Monday, March 11th 2019
Maxon Sends Legal Threats to PC Enthusiast Websites Hosting Portable Cinebench R20 Downloads
Maxon last week week posted its Cinebench R20 CPU benchmark. Breaking convention, the company behind rendering software such as Cinema 4D R20, did not host the installer of Cinebench R20 on its own website. Instead, the software is being exclusively distributed through Microsoft Store (for Windows) and Apple App Store (for the MacOS platform). Several reputable PC enthusiast websites such as Guru3D and us, were bombarded by comments from their readers that they didn't like having to get their Cinebench R20 copy from "walled garden DRM platforms," and instead preferred portable versions of the software. Cinebench R20 is freeware, and so with good intentions, many PC enthusiast websites decided to build portable versions of Cinebench R20 that people can just unzip and run. Maxon did not take kindly to this.
Guru3D received legal threats from Maxon to take down their download hosting of Cinebench R20 portable. Facing these threats, Guru3D took down their download and amended their news articles with links to the Microsoft DRM store. The e-mail we received politely asked us to remove the "unauthorized download" but did include a threat that the company "reserves the next legal steps." We believe this behavior by Maxon is unfair, and will alienate a section of PC enthusiasts form Cinebench. No record-seeking PC enthusiast with an LN2 bench painstakingly set up has time to plug their machine to the Internet, launch the UWP store, evade attempts to get them to log in with a Microsoft account, and fetch Cinebench R20 with versions they have no control over. They'd rather install and run their benchmarks and tools off a flash drive, with control over versions, and the ability to keep their machines offline to stabilize their overclock. Many others simply hate DRM platforms for freeware. TechPowerUp has since taken down Cinebench R20 portable from its Downloads section. You can find it on Microsoft UWP Store.
Guru3D received legal threats from Maxon to take down their download hosting of Cinebench R20 portable. Facing these threats, Guru3D took down their download and amended their news articles with links to the Microsoft DRM store. The e-mail we received politely asked us to remove the "unauthorized download" but did include a threat that the company "reserves the next legal steps." We believe this behavior by Maxon is unfair, and will alienate a section of PC enthusiasts form Cinebench. No record-seeking PC enthusiast with an LN2 bench painstakingly set up has time to plug their machine to the Internet, launch the UWP store, evade attempts to get them to log in with a Microsoft account, and fetch Cinebench R20 with versions they have no control over. They'd rather install and run their benchmarks and tools off a flash drive, with control over versions, and the ability to keep their machines offline to stabilize their overclock. Many others simply hate DRM platforms for freeware. TechPowerUp has since taken down Cinebench R20 portable from its Downloads section. You can find it on Microsoft UWP Store.
149 Comments on Maxon Sends Legal Threats to PC Enthusiast Websites Hosting Portable Cinebench R20 Downloads
It first I was very happy that they finally released new version to be relevant in 2019 with all the new CPU's, but forcing Windows store? not cool.
They could just add windows store as another download source, and as mentioned before- what Win 7 users should do?
Instead of sending out legal threats they should just make their own portable version to share...
Maybe their strategy is "OS price down, 'app' monetarization up"? Turning indeed the OS into a portal. "Hey mama!! Look, just like Android and iOS!"
That doesn't look like "marked as not for resale"
Great example of: "left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing ".
www.techpowerup.com/download/linpack-xtreme/
It is completely portable, just 8MB in size, cross-platform, supports MP platforms and uses the latest instructions sets.
No need to download 200MB files from MS Store.
Linpack is brutal. Though I agree, its a good one and pretty stable across many years too.
DRM? DRM depends mostly on the app itself, not so much the Store. The apps choose whether or not to implement some form of DRM. The Store only records that you've downloaded the app and that it should be kept updated, if it is installed. If you login with a MS account, it just means that the Store will remember everything you've ever acquired, even if you reinstall the OS. And why the hell would Cinebench launch from the Store if there was any kind of DRM that could affect its performance? I'd like to believe they thought about that.
Walled-garden? Seriously? Microsoft isn't forcing anyone to ditch the classic Win32/Win64 software and run everything from the Store. This isn't iOS, or even Android, and Microsoft knows that.
On the other hand, the site says Cinebench supports Windows 7... So, where is the installer for Windows 7? Or is it something they forgot to change during the launch?
The target audience is overclockers, it isn't your average facebook dweller.
hwbot only considers windows7 submissions as valid for r15, and will likely be the case for r20.
You shouldn't start blurting out linux nonsense when you don't understand who this software is for.
Since it is Maxon’s property, and distribution is up to them, then respecting their wishes keeps TPU safe from lawsuit. I really would hate to see TPU facing legal action it can ill afford just because TPU insisted it is “free.”
In the long run, it is better reputation-wise throughout the tech community to to be seen as respecting their wishes. Even if it is obtained at the Microsoft store, promoting R20 is also a bad idea, given Maxon’s stance, and would further embolden them. I say don’t even pay it any attention.
I'm still rocking Windows 7 and i'm gonna use it until it dies .
How i was suppose to download it from the MS Store?
Someone didn't switch on the brain .
Glad i got it before was removed.