Ridiculous prices like always.

kastriotRidiculous prices like always.

Considering the engineering, not really.

lexluthermiesterConsidering the engineering, not really.

What engineering? Drilling holes in metal plates and screwing them together?

All cpu tower coolers have this genious design, but they cost at around 50 Eur for 800grams of ALU and engineering.

This one weighs 2.5kg for 500 eur

Furthermore, Arctic cooling Alpine 12 passive costs 9.80 eur and its 500grams of ALU.
This is rated for 37W TDP, and i can assure you, it does its job very well. I have a 58W TDP non U CPU running with this thing with no fans in an ITX case (26cm x 27cm x 9cm) full of cables.

heck, even intel own NUC with i5-8250 costs 400 eur and it's passive.

There is only one reason somebody would buy this - design. Everything else is terrible for the price tag.

Before I've had my coffee, I read that as Nimbus 2000, then I put my glasses on.

I just LOL’d at Bean Canyon...

randomUserAll cpu tower coolers have this genious design, but they cost at around 50 Eur for 800grams of ALU and engineering.
This one weighs 2.5kg for 500 eur
Furthermore, Arctic cooling Alpine 12 passive costs 9.80 eur and its 500grams of ALU.
This is rated for 37W TDP, and i can assure you, it does its job very well. I have a 58W TDP non U CPU running with this thing with no fans in an ITX case (26cm x 27cm x 9cm) full of cables.
heck, even intel own NUC with i5-8250 costs 400 eur and it's passive.
There is only one reason somebody would buy this - design. Everything else is terrible for the price tag.

The base price of 499€ includes NUC. One of the NUC8i3 options that cost 250€ or a bit more by itself plus 4GB of RAM.
As far as the price goes it is not all that bad.

Considerable part of the engineering challenge is probably the modularity of the heatsink. When looking at Cirrus7's page they offer the same case/heatsink in different widths and the third picture in the news post seems to illustrate some of that.
www.cirrus7.com/produkte/cirrus7-nimbini-v2/overview
Edit: I was wrong about the picture illustrating it. Their blog states these are heatsink variants they tested for the performance targets.

randomUserWhat engineering? Drilling holes in metal plates and screwing them together?

Try doing it yourself and let's see what BOM you come up with. This kind of engineering isn't as simple or cheap as you might suppose.

kastriotRidiculous prices like always.

You realize those prices include a NUC motherboard?

lexluthermiesterTry doing it yourself and let's see what BOM you come up with. This kind of engineering isn't as simple or cheap as you might suppose.

Have you checked that Alpine radiator? Thats all the engineering that is needed. You only need to make a simple steel/plastic case to hold the MoBo and this heatsink.
This heat sink WITHOUT any heatpipes at all is already overkill for things like i5-8250U and i5-8259U

Intel NUC BOXNUC8i5BEK2 costs 382 eur, that is 250eur cheaper.

What I am wondering aside from price /engineering ratio is why not go that extra mile and jam in the core i7with the vega chip on board?

Fabio BolognaWhat I am wondering aside from price /engineering ratio is why not go that extra mile and jam in the core i7with the vega chip on board?

100W package TDP might have something to do with that ;)

This is just plain odd.

-The cooler doesn't have heatpipes, but is seemingly held together with copper rods. Look at their ends - they're thick and flat, not tapered or pinched like a heatpipe. That might be a rushed render, of course, but then how do you fit five heatpipes across the core like that? Or is it two U-shaped and one L-shaped? If so: why?
-Not to sound overly snarky, but they came up with a common thermal transfer core that accepts various amounts of aluminium heatsink plates pressed onto it. Whoop de doo. This does not seem all that complicated. I get that there's a difference between napkin engineering and making an actual design and then bringing it to life with all the weirdness that manufacturing throws into the mix, but come on.
-The same goes for the case design: long screws, spacers, aluminium fins. Done. Add or remove holes, screws and spacers for increased rigidity. If the inner fins are the same ones that make up the outer sides, that's pretty clever, but also really, really simple. All that's needed is a half-decent metal workshop.

All in all, the pricing isn't terrible (they have R&D costs, after all, and I can't imagine stuff like this selling in massive quantities), but it's not good either. If the base motherboard is €250 and this is €500, that's at least €100 too much for the case alone.

londiste100W package TDP might have something to do with that ;)

So what? make it a bit bigger and job done ;) it says in the article that 28w part runs 12° cooler under load then that stupid intel stock thing... it has the reserves as it is right now plus you can make it bigger and add some more reserve cooling capacity...

randomUserWhat engineering? Drilling holes in metal plates and screwing them together?

All cpu tower coolers have this genious design, but they cost at around 50 Eur for 800grams of ALU and engineering.

This one weighs 2.5kg for 500 eur

Furthermore, Arctic cooling Alpine 12 passive costs 9.80 eur and its 500grams of ALU.
This is rated for 37W TDP, and i can assure you, it does its job very well. I have a 58W TDP non U CPU running with this thing with no fans in an ITX case (26cm x 27cm x 9cm) full of cables.

heck, even intel own NUC with i5-8250 costs 400 eur and it's passive.

There is only one reason somebody would buy this - design. Everything else is terrible for the price tag.

The "value proposition" is based on looks and marketing.
If any disagree, go buy a pet rock.