Wentai Aidan 1616 W Review - The Corsair AX1600i Challenger?

Name: Wentai Aidan 1616 W
Brand: Wentai Technology

crmaris

on Mar 16th, 2020,

in Power Supplies.

Manufacturer: Wentai Technology

Protection Features Evaluation, DC Power Sequencing & EMC Pre-Compliance Testing »

Advanced Transient Response Tests

In these tests, we monitor the response of the PSU in two different scenarios. First, a transient load (10 A at +12V, 5 A at +5V, 5 A at +3.3V, and 0.5 A at 5VSB) is applied to the PSU for 200 ms while the latter is working at 20% load. In the second scenario, the PSU, while working at 50% load, is hit by the same transient load. We measure the voltage drops the transient load causes with our oscilloscope in both tests. Voltages should remain within the regulation limits defined by the ATX specification.

Real-world usage always has a PSU work with loads that change depending on whether the CPU or graphics cards are busy, which makes whether the PSU can keep its rails within the ranges defined by the ATX specification important. The smaller the deviations, the steadier the system will be, which results in less stress being applied to its components.

We should note that the ATX specification requires for capacitive loading during the transient tests, but in our methodology, we chose to apply the worst-case scenario with no extra capacitance on the rails. Although the ATX specifications asks for this capacitance, your system—the mainboard and its other parts—may not provide it, which we have to keep in mind as well.

Advanced Transient Response 20% - 5 Hz
Voltage	Before	After	Change	Pass/Fail
12 V	12.048V	12.007V	0.34%	Pass
5 V	5.062V	4.987V	1.48%	Pass
3.3 V	3.357V	3.271V	2.56%	Pass
5VSB	5.043V	4.982V	1.21%	Pass

Advanced Transient Response 50% - 5 Hz
Voltage	Before	After	Change	Pass/Fail
12 V	12.064V	12.022V	0.35%	Pass
5 V	5.042V	4.972V	1.39%	Pass
3.3 V	3.335V	3.242V	2.79%	Pass
5VSB	5.013V	4.956V	1.14%	Pass

Transient response at +12 V is amazing. Voltage drops are low on the other three rails as well.

Below are the oscilloscope screenshots we took during Advanced Transient Response testing.

Transient Response at 20% Load

Transient Response at 50% Load

Turn-On Transient Tests

We measure the response of the PSU in more straightforward scenarios of transient load—during the Power-on phase of the PSU—in the next set of tests. In the first test, we turn the PSU off, dial the maximum current the 5VSB can output, and then switch on the PSU. In the second test, we dial the maximum load +12V can handle and start the PSU while the PSU is in standby mode. In the last test, while the PSU is completely switched off (we cut off power or switch the PSU off by flipping its on/off switch), we dial the maximum load the +12V rail can handle before switching the PSU on from the loader and restoring power. The ATX specification states that recorded spikes on all rails should not exceed 10% of their nominal values (e.g., +10% for +12V is 13.2 V and 5.5 V for +5V).

Power Supply Timing Tests

Power Supply Timing
Parameter	Description	Required Value - Includes (Support for Alternative Sleep Mode)
T0	AC power-on time	< 2s
T1	Power-on time	< 150 ms
T2	Rise time	0.2 - 20 ms
T3	PWR_OK delay	100 - 150 ms
T4	PWR_OK rise time	< 10 ms
T5	AC loss to PWR_OK hold-up time	> 16 ms
T6	PWR_OK inactive to DC loss delay	> 1 ms

The table above lists all required power supply timing values.

T1 (Power-on time) & T3 (PWR_OK delay)
Load	T1	T3
20%	166 ms	148 ms
100%	170 ms	152 ms

Power-on time is pretty high. It should be notably lower.

Ripple Measurements

Ripple represents the AC fluctuations (periodic) and noise (random) found in the DC rails of PSUs. Ripple significantly decreases the life span of capacitors because it increases their temperature; a 10 °C increase can cut into a capacitor's life span by up to 50 percent. Ripple also plays an important role in overall system stability, especially when it is overclocked. The ripple limits according to the ATX specification are 120 mV (+12V) and 50 mV (+5V, +3.3V, and 5VSB).

Ripple Measurements - Wentai Aidan - T1616
Test	12 V	5 V	3.3 V	5VSB	Pass/Fail
10% Load	9.4 mV	6.2 mV	6.6 mV	5.8 mV	Pass
20% Load	10.7 mV	6.6 mV	8.7 mV	6.5 mV	Pass
30% Load	34.3 mV	8.8 mV	9.2 mV	9.7 mV	Pass
40% Load	11.7 mV	6.1 mV	7.2 mV	6.5 mV	Pass
50% Load	14.4 mV	8.5 mV	7.8 mV	8.8 mV	Pass
60% Load	15.4 mV	9.2 mV	8.7 mV	9.5 mV	Pass
70% Load	14.5 mV	6.8 mV	8.3 mV	8.5 mV	Pass
80% Load	16.9 mV	7.6 mV	10.0 mV	9.3 mV	Pass
90% Load	20.9 mV	9.1 mV	11.1 mV	11.8 mV	Pass
100% Load	25.5 mV	9.5 mV	12.9 mV	14.4 mV	Pass
110% Load	41.6 mV	12.3 mV	14.0 mV	17.7 mV	Pass
Crossload 1	11.5 mV	7.3 mV	9.1 mV	6.6 mV	Pass
Crossload 2	26.1 mV	13.3 mV	11.4 mV	16.0 mV	Pass