Thursday, November 16th 2017
New Studies Reveal MOBA Gamers Having Higher IQs Than FPS Gamers
Researchers at the University of York have discovered a link between young people's ability to perform well at two popular video games and high levels of intelligence. Studies carried out at the Digital Creativity Labs (DC Labs) at York found that some action strategy video games can act like IQ tests. The researchers' findings are published today in the journal PLOS ONE.
The York researchers stress the studies have no bearing on questions such as whether playing computer games makes young people smarter or otherwise. They simply establish a correlation between skill at certain online games of strategy and intelligence. The researchers focused on 'Multiplayer Online Battle Arenas' (MOBAs) - action strategy games that typically involve two opposing teams of five individuals - as well as multiplayer 'First Person Shooter' games. These types of games are hugely popular with hundreds of millions of players worldwide.
The team from York's Departments of Psychology and Computer Science carried out two studies. The first examined a group of subjects who were highly experienced in the MOBA League of Legends - one of the most popular strategic video games in the world with millions of players each day.
In this study, the researchers observed a correlation between performance in the strategic game League of Legends and performance in standard paper-and-pencil intelligence tests.
The second study analyzed big datasets from four games: Two MOBAs (League of Legends and Defense of the Ancients 2 (Dota 2) and two 'First Person Shooters' (Destiny and Battlefield 3). First Person Shooters (FPS) are games involving shooting enemies and other targets, with the player viewing the action as though through the eyes of the character they are controlling.
In this second study, they found that for large groups consisting of thousands of players, performance in MOBAs and IQ behave in similar ways as players get older. But this effect was not found for First Person Shooters, where performance declined after the teens.
The researchers say the correlation between ability at action strategy video games such as League of Legends and Defense of the Ancients 2 (Dota 2) and a high IQ is similar to the correlation seen in other more traditional strategy games such as chess.
Corresponding author Professor Alex Wade of the University of York's Department of Psychology and Digital Creativity Labs said: "Games such as League of Legends and DOTA 2 are complex, socially-interactive and intellectually demanding. Our research would suggest that your performance in these games can be a measure of intelligence.
"Research in the past has pointed to the fact that people who are good at strategy games such as chess tend to score highly at IQ tests. Our research has extended this to games that millions of people across the planet play every day."
The discovery of this correlation between skill and intelligence opens up a huge new data source. For example, as 'proxy' tests of IQ, games could be useful at a global population level in fields such as 'cognitive epidemiology' - research that examines the associations between intelligence and health across time - and as a way of monitoring cognitive health across populations.
Athanasios Kokkinakis, a PhD student with the EPSRC Center for Intelligent Games and Game Intelligence (IGGI) research program at York, is the lead author on the study.
He said: "Unlike First Person Shooter (FPS) games where speed and target accuracy are a priority, Multiplayer Online Battle Arenas rely more on memory and the ability to make strategic decisions taking into account multiple factors.
"It is perhaps for these reasons that we found a strong correlation between skill and intelligence in MOBAs."
Co-author Professor Peter Cowling, Director of DC Labs and the IGGI program at York, said: "This cutting-edge research has the potential for substantial impact on the future of the games and creative industries - and on games as a tool for research in health and psychology.
"The IGGI program has 48 excellent PhD students working with industry and across disciplines - there is plenty more to come!"
The studies were funded by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC).
The York researchers stress the studies have no bearing on questions such as whether playing computer games makes young people smarter or otherwise. They simply establish a correlation between skill at certain online games of strategy and intelligence. The researchers focused on 'Multiplayer Online Battle Arenas' (MOBAs) - action strategy games that typically involve two opposing teams of five individuals - as well as multiplayer 'First Person Shooter' games. These types of games are hugely popular with hundreds of millions of players worldwide.
In this study, the researchers observed a correlation between performance in the strategic game League of Legends and performance in standard paper-and-pencil intelligence tests.
The second study analyzed big datasets from four games: Two MOBAs (League of Legends and Defense of the Ancients 2 (Dota 2) and two 'First Person Shooters' (Destiny and Battlefield 3). First Person Shooters (FPS) are games involving shooting enemies and other targets, with the player viewing the action as though through the eyes of the character they are controlling.
In this second study, they found that for large groups consisting of thousands of players, performance in MOBAs and IQ behave in similar ways as players get older. But this effect was not found for First Person Shooters, where performance declined after the teens.
The researchers say the correlation between ability at action strategy video games such as League of Legends and Defense of the Ancients 2 (Dota 2) and a high IQ is similar to the correlation seen in other more traditional strategy games such as chess.
Corresponding author Professor Alex Wade of the University of York's Department of Psychology and Digital Creativity Labs said: "Games such as League of Legends and DOTA 2 are complex, socially-interactive and intellectually demanding. Our research would suggest that your performance in these games can be a measure of intelligence.
"Research in the past has pointed to the fact that people who are good at strategy games such as chess tend to score highly at IQ tests. Our research has extended this to games that millions of people across the planet play every day."
The discovery of this correlation between skill and intelligence opens up a huge new data source. For example, as 'proxy' tests of IQ, games could be useful at a global population level in fields such as 'cognitive epidemiology' - research that examines the associations between intelligence and health across time - and as a way of monitoring cognitive health across populations.
Athanasios Kokkinakis, a PhD student with the EPSRC Center for Intelligent Games and Game Intelligence (IGGI) research program at York, is the lead author on the study.
He said: "Unlike First Person Shooter (FPS) games where speed and target accuracy are a priority, Multiplayer Online Battle Arenas rely more on memory and the ability to make strategic decisions taking into account multiple factors.
"It is perhaps for these reasons that we found a strong correlation between skill and intelligence in MOBAs."
Co-author Professor Peter Cowling, Director of DC Labs and the IGGI program at York, said: "This cutting-edge research has the potential for substantial impact on the future of the games and creative industries - and on games as a tool for research in health and psychology.
"The IGGI program has 48 excellent PhD students working with industry and across disciplines - there is plenty more to come!"
The studies were funded by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC).
33 Comments on New Studies Reveal MOBA Gamers Having Higher IQs Than FPS Gamers
if that is true that would be due to more many people playing FPS therefore many noobs/newbies are playing FPS
i personally know many mmorpg players who arent quite high IQed
Any game that is played on a high level requires a high degree of skill. Even the simplest of concepts like Tetris or Mario Kart, that a five year old can grasp, can be played at an extreme level. But each of them develops a different skillset. IQ is a blunt instrument went it comes to measuring 'intelligence' - there is only one scale.