Thursday, February 13th 2025

Western Digital Faces $553M Patent Bill Days Before Company Split

The Register reports that a federal judge has rejected Western Digital's attempt to delay payment of a $553 million patent infringement penalty, giving the storage giant just seven days to secure a bond or pay up. The ruling, issued February 11, comes as Western Digital faces mounting pressure over intellectual property disputes. To be more specific it's about SPEX Technologies' Patent No. 6,088,802, which protects security features in peripheral devices. In October 2023, a California jury ruled that several WD products, including Ultrastar and My Book drives infringed on this 1997 patent. Judge James Selna later expanded the initial $316 million verdict to include $237 million in interest charges.

Western Digital's upcoming corporate restructuring complicates the situation. The company plans to split into two separate entities by February 21—one to focus on NAND flash memory under the SanDisk brand and another to maintain the traditional hard drive business. This pending division has raised questions about how to enforce the damages, with Judge Selna mentioning his "concerns about potential corporate restructuring" because the judgment targets Western Digital Technologies Inc. SPEX has voiced concerns about the company split pointing out in legal papers their lack of insight into which new entity would pay the penalty or if either would have enough money to cover the owed amount.
Western Digital's legal troubles go beyond the SPEX case. The company faces another big patent verdict from August 2023 where German firm MR Technologies won damages first set at $262 million and later raised to about $380 million with interest.

The storage company's recent court filing tried to delay the payment order while it seeks a new trial and tries to reverse the original patent verdict. Their lawyers argued that SPEX didn't show their devices did "the identical function specified in the claim" of the patent. However, this argument didn't convince Judge Selna, who kept the payment deadline.

While Western Digital hasn't said anything inside sources say the company will appeal both patent infringement rulings.
Source: The Register
Add your own comment

5 Comments on Western Digital Faces $553M Patent Bill Days Before Company Split

#1
CandidConflict
From 1997? What exactly is being protected here? Patent trolls are absolute scum
Posted on Reply
#2
bonehead123
OuCh...but of course you know who is gonna REALLY be paying for those judgements, now don't you ?

Yup, us little people, by virtue of drastically increasing prices of WD's drives...
Posted on Reply
#3
Steevo
I read the patent, its a broad description of many things, I believe they will use this money as seed money to sue everyone else. This is a travesty of uneducated idiots passing a lawsuit for obvious patent trolls and what appears to be a high school computer grade paper that got a patent number.

patents.google.com/patent/US6088802A/en
Posted on Reply
#4
windwhirl
Nomad761997 patent.
Uh, aren't patents supposed to expire after 20 years?
Posted on Reply
#5
freeagent
Chump change for those companies.
Posted on Reply
Feb 13th, 2025 18:24 EST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts