My opinion is that Windows 11's biggest problem is its nonsensical, unfinished shell and frankly disjointed user experience. Microsoft UX designers are actual morons and they've been making it repeatedly worse since Windows 8 because
oh my effing god we need to change for the sake of change!!!!!!!! - I strongly suspect there might be a culture of "toxic positivity" going on within the Windows development team because clearly, whoever seems to be in charge clearly hasn't stopped to tell these people to back off. Some heads have to roll, some people need to get fired, and they're not; Microsoft urgently needs to revisit Windows Vista and 7 to see what makes them look so pretty without losing any usability, and bring that to Windows 12.
As to what we can do to remedy the situation, the Stardock Object Desktop tools - specifically
Start11 v2 and
Fences 5 go great lengths towards "fixing" a lot of what's wrong with Windows 11's UI. Disabling the new context menu is also a must-do tweak, using
Winaero Tweaker to trim the bloat, restore a few things that were moved or removed and you can actually get a great thing going. Other free options like
RetroBar or
Open Shell are also viable towards customizing your OS back into a semblance of normality. I think mine is actually looking great, and it behaves as you would expect
I will only ditch W10 when it becomes as deranged as using W7 today. Now, it's a totally viable and time tested OS. Unlike W11, which tends to just refuse to work on some machines for no apparent reason.
Lex has a good point. Underneath the (clearly unfinished and problematic) stock UI/UX, Windows 11 is more refined and a better developed OS. If you're willing to put the time (and perhaps a small bit of money) into getting this sorted out, you
will have a better experience than you would by just sticking to Windows 10. However, these things should be
default and come as part of the standard experience with Windows, which clearly isn't the case - Microsoft is tripling down on everything we've come to
hate lately, and even began taking steps towards making sure we can't fix their messes. 24H2 LTSC might be a landmark - anything past this smells and looks like no man's land, hopefully Nvidia starts investing in their Linux stack soon...