Wednesday, May 19th 2010

EU Slaps Chip Vendors with Penalties for Price-Fixing

As many as nine major chip vendors were fined a total of 331 million Euros (US $404.2 million) for participating in illegal price-fixing activities, by the European Union authorities. These include Samsung, Hynix, Nanya, Elpida, Infineon, NEC, Toshiba, Hitachi, and Mitsubishi. A 10th company in this price-fixing cartel was Micron Technology, which escaped the fine for exposing the malpractice to the EU authorities. Of these Samsung was given the single biggest fine of 146 million Euros, followed by Infineon at 57 million Euros. The fines were reduced by 10% because all companies extended cooperation in the investigations.

The price-fixing cartel mostly involved bad trade of DRAM chips, and was active between 1998 and 2002, operating with a network of contacts which secretly exchanged pricing information. They colluded to fix prices of DRAM chips sold to major PC and server manufacturers. Investigations in the scam began in 2002 when Micron blew the whistle on the cartel. "By acknowledging their participation in a cartel the companies have allowed the Commission to bring this long-running investigation to a close and to free up resources to investigate other suspected cartels," said EU's Competition Commissioner, Joaquin Almunia. "As the procedure is applied to new cases it is expected to speed up investigations significantly," he added.
Source: BBC News
Add your own comment

46 Comments on EU Slaps Chip Vendors with Penalties for Price-Fixing

#26
Zubasa
tiggerThe ram in my machine is actually worth more secondhand now than what i paid for it new.
Yup I sold my Corsair DDR3 1333 kit and made a small fortune :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#27
TheMailMan78
Big Member
Hmmmm Greece gets a bailout and all of a sudden the EU lays out a blanket of "lawsuits". I call BS.
Posted on Reply
#28
robn
Nah the EU's just horribly inefficient ...more likely paid a greater sum to their lawyers than they made in fines.
Posted on Reply
#29
AsRock
TPU addict
FreedomEclipseQFT

nobody puts the money back into the consumers pocket - the real victims. especially for us Brits....everything is so unbelievably expensive here (=__=)
Tell me about it now i pay US prices :). Even some of my family come over get stuff.
Posted on Reply
#30
Valdez
FreedomEclipseespecially for us Brits....everything is so unbelievably expensive here (=__=)
poooor Brits :(
Posted on Reply
#31
seedvt
Well, Infineon is already bankrupt, and I don't think they have many remaining assets to be seized.
Posted on Reply
#32
Zubasa
seedvtWell, Infineon is already bankrupt, and I don't think they have many remaining assets to be seized.
You mean Qimonda :p
Posted on Reply
#33
chaotic_uk
me thinks the EU is getting greedy again tbh
Posted on Reply
#34
ToTTenTranz
A 10th company in this price-fixing cartel was Micron Technology, which escaped the fine for exposing the malpractice to the EU authorities.
LOL, the mole got away!
Posted on Reply
#35
zithe
FreedomEclipseQFT

nobody puts the money back into the consumers pocket - the real victims. especially for us Brits....everything is so unbelievably expensive here (=__=)
Then the gov't would owe people for the difference. Easier to just fine them.
Posted on Reply
#37
xtremesv
What about today??? $70 for 2GB DDR3???? Come on!!! The fine was for something that happened 9 years ago. Who assures us that this same thing is not happening just now? :shadedshu
Posted on Reply
#38
cadaveca
My name is Dave
xtremesvWhat about today??? $70 for 2GB DDR3???? Come on!!! The fine was for something that happened 9 years ago. Who assures us that this same thing is not happening just now? :shadedshu
We don't buy from these businesses in the first place any more. You can thank OCZ, Mushkin, Corsair, Kingston, et al, for that.

They buy the DIMMs for cheap(even if they assemble them). REAL CHEAP. Many people, who work at these companies, get food put on thier plates for the increased cost. They can only lower prices so much.

Do you read the tech news? Staff at Foxconn are killing themselves from having such crappy jobs. If ya want cheap parts, that's what it takes.
Posted on Reply
#39
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
TheMailMan78Hmmmm Greece gets a bailout and all of a sudden the EU lays out a blanket of "lawsuits". I call BS.
Greece's bailout is more like 90~100 billion Euros. This penalty is peanuts compared to that. So no, that bullshit is unfounded.
Posted on Reply
#41
NdMk2o1o
pr0n InspectorFine them some more, greedy EU.
Honestly this and the mailmans comment have to be the dumbest on this thread so far :slap:

I am so sick of hearing a select few have a pop at the EU for every little thing they see posted in the news section, heck you wanna talk lawsuits? the grand ol US of A invented them. You cant breath over there for someone filing a lawsuit about something or other.

And by the way I am not from the EU, I am from the UK though the ignorant few of you dont even know the bloody difference or that we dont even have the same currencies.

heres a couple of nice things to try, go and google EU IT Lawsuits and then google US IT Lawsuits.

Whilst some are happy in their bubbles please dont spout about others when you need only look closer to home.
Posted on Reply
#42
TheMailMan78
Big Member
btarunrGreece's bailout is more like 90~100 billion Euros. This penalty is peanuts compared to that. So no, that bullshit is unfounded.
Every little bit counts. But I agree. The two are unrelated directly.
NdMk2o1oHonestly this and the mailmans comment have to be the dumbest on this thread so far :slap:

I am so sick of hearing a select few have a pop at the EU for every little thing they see posted in the news section, heck you wanna talk lawsuits? the grand ol US of A invented them. You cant breath over there for someone filing a lawsuit about something or other.

And by the way I am not from the EU, I am from the UK though the ignorant few of you dont even know the bloody difference or that we dont even have the same currencies.

heres a couple of nice things to try, go and google EU IT Lawsuits and then google US IT Lawsuits.

Whilst some are happy in their bubbles please dont spout about others when you need only look closer to home.
I couldn't agree more. The U.S. goverment could teach the EU on pointless lawsuits. I called BS on my own goverment years ago :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#43
ToTTenTranz
TheMailMan78I couldn't agree more. The U.S. goverment could teach the EU on pointless lawsuits. I called BS on my own goverment years ago :laugh:
LOL, it's actually happening the other way around.

Every time the EU successfully pins down a company for market rules violation, the FTC follows the example and does the exact same thing.
Just check what happened with Intel and Microsoft. The EU gets them and some months later we hear the FTC is doing the exact same investigation.
Posted on Reply
#44
btarunr
Editor & Senior Moderator
TheMailMan78Every little bit counts. But I agree. The two are unrelated directly.
Every bit? This penalty is 0.3% of Greece's bailout. Besides EU has the money to bail Greece out.

Actually it has more to do with German and French governments wanting to bail their banks who lent to Greece out, because if Greece defaults, those banks are screwed.
Posted on Reply
#45
Easy Rhino
Linux Advocate
btarunrEvery bit? This penalty is 0.3% of Greece's bailout. Besides EU has the money to bail Greece out.

Actually it has more to do with German and French governments wanting to bail their banks who lent to Greece out, because if Greece defaults, those banks are screwed.
we are all screwed because in reality we all operate just like greece. oh well. enjoy being able to afford computers while it lasts.
Posted on Reply
#46
cadaveca
My name is Dave
Easy Rhino;1900017 enjoy being able to afford computers while it lasts.[/QUOTEI was kinda thinking the same thing...what if that gulf oil spill travelled all the way up to Iceland...with it's active volcano...I dunno about you, but I'm envisioning the entire eastern coastal waters going up in flames.

And people are worried about money? :laugh:
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Jan 5th, 2025 13:10 EST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts