LEPA MaxPlatinum Series 1700 W Review 3

LEPA MaxPlatinum Series 1700 W Review

(3 Comments) »

Value and Conclusion

  • The LEPA P1700-MA-EU retails for €206 (around $235 with a conversion rate of €1 = $1.139) in the EU, and it won't make an appearance in the US since it is only compatible with 230 VAC.
  • Good price/performance ratio
  • Delivered full power at 48°C
  • Able to deliver huge power levels
  • Excellent ripple suppression at +12V
  • Efficient (although it cannot perform as well as modern high-capacity platforms)
  • Performance of +12V in Advanced Transient Response tests
  • Japanese electrolytic caps
  • Amount of connectors
  • Quality construction
  • Compact dimensions (for a 1.7 kW unit)
  • Five year warranty
  • Ridiculously low hold-up time!
  • Ripple at 5VSB with light loads
  • 5VSB overshoots in turn-on test
  • Noisy operation
  • Efficiency with light loads
  • Loose load regulation at +12V
  • Placement of sockets on the modular PCB
The unit's incredibly low hold-up time forced me deduct a good chunk of points from its final rating, all while spoiling the overall picture. I expect a 1.7 kW unit to come with much larger bulk caps, but there apparently wasn't enough space on the main PCB to accommodate them. Whatever the case, the registered hold-up time was even lower than half of the allowed limit, so you better have this PSU connected to a good UPS should you buy one. Although the platform counts several years in production, it can still offer up good performance, which, however, cannot match that of the high-end competition. That said, at its current price, the deal looks good if you take its low hold-up time and its increased ripple at 5VSB with light loads out of the equation.

There aren't enough PSU offerings with a capacity of over 1.6 kW in Europe, where this LEPA unit is available. There are actually only two, the Super Flower Leadex with 2 kW capacity being the only alternative to LEPA's offer. If you are in need of such a high capacity PSU, the P1700-MA looks like a good deal because of its price/performance ratio and its quality components, which include Japanese electrolytic capacitors. However, there is a big "but" here. Given its low hold-up time, you should only use it in combination with a strong UPS that can support it in a worst-case scenario or you might lose some precious date during even the slightest power cut. If you don't care about data loss or already have a good UPS, you might want to consider buying this unit; that is, if you need 1.7 kW. Seeing a good platform fail so horribly in a test that is required by the ATX specification is a sad thing. LEPA should have made room for bigger APFC caps even if the result would have been a larger PCB and, as such, a larger unit. Finally, all noise haters out there be warned: This PSU is loud, especially once stressed.
Discuss(3 Comments)
View as single page
Oct 4th, 2024 06:12 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts