Thursday, May 4th 2023

US Government Targeting Crypto Miners With Proposed Energy Bill Tax

The US Government is considering new plans that will attempt to curb the after effects of cryptocurrency mining. The White House revealed details about its proposed "DAME Tax" scheme on Tuesday of this week - the Digital Asset Mining Energy excise tax is under consideration for this year's US Budget. The government wants to address the impact that cryptomining has on the US economy as well as the environment, alongside numerous other national challenges. Companies engaged in the extraction of cryptocurrencies could be charged extra for the running of computer equipment (starting in early 2024). A White House spokesperson states: "after a phase-in period, firms would face a tax equal to 30 percent of the cost of the electricity they use in cryptomining."

American crypto companies are facing a 10 percent taxation of their energy bill for 2024, that will then increase to 20 percent in 2025, and the maximum tax rate will hit a high of 30 percent in 2026. The White House number crunching team reckons that $3.5 billion could be generated by the proposed DAME excise tax. The new rules would represent a radical change for large scale cryptomining efforts: "Currently, cryptomining firms do not have to pay for the full cost they impose on others, in the form of local environmental pollution, higher energy prices, and the impacts of increased greenhouse gas emissions on the climate. The DAME tax encourages firms to start taking better account of the harms they impose on society," reads a White House statement." The government's investigation has determined that the domestic cryptomining industry is close to consuming more electricity than the entire nation's residential lighting system. US lawmakers last year calculated that some of the larger digital asset mining firms are capable of using more energy than nearly all of the residential population based in Houston, TX.
Sources: White House Statement, The Register, Guardian UK
Add your own comment

103 Comments on US Government Targeting Crypto Miners With Proposed Energy Bill Tax

#51
kondamin
jigar2speedHow about -10% tax to people who have solar panel, they are assisting in maintaining grid power right ?
They are putting a load on a network not built for local production.
I don’t know about the us but here in Belgium and the Netherlands people with solar panels are getting their inverters turned of to stop the grid from failing.

solar is great if you are somewhere in the boonies and don’t have a connection to the grid.
for everyone else its a financial tool If properly managed and the government incentives get used fully.

the environment would be far better off if the damn things were never invented.
a big nuclear plant and geothermal/hydro for base load and large the bigger the better wind turbines would be infinitely better
Posted on Reply
#52
80251
@kondamin
Don't they have safer, more efficient NPP designs now? I remember reading something about salt reactors (where some sort of salt, not necessarily NaCl, is the heat transfer medium).
Posted on Reply
#53
phubar
80251the British government was taking 50% of his earnings, so he left and Ringo Starr and Keith Richards. The Beatles at some point were looking into buying an entire Greek island for themselves.
Yeah I don't care. 50% of tens or hundreds of millions still means you're filthy rich by anyone's standards.
80251Billionaires can ALWAYS relocate somewhere else, Elon Musk could buy a house (or island) in another country and be out of the USA anytime he wants. Other countries WANT their money and maybe even a lot less of it.
Many places, including the US, already have laws on the books that allow them to tax people when they move their money around, or want to sell their goods in a given jurisdiction, etc.

They can move anywhere they want it doesn't matter if their money is in the global banking system. If the govt. wants your money they can get at it.
80251Don't they have safer, more efficient NPP designs now? I remember reading something about salt reactors (where some sort of salt, not necessarily NaCl, is the heat transfer medium).
Molten salt reactors are still pretty new and while several have been built they're just really getting into the commercialization phase and out of development: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molten_salt_reactor

Nuke reactors are great and all but unless you're willing to go France's route (that is heavily standardized on 1 or 2 designs that are mass produced AND ran by the govt not the power companies, they'll screw it up trying to save a buck or 2) they're not worth bothering with.
Posted on Reply
#54
(MAD)Joao
Can we tax the USA gov for the emissions of all the jets, battleships, submarines, rockets to moon...etc ? :laugh:
Posted on Reply
#55
Redwoodz
Thank goodness. Make sure the tax rate is sufficient to make it completely unprofitable. Crypto is a completely useless so it should be.
Posted on Reply
#56
kondamin
80251@kondamin
Don't they have safer, more efficient NPP designs now? I remember reading something about salt reactors (where some sort of salt, not necessarily NaCl, is the heat transfer medium).
Current generation reactors are safe, they are a bitch to tear down but they are safe.
Posted on Reply
#57
Penev91
Although I got out of crypto a long time ago this sounds absolutely stupid.
I have 3 workstations and 2 gaming PCs in my house that combined use more electricity than what 14 of my mining rigs used to consume.
If this is allowed then nothing will stop them to put an electricity tax on gamers in a few years, especially if nvidia keeps launching 500 watt GPUs.
Posted on Reply
#58
TumbleGeorge
Penev91Although I got out of crypto a long time ago this sounds absolutely stupid.
I have 3 workstations and 2 gaming PCs in my house that combined use more electricity than what 14 of my mining rigs used to consume.
If this is allowed then nothing will stop them to put an electricity tax on gamers in a few years, especially if nvidia keeps launching 500 watt GPUs.
Brother, you are not thinking right. Something is fundamentally wrong with your head. The currently owned computers listed are hardly used 24/7 at full capacity. There is no basis for comparison with the consumption of a mining farm that draws electricity for weeks and perhaps months non-stop.
Posted on Reply
#59
JimmyDoogs
Crypto sucks, that's why we should tax it. Has nothing to do with power use to me. It's a waste of our high end fabrication facilities. There's people in here that are probably wall street bros saying how it's a good thing. Not for me dude. It's made several generations of GPUs AND cars more expensive? You're just exploiting people like me having to pay more for things so you can make a quick dime. I don't care if it's helped AI and machine learning, those things will do fine in the end and what do you directly gain out of those things right now? I've lost money for this crap. NFTs and everything crypto is the butt of jokes. Ban Crypto.
Posted on Reply
#60
AnotherReader
JimmyDoogsI don't care if it's helped AI and machine learning, those things will do fine in the end and what do you directly gain out of those things right now? I've lost money for this crap. NFTs and everything crypto is the butt of jokes. Ban Crypto.
I agree with you, but Crypto didn't help AI. It was PC gaming that helped AI take off by providing cheap, massively parallel processing hardware.
Posted on Reply
#61
dragontamer5788
R0H1TNot from the US but how do you explain the Fed (FDIC?) essentially backstopping all deposits in those large banks?
Fed, FDIC, Treasury are all different groups doing different things. USA's government is split into different groups and they don't necessarily do the same thing.

The Fed, aka: the Federal Reserve, sets interest rates in the country. By raising interest rates, the Fed destroys money.

FDIC is another group. They insure banks. But FDIC only has a few hundred-billion bucks. The Federal Reserve is in control of trillions. I pay attention to Federal Reserve because their actions are more important with regards to M2 action (ie: how much money is growing, or shrinking in this country). Totally different people, totally different mechanisms. FDIC's job is to ensure that banks remain stable by regulating and investigating banks. Or, should the regulations fail, then FDIC will backstop our bank accounts, or find a buyer for an ailing bank. (FDIC didn't backstop FRC's collapse for example. FDIC went out and convinced JPMorgan to buy FRC)

US Treasury is in charge of paying the US Government's bills and our debt. Totally different people, again.
Posted on Reply
#62
AusWolf
TumbleGeorgeNot quite, obviously, but the impact of training consumers from infancy to the Western(not only US) model and supporting the training throughout their lives with advertising messages and other media ploys towards over-purchasing is another topic and perhaps even another forum.
Ps. People are being trained as fighting dogs. To buy in excess is not necessarily of their own volition. But they are unable to realize it.
I somewhat agree, but if that's the whole truth, then why can I and so many others make the destinction between needs and wants?
Posted on Reply
#63
AnotherReader
AusWolfI somewhat agree, but if that's the whole truth, then why can I and so many others make the destinction between needs and wants?
In my case, I would have to credit my parents with helping me with impulse control while growing up. Of course, that isn't applicable to everyone.
Posted on Reply
#64
Penev91
TumbleGeorgeBrother, you are not thinking right. Something is fundamentally wrong with your head. The currently owned computers listed are hardly used 24/7 at full capacity. There is no basis for comparison with the consumption of a mining farm that draws electricity for weeks and perhaps months non-stop.
You're completely missing the point.
Mark my words and watch what happens. If this bill passes, sooner or later americans will be charged with extra tax just for running their ACs and refrigerators 24/7. It may not happen within the next 10 years but it will happen eventually and this bill will be the gateway for them to ask for extra bullshit taxes.
Posted on Reply
#65
AusWolf
Penev91You're completely missing the point.
Mark my words and watch what happens. If this bill passes, sooner or later americans will be charged with extra tax just for running their ACs and refrigerators 24/7. It may not happen within the next 10 years but it will happen eventually and this bill will be the gateway for them to ask for extra bullshit taxes.
ACs and refrigerators have been running 24/7 for decades, but no one made a single penny/cent profit out of it (refrigerators aren't money making machines, obviously).

It's not about the environment. It's about money, as always. Crypto is a source of income, that's why mining gets taxed, and in my opinion, it should have been from the point of its invention.
Posted on Reply
#66
TumbleGeorge
Penev91You're completely missing the point.
Mark my words and watch what happens. If this bill passes, sooner or later americans will be charged with extra tax just for running their ACs and refrigerators 24/7. It may not happen within the next 10 years but it will happen eventually and this bill will be the gateway for them to ask for extra bullshit taxes.
This conspiracy completely confirms my conclusions.
Posted on Reply
#67
R-T-B
TumbleGeorgeAnyone who doesn't call crypto a crime is almost certainly a criminal himself.
I hate this kind of logic. I don't support crypto-mining anymore, but I did for years, it's easy to be misguided. I'm still not a criminal.
AusWolfACs and refrigerators have been running 24/7 for decades, but no one made a single penny/cent profit out of it (refrigerators aren't money making machines, obviously).

It's not about the environment. It's about money, as always. Crypto is a source of income, that's why mining gets taxed, and in my opinion, it should have been from the point of its invention.
Also, people miss this, but most electric companies already charge you extra if you pass a set bracket of usage, no government intervention needed.
(MAD)JoaoCan we tax the USA gov for the emissions of all the jets, battleships, submarines, rockets to moon...etc ? :laugh:
The USA government doesn't make virtually any of those products anymore... all private contracts. So yes.
Posted on Reply
#68
Paranoir andando
The spanish robbers say in the banks: "DAME la Pasta"
US Government says "DAME Tax"
World is so funny. We all know who orders it.
Posted on Reply
#69
evilpaul
axiomlol it's not the government who is trying or needing to make money in this scenario.
sure now they want to profit that they know the greedy bastards have been sucking up so much power...
but the culprits are and have been vaguely degen's scamming midwesterners and 3rd worlders on r/memestonks .

Software bros really are some of the most clueless people when it comes to morality I have ever encountered ....

arresting someone isn't about making money in a democratic society it's about preserving the balance and order needed to avoid social chaos, and holding people accountable for stealing resources and scamming people in this case.

Those people are causing social decline with their behaviors tertiary to the act of the mining itself- the way they recruit people is like a ponzi scheme and they've got nvidia in on it and a bunch of foreign actors; now they're about to blow out the power grid.

Should put a stop to it, can only assume at this point the gov't must be complicit for not acting more swiftly
Internet porn uses more electricity than crypto mining. The banking industry uses more electricity than crypto mining. Literally, nearly anything that can be described as an "industry" uses more electricity than crypto.

The US government is going after crypto because people having sound money that the USG can't silently confiscate via inflation, and control via censorship and sanctions, is a threat to their flaccid dying empire. What's the carbon footprint of having a military larger than the next ten largest militaries combined with close to 1,000 bases all over the planet? It's a lot.

You have zero clue how the power grid works, how much electricity is used by various industries and services, and are pitching braindead conspiracy theories. Being the most blood-thirsty, warlike people in the history of the world with a rapidly declining currency, only interacting with neighboring countries to bully or destroy them, and ever growing wealth gap between the rich and everyone else domestically might be causing more "social decline" than fucking doggy coins.
Posted on Reply
#70
TumbleGeorge
The numbers only for $hitcoin*Numbers are for the world total.
Now imagine how energy, how is big footprint for all kinds of crypto.
Posted on Reply
#71
80251
Thanks TumbleGeorge for cutting through the veneer of lies of cryptocurrency propagandists.
Posted on Reply
#72
kondamin
80251Thanks TumbleGeorge for cutting through the veneer of lies of cryptocurrency propagandists.
You live in a nation and are making a nice living, suddenly that nation sees an evil government take power and you have no option but to flee.

situation a) you have some btc tucked away somewhere hidden on the internet.
situation b) you only have money in the bank a bank that was ordered by the government to lock your accounts because your are some sort of evil.

which one is the best scenario
Posted on Reply
#73
dragontamer5788
kondaminYou live in a nation and are making a nice living, suddenly that nation sees an evil government take power and you have no option but to flee.

situation a) you have some btc tucked away somewhere hidden on the internet.
situation b) you only have money in the bank a bank that was ordered by the government to lock your accounts because your are some sort of evil.

which one is the best scenario
Let's say you're my coworker and you put your money in Celsius.

Oh right. All that money is gone, and there weren't any evil governments that popped out and stole his money.

It's just an average month in Cryptoland. Celsius, Voyager, FTX, Mt. Gox.

Your money was safer in pretty much everything else than in Cryptocoin.
Posted on Reply
#74
phubar
evilpaulInternet porn uses more electricity than crypto mining.
LOL no it doesn't. Its not even close. Making (snapping pics or filming a movie IOW) and looking at porn (aka looking at a webpage) aren't high power use cases like crypto mining.
evilpaulThe banking industry uses more electricity than crypto mining. Literally, nearly anything that can be described as an "industry" uses more electricity than crypto.
None of this is true. Crypto uses more power than several small countries and is easily one of the most power hungry use cases out there in computing since it requires running huge numbers of GPU's, each consuming hundreds of watts typically, as hard as possible 24/7.
evilpaulThe US government is going after crypto because people having sound money that the USG can't silently confiscate via inflation, and control via censorship and sanctions, is a threat to their flaccid dying empire.
Yeah this is conspiracy BS that doesn't even hold up with just a smidge of knowledge about the real world.

After all if crypto is "sound money" then why does the value flucutate madly? Or rugpulls happen all the time by the people who you should supposedly trust in cryptoland? Or that its treated more as a stock than a currency by litterally everyone? Or things like wash trades, exchanges front running their own clients, and essentially 0 actual professional accounting occur constantly?

Hell pretty much all these crypto currencies were created out of nothing in the first place and they just keep cutting 1 unit of their "currency" into infinitely smaller pieces anyways!
evilpaulWhat's the carbon footprint of having a military larger than the next ten largest militaries combined with close to 1,000 bases all over the planet? It's a lot.
The military actually has some sort've real world value and purpose though. Buttcoins exist solely to scam people.
Posted on Reply
#75
R-T-B
dragontamer5788Let's say you're my coworker and you put your money in Celsius.

Oh right. All that money is gone, and there weren't any evil governments that popped out and stole his money.

It's just an average month in Cryptoland. Celsius, Voyager, FTX, Mt. Gox.

Your money was safer in pretty much everything else than in Cryptocoin.
I mean if you were fleeing a country and
used an exchange wallet you were doing it wrong.

The correct answer is the situation is contrived. Use fucking cash.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Feb 22nd, 2025 17:53 EST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

Controversial News Posts