be quiet! Dark Power Pro 1500 W Review - Better than Corsair AX1600i? 22

be quiet! Dark Power Pro 1500 W Review - Better than Corsair AX1600i?

Fan Noise »

Efficiency

Using the results we gathered so far, we plotted a chart showing the PSU's efficiency at low loads and loads ranging from 10 to 110 percent of the maximum-rated capacity.




In terms of efficiency, the PSU has a hard time keeping up with ETA-A+ and 80 PLUS Titanium offerings.

10%–110% Load Testing

These tests reveal the PSU's load regulation and efficiency levels under high ambient temperatures. They also show how the fan-speed profile behaves under tough operating conditions.

Load Regulation & Efficiency Testing Data - be quiet! P12-PRO-1500
Test12 V5 V3.3 V5VSBPower
(DC/AC)
EfficiencyFan SpeedPSU NoiseTemp
(In/Out)
PF/AC
Volts
10% Load10.618A1.987A1.993A0.999A150.029W92.473%548 RPM8.6 dB(A)40.47°C0.796
12.095V5.035V3.311V5.006V162.240W43.48°C230.41V
20% Load22.272A2.982A2.992A1.201A300.087W93.822%550 RPM8.5 dB(A)40.64°C0.950
12.086V5.032V3.309V4.998V319.846W44.13°C230.40V
30% Load34.266A3.480A3.492A1.403A449.891W94.655%550 RPM8.5 dB(A)41.19°C0.969
12.077V5.030V3.309V4.990V475.295W45.68°C230.41V
40% Load46.295A3.979A3.993A1.606A599.902W94.810%551 RPM8.5 dB(A)41.67°C0.977
12.068V5.027V3.308V4.983V632.741W46.66°C230.40V
50% Load58.030A4.977A4.991A1.809A750.062W94.619%553 RPM8.5 dB(A)42.90°C0.981
12.055V5.025V3.306V4.976V792.719W48.60°C230.39V
60% Load69.765A5.976A5.991A2.001A900.071W94.247%681 RPM15.7 dB(A)43.50°C0.983
12.045V5.022V3.305V4.968V955.010W49.83°C230.38V
70% Load81.510A6.975A6.995A2.218A1050.272W93.697%682 RPM15.8 dB(A)43.91°C0.986
12.037V5.021V3.304V4.961V1120.918W50.78°C230.37V
80% Load93.278A7.978A7.995A2.423A1200.475W92.966%1020 RPM28.7 dB(A)44.21°C0.987
12.029V5.018V3.302V4.953V1291.302W52.33°C230.35V
90% Load105.474A8.480A8.483A2.424A1350.223W92.439%1460 RPM38.9 dB(A)44.87°C0.988
12.019V5.015V3.301V4.951V1460.657W53.68°C230.35V
100% Load117.232A8.984A9.002A3.566A1499.962W91.900%1743 RPM44.7 dB(A)45.61°C0.988
12.008V5.012V3.300V4.909V1632.159W55.27°C230.33V
Crossload 10.118A18.001A17.999A0.000A151.638W86.395%561 RPM8.8 dB(A)42.50°C0.806
12.082V5.041V3.304V5.074V175.518W48.10°C230.41V
Crossload 2125.030A1.001A1.002A1.000A1515.558W92.171%1644 RPM42.8 dB(A)45.81°C0.988
12.015V5.017V3.305V4.990V1644.292W55.02°C230.33V

The cooling fan's speed dropping so low during the CL1 test despite high operating temperature looks odd. I also noticed that the PF readings are not that high, especially during high loads. Given the digitally controlled PFC converter, I expected higher PF readings.

As you will notice in the table above, there is no 110% test because I couldn't get the PSU to operate correctly at the load level. Strangely, I didn't have this problem during the OPP evaluation.

Light Load Testing

In the following tests, we measure the PSU's efficiency at loads significantly lower than 10 percent of the maximum capacity (the lowest load the 80 PLUS standard measures). This is important for representing when a PC is idle with its power-saving features turned on.

Efficiency at Low Loads - be quiet! P12-PRO-1500
Test #12 V5 V3.3 V5 VSBPower
(DC/AC)
EfficiencyFan SpeedPSU NoisePF/AC
Volts
12.882A0.496A0.498A0.199A40.034W75.440%546 RPM8.9 dB(A)0.602
12.104V5.037V3.313V5.032V53.067W230.41V
24.105A0.993A0.997A0.398A59.984W85.721%542 RPM9.1 dB(A)0.658
12.102V5.037V3.312V5.026V69.976W230.41V
35.336A1.489A1.496A0.598A80.025W88.424%543 RPM9.1 dB(A)0.706
12.101V5.036V3.312V5.019V90.501W230.40V
46.567A1.986A1.994A0.798A100.057W90.051%543 RPM9.1 dB(A)0.743
12.099V5.035V3.311V5.013V111.112W230.40V

Efficiency levels with light loads are satisfactory.

Ultra-light Load Testing

The applied load in this test is only 10 W for PSUs with 500 W and less capacity. We dial in 2% of the maximum-rated capacity for all other PSUs. We only run this test with 115 V input.

Efficiency at Low Loads - be quiet! P12-PRO-1500
Test #12 V5 V3.3 V5 VSBPower
(DC/AC)
EfficiencyFan SpeedPSU NoisePF/AC
Volts
12.248A0.325A0.325A0.063A30.245W69.808%542 RPM9.1 dB(A)0.766
12.107V5.032V3.311V5.031V43.326W115.17V

This PSU is just barely below the 70% efficiency mark the ATX specification asks for with 2% load.

5VSB Efficiency

5VSB Efficiency - be quiet! P12-PRO-1500
Test #5VSBPower (DC/AC)EfficiencyPF/AC Volts
10.100A0.502W73.499%0.020
5.022V0.683W230.36V
20.250A1.254W76.277%0.048
5.012V1.644W230.39V
30.550A2.752W77.543%0.100
5.002V3.549W230.38V
41.000A4.987W77.510%0.167
4.986V6.434W230.37V
51.500A7.456W77.578%0.225
4.970V9.611W230.36V
63.501A17.143W76.947%0.347
4.896V22.279W230.36V


While 5VSB efficiency is high enough, the digital competition has a significant lead here.

Power Consumption in Idle and Standby

Idle / Standby - be quiet! P12-PRO-1500
Mode12 V5 V3.3 V5VSBPower (AC)PF/AC Volts
Idle12.108V5.030V3.310V5.030V0.125W0.004
230.4V
Standby0.048W0.001
230.4V

Vampire power is very low.
Next Page »Fan Noise
View as single page
Nov 28th, 2024 10:30 EST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts