Wednesday, May 14th 2008

GIGABYTE: ASUS Lied and Fooled Customers

I will finish my day reporting a story published by Tom's Hardware that involves two big motherboard manufacturers - GIGABYTE and ASUS. According to GIGABYTE's technical team, ASUS is lying about its EPU (Energy Processing Unit) energy efficiency performance figures and is playing tricks with its users. ASUS claims that EPU outfitted motherboards can deliver up to 80.23% "power savings" from motherboards without EPU components. Yea, but that's not what GIGABYTE thinks. Test results from GIGABYTE's lab show that the claimed 80% energy efficiency is around 58.6% in reality, and ASUS is "playing numbers marketing" and "cheating end users." GIGABYTE engineers continued: "We found that [Asus'] EPU in 4 phase mode CAN NOT act PWM phase changing while Asus still claims EPU is a hardware based energy saving chip. Don't get fooled. The EPU (AIGear3+) is pure software based, not hardware!" "How can you believe it? Everything [Asus] say are lies," they added. GIGABYTE even pointed out that ASUS motherboards use poor quality non-Japanese solid capacitors. Read the full story here.
Source: Tom's Hardware
Add your own comment

64 Comments on GIGABYTE: ASUS Lied and Fooled Customers

#52
Mussels
Freshwater Moderator
HaZe303I dont know if anything gigabyte says is true, but I totally prefer mobo´s from GB over Asus. Sure Asus make great "looking" boards with great cooling, but I have found Asus boards often to be very unstable with bios's that are more tweaked for OC than stability. Id like to have both, my GA-P35-DS4 is one of the best boards I ever had. I can hardly touch a Asus board without it getting damaged, my DS4 has gone through hard treatments and it still works perfectly without any issues???

My Asus Maximus Formula is great, but comes nowhere near the stability of my GB board.
Were they Nvidia chipset boards? i've only had the best of luck with asus intel boards, but the Nv ones have mostly been crap.
Posted on Reply
#54
HaZe303
MusselsWere they Nvidia chipset boards? i've only had the best of luck with asus intel boards, but the Nv ones have mostly been crap.
Well asus maximus is a x38 board, and I have had a p5b deluxe wifi, that one was actually very good, but that one was actually one of few good ones from asus I have had.
Posted on Reply
#55
imperialreign
msgclbEPU vs. DES power war wages on in Taipei

And the winner is...
<looks at pocketwatch> GIGA will repond to this in exactly two more days . . . :wtf:


The way it looks so far, GIGA will try to debunk this presentation in some form, instead of trying to counter the argument with their own tests/presentation . . .
Posted on Reply
#59
msgclb
imperialreignwas I right, or was I right? :D
That depends on whose timepiece you have in your pants. Next up, ASUS.
:nutkick:
Posted on Reply
#60
jbunch07
intel igentthis sux im buying a Mac

:laugh:
no you better not! :mad:

nice fine imperialreign!
Posted on Reply
#61
new_rez
ShadowFoldGigabyte is just trying to get more customers... Like their power saving thing is any good anyway.
Any power saving is better than no power saving! It will prolong the time before we all die from global warming.
Posted on Reply
#62
jbunch07
new_rezAny power saving is better than no power saving! It will prolong the time before we all die from global warming.
i really dont care about power saving i would rather have a 500hp v8 than a 100hp 4 cylinder!
Posted on Reply
#64
Luke Skywalker
Here is the response from Asus:

www.asus.com/news_show.aspx?id=11400

They say that Gigabyte is lying. Asus says Gigabyte claimed that the VGA card with the blown capacitors is NOT an Asus VGA card. Since they are taking it to court, I believe they must know what they are doing.

"Also, in a press briefing presentation, Gigabyte used a photograph with blown-up (exploded) capacitors and led the audience to believe it was an ASUS product, to support its false allegations that ASUS uses questionable quality components. However, the image was found to be taken from a photograph of a VGA card manufactured by another vendor. The action of misrepresenting a third party product to be an ASUS product is truly defamatory and clearly outside the realm of decent competition."

I guess we will find out soon who is lying.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 25th, 2024 10:32 EST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts