Tuesday, January 18th 2022

ARCTIC Identifies Bad Batch of MX-5 TIM in the Market, Offers Free Replacements

For ARCTIC, it has always been a top priority to supply customers only with products of the best quality and durability. Should there ever be any doubts about products we've delivered, we stand by our responsibility to our customers.

Current findings from our permanent quality assurance tests show that certain batches of our MX-5 thermal compound contain anomalies in consistency and shelf life. The affected products show an increased separation of oil within the paste, resulting in premature hardening. This can lead to adverse effects and application difficulties.
Affected batches have already been identified and recalled from circulation so that no further affected product can enter the market. We regret that this quality defect could not be detected before delivery to distributors and customers, despite constant quality controls and diligent care during production.

Affected MX-5 thermal compounds can of course be returned without exception, and we will offer a replacement product. For this purpose, we ask you to contact us and provide proof of purchase via the form support.arctic.de/en/menu/support.
Add your own comment

60 Comments on ARCTIC Identifies Bad Batch of MX-5 TIM in the Market, Offers Free Replacements

#27
Crackong
NT-H2 all the way.
I just wanna build it and leave it, not going to bother with the "ultra high performing thermal paste" crowd.
Posted on Reply
#28
Space Lynx
Astronaut
CrackongNT-H2 all the way.
I just wanna build it and leave it, not going to bother with the "ultra high performing thermal paste" crowd.
plus the quality control of Noctua is immaculate.
Posted on Reply
#29
freeagent
On the first page of this thread they state that it has always been their top priority to supply its customers with nothing but the best.. I guess they sent out a batch before Q.A. could get back from holidays?

I liked AS5 better than MX4 anyways :D

And don't get me started on how my Ultra 120 Extreme was better than my D14 :D :D

:fear:
Posted on Reply
#30
Space Lynx
Astronaut
freeagentOn the first page of this thread they state that it has always been their top priority to supply its customers with nothing but the best.. I guess they sent out a batch before Q.A. could get back from holidays?

I liked AS5 better than MX4 anyways :D

And don't get me started on how my Ultra 120 Extreme was better than my D14 :D :D

:fear:
I have never heard of Ultra 120 Extreme, will google it now, but better or not temp wise does not mean better in customer service if something were to go wrong or missing. Noctua is king of customer service, that is worth even being a couple celsius hotter imo.

I also see no reason to risk damage to components with something like AS5, when MX4 is only 1-3 celsius hotter. PC stuff is expensive, same reason I use air cooling only, just not worth the risk, even if the risk is mild.
Posted on Reply
#31
freeagent
I'm not a total hater though, I am using Noctua fans to keep 625w cool right now as we speak. Wish I could say they were quiet though :D

I am glad they aren't, I need the airflow :)
Posted on Reply
#32
Space Lynx
Astronaut
freeagentI'm not a total hater though, I am using Noctua fans to keep 625w cool right now as we speak. Wish I could say they were quiet though :D

I am glad they aren't, I need the airflow :)
I'm a bit of a Noctua sinner in this regard.

I use the NZXT Aer-P fans, they look like propellor blades on an airplane, they are relatively quiet and push air like a mofo. I love mine.
Posted on Reply
#33
lexluthermiester
R-T-BI remember the "love it or hate it" reviews on this stuff vs mx4. Maybe this was a factor in some of the bad reviews.
That's possible. I love this stuff. It is the best non-liquid-metal TIM I've tested.

Props to Arctic for making it public and setting things right. This is how a company is supposed to handle problems.
lynx29interesting my arctic mx-5 thread here has 101k views, and I don't recall a single issue about it turning into a liquid...
Never had that issue. It's always been a very sticky, gooey material.
Posted on Reply
#34
freeagent
lynx29I'm a bit of a Noctua sinner in this regard.

I use the NZXT Aer-P fans, they look like propellor blades on an airplane, they are relatively quiet and push air like a mofo. I love mine.
It’s all good my man, I have said in the past that I am a massive Thermalright fanboy :D

I almost bought an Arctic LFII 360 more than a few times now.. the shipping is the deal breaker because I am not a fan of the price as it is lol. So I am not entirely against an AIO because a custom loop is not in the cards at this stage.. but I really should educate myself on it because 12 cores man.. only so much air can do and next gen stuff is supposed to be a little more brutal :D
Posted on Reply
#35
Space Lynx
Astronaut
freeagentIt’s all good my man, I have said in the past that I am a massive Thermalright fanboy :D

I almost bought an Arctic LFII 360 more than a few times now.. the shipping is the deal breaker because I am not a fan of the price as it is lol. So I am not entirely against an AIO because a custom loop is not in the cards at this stage.. but I really should educate myself on it because 12 cores man.. only so much air can do and next gen stuff is supposed to be a little more brutal :D
if i could get a $70-90 PC case that supports 420mm AIO, I would get the Arctic 420mm AIO and that case (assuming it was halfway decent for the price), the 420mm AIO from arctic is an insane deal at only $125. problem is finding a case...
Posted on Reply
#36
Crackong
lynx29I'm a bit of a Noctua sinner in this regard.

I use the NZXT Aer-P fans, they look like propellor blades on an airplane, they are relatively quiet and push air like a mofo. I love mine.
Speaking about fans.
The next gen 140mm fans delayed so many times, I bought silent wings instead
Posted on Reply
#37
maxfly
Has anyone actually tried the return/replace option since this was posted?
Posted on Reply
#38
Chomiq
maxflyHas anyone actually tried the return/replace option since this was posted?
Most likely they will just ask for photos with proof of purchase and a shipping address. Doubt they'll ask for returns of bad batches.
Posted on Reply
#39
iuliug
I bought some and it arrived yesterday. bad timing. If i have to pay for return to Germany then it will cost more than the product itself. The lack of info on this article is unsettling.
Posted on Reply
#40
lexluthermiester
iuliugThe lack of info on this article is unsettling.
You are expected to reach out to Arctic if you have a problem.
Posted on Reply
#41
TheoneandonlyMrK
maxflyHas anyone actually tried the return/replace option since this was posted?
Has anyone found out how where I genuinely tried no luck.
@lexluthermiester they are illusive reach out how.


Googlefu letting me down, I have some Corsair x50 on the way ?! Wtfk how that's going to go but artic and TG are possible arse so choices.
Posted on Reply
#42
lexluthermiester
TheoneandonlyMrKHas anyone found out how where I genuinely tried no luck.
@lexluthermiester they are illusive reach out how.


Googlefu letting me down, I have some Corsair x50 on the way ?! Wtfk how that's going to go but artic and TG are possible arse so choices.
It's at the end of the article;
support.arctic.de/en/menu/support

At the top of that page there are a pair of phone numbers that might work for you.
Posted on Reply
#43
bug
maxflyHas anyone actually tried the return/replace option since this was posted?
Not for thermal paste, but they recently sent me a free socket 1700 adapter kit. Send the invoice, get a discount code, purchase the goods at 100% discount (incl. shipping), get the goods in ~1 week. As hassle free as it gets imho.
Posted on Reply
#44
eidairaman1
The Exiled Airman
freeagentIf you push the plunger and a bunch of oily stuff comes out that means your TIM has separated and is garbage.
Put it on a paper and remix it
freeagentIt’s all good my man, I have said in the past that I am a massive Thermalright fanboy :D

I almost bought an Arctic LFII 360 more than a few times now.. the shipping is the deal breaker because I am not a fan of the price as it is lol. So I am not entirely against an AIO because a custom loop is not in the cards at this stage.. but I really should educate myself on it because 12 cores man.. only so much air can do and next gen stuff is supposed to be a little more brutal :D
I will still use AS5, along with Arctic, Thermalright, just depends on what i have on hand
Posted on Reply
#45
TheoneandonlyMrK
eidairaman1Put it on a paper and remix it
Well I remixed it In situ, worked well initially but I feel it's re separated after two weeks heavy use, I can't check until I have something to swap it with but can't load that pc up ATM.

It's a bad batch only, it does put me off a bit though.
Posted on Reply
#46
iuliug
Artic support said it will replaced with mx-4 (at double the grams) and requires mx-5 be sent at the cost of user. "Should there ever be any doubts about products we've delivered, we stand by our responsibility to our customers." - i would disagree.
Posted on Reply
#47
TheoneandonlyMrK
iuliugArtic support said it will replaced with mx-4 (at double the grams) and requires mx-5 be sent at the cost of user. "Should there ever be any doubts about products we've delivered, we stand by our responsibility to our customers." - i would disagree.
How's about I spend no more money in ANY way on artic products, because I sure as shit am not shipping thermal paste with it's meager cost of 10£ already spent to get something older at a cost AGAIN to me.

F&£# the f£#@ off artic.
Posted on Reply
#48
maxfly
iuliugArtic support said it will replaced with mx-4 (at double the grams) and requires mx-5 be sent at the cost of user. "Should there ever be any doubts about products we've delivered, we stand by our responsibility to our customers." - i would disagree.
They want you to ship it on your dime?
Then replace it with mx-4?
Mmmmnah. That is unacceptable.
Posted on Reply
#49
bug
maxflyThey want you to ship it on your dime?
Then replace it with mx-4?
Mmmmnah. That is unacceptable.
Shipping alone costs more than buying another paste yourself. So yeah, strange.
Posted on Reply
#50
TheoneandonlyMrK
So I thought I would show whats what with a before and after worth noting the load is world community grid at 60% not 100% and there is less than a minute between pics the first was at a cool ambient of 19 after being idle 10 mins.
the second is after a 15 seconds of load.

Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Jul 24th, 2024 11:29 EDT change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts