Drop CTRL Mechanical Keyboard Review 4

Drop CTRL Mechanical Keyboard Review

(4 Comments) »

Value and Conclusion

  • The Drop CTRL keyboard comes in a variety of color and switch options, with the cost ranging from $200 to $225 from Drop directly. There is an occasional $21 discount to be had from Drop, if not more at times, bringing the prices to $179–204. There is also an option to pair it with different keycap sets, get an optional extended warranty, or even purchase the keyboard as just a kit, in addition to other accessories and parts, including a higher-profile aluminium case or different layout PCBs.
  • Fully open-source firmware and design language
  • Very customizable with spare/replacement parts
  • Available as a kit for lower cost
  • Two color options and six switch options
  • PBT doubleshot keycaps are of great quality
  • Hot-swappable mechanical switch socket, albeit limited to 3-pin switches
  • Vibrant side lighting courtesy 32 extra LEDs
  • Full programmability with Drop configurator, with up to 15 extra layers
  • Per-key RGB backlighting options to edit and create
  • Two add-on feet for different elevation options courtesy magnets and tilting
  • Very good build quality
  • Low-profile, clean looks with no branding on the front or sides
  • The software experience is too complicated for the average customer
  • 1st-party configurator updates seem dead now, albeit QMK loader is still being worked on
  • Legends are not very clear without backlighting
  • Not very competitive at MSRP today, especially with 3-pin switch sockets, plate-mounted stabilizers, and north-facing LEDs
I know I have brought up Input Club twice already, but bear with me a third time. The Drop CTRL and Hexgears Gemini I've compared this to over the course of the review both are variants of the (Mass)Drop x Input Club K-Type that was an inspiration and a half to many keyboards adopting the design language with a low-profile aluminium frame/case that also has the plastic diffuser in the middle for side lighting accents. The Drop CTRL might as well be considered the direct replacement to the K-Type, with several quality of life improvements, including hot-swappable switches, 32 added LEDs for actual side lighting, and more switch/case/parts options, all while retaining availability of the Halo switches. At $200, it is similarly priced out of reach for many wallets, yet feels like it's not doing enough for more custom keyboard enthusiasts at the same time.

The Cherry MX premium aside, you can quite often get the Drop CTRL for $179. In fact, as I write this, there is a "Back to School" sale ongoing at Drop which has the keyboard available for $179. This certainly helps, as the Hexgears Gemini comparison again enters the picture here. That keyboard currently costs $160, has a very similar feature set and design, and is also available in two colors. Both of these are relatively old releases, yet somehow have managed to come out looking weak when it comes to their updated configurator support. Drop ends up doing most things better, however, including in terms of available options in their custom configurator and taking the open-source design further by retaining a parts inventory to make the Drop CTRL far more personal. For $20 more, I'd definitely take this over the Hexgears Gemini.

My issue is that these two alone don't exist in a vacuum anymore. Be it $179/$204 or $200/$225, the Drop CTRL is harder to justify in 2021 since a lot of the features are found elsewhere for less money spent. The first-party QMK support for it is lacking now and needs to be improved, or at least updated. There are very few users who will go the extra mile to use QMK/VIA and other open-source firmware solutions by themselves, instead relying on other options from the community or the company. The Drop CTRL does distinguish itself from the pack by doing most things better, and customers no doubt are also paying for the increased hardware support. It is the software and pricing that make it hard to wholly recommend despite there being a lot of things I like about the DROP CTRL. Sure, I would have also liked to see screw-in stabilizers and south-facing LEDs, but it's harder to complain about features not present in a design that was pretty much finalized three years ago. I suppose that the Drop CTRL is still in discussions today is a positive testament to its longevity, and it being in stock always certainly helps, too. Now, if you happen to see it for closer to $150, things would be much different. It competing in the ever-growing mechanical keyboard market will get progressively harder at MSRP, or even with the occasional discounts it gets.
Discuss(4 Comments)
View as single page
Jul 19th, 2024 21:31 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts