectrum, but that spectrum is real, and is visible every time around these subjects.
You just highlighted the key point: There's more than one way to skin a cat. RayTracing is flexible and can be done in many varying ways. The general concept tracing light rays is the same, but the way it's done is very customizable for the specific needs of the use-case scenario.
However, until a better way to replicate lighting comes about, mimicking nature with raytracing is now the standard and isn't going anywhere.
Very true. That's why I also think remekra's post was valuable. Those are tangible arguments to identify progress. But they're all attempts and none of them are really at a point where everyone says 'This is it!' And we've been looking at this for quite a while now.