Sunday, November 15th 2026

Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron Fail to Get DRAM Antitrust Suit Dismissed

The class-action lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron of restricting DRAM supply is moving forward. On November 14, U.S. District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied the three companies' joint motion to dismiss, finding the complaint plausibly alleges an agreement in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The suit, filed in June by 17 consumers and small businesses, claims the trio, which held over 91% of global DRAM revenue as of Q3 2025, coordinated production cuts starting in late 2022 and shifted capacity toward HBM while conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months. Of course, it's a pleading-stage ruling, and nothing has been proven yet.

The companies argued the case was a rerun of an earlier suit over 2016 to 2018 supply cuts, which the Ninth Circuit threw out in 2022. Judge Wise disagreed, pointing to newer alleged conduct like long-term HBM contracts, Samsung and SK hynix allegedly refusing long-term deals with conventional DRAM buyers, Micron shutting down Crucial, and near-identical customer vetting questions all three adopted in January 2026. She also turned the companies' own hawk comparison around, writing that the alleged conduct is more like "hawks flying in formation."
The three now have until December 7 to answer the complaint, with an initial case management conference set for January 12, 2027. The judge also refused to ignore the 1998 to 2002 DRAM cartel, where Samsung and Hynix paid fines, and Micron got immunity. Despite all this, a lawsuit won't add any wafers, and with SK hynix's CEO expecting the shortage to last through 2030, readers shouldn't count on cheaper memory anytime soon. Still, this one will be interesting to keep an eye on.
Source: LitNews
Add your own comment

49 Comments on Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron Fail to Get DRAM Antitrust Suit Dismissed

#1
shuffy_losys
I don't expect this to add manufacturing capacity, but at the least I hope they get something for doing bullying tactics like "you pay this much or we're never talking to you again."
Posted on Reply
#2
Athena
coordinated production cuts starting in late 2022 and shifted capacity toward HBM while conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months
It takes DRAM to make HBM, so this makes no sense
Sure, they allocated more DRAM to HBM, since that is where the $ is, but they didn't cut DRAM making, they did the opposite, demand is just super high because the artificial buying from the AI idiots who write them blank checks no matter the price, and it takes years to get a new fab up and running, not to mention billions of $
Posted on Reply
#3
TumbleGeorge
AthenaIt takes DRAM to make HBM, so this makes no sense
Sure, they allocated more DRAM to HBM, since that is where the $ is, but they didn't cut DRAM making, they did the opposite, demand is just super high because the artificial buying from the AI idiots who write them blank checks no matter the price, and it takes years to get a new fab up and running, not to mention billions of $
If things was so "simple" the case will be not started.
Posted on Reply
#4
Hecate91
Good, the memory cartel shouldn't be getting away without a lawsuit, although they're so powerful now any fine for colluding to raise prices is a slap on the wrist.
Posted on Reply
#5
TumbleGeorge
Hecate91Good, the memory cartel shouldn't be getting away without a lawsuit, although they're so powerful now any fine for colluding to raise prices is a slap on the wrist.
The court decision is more containing not only impose fines. It can also order companies to take action to end price fixing.
Posted on Reply
#6
Denver
Well, well, well... so, Huang was a stumbling block, preventing the legal battles from moving forward.

Posted on Reply
#8
yfn_ratchet
It's a Christmas miracle, come early! I'm elated to hear that this is being sustained. Another block on the pile of terrible news for the greedy-ass fools who've kept this charade going on far too long.
Posted on Reply
#9
Solaris17
Super Dainty Moderator
Hecate91Good, the memory cartel shouldn't be getting away without a lawsuit, although they're so powerful now any fine for colluding to raise prices is a slap on the wrist.
I agree, the monitary slap is meaningless for companies that posted 157% over normal, its just going through the motions. This imo is all about visibility. Its wild they have all been caught doing it before.
Posted on Reply
#10
jesdals
Well not much going to change by this but at least there is some justice
Posted on Reply
#11
TumbleGeorge
Solaris17I agree, the monitary slap is meaningless for companies that posted 157% over normal, its just going through the motions. This imo is all about visibility. Its wild they have all been caught doing it before.
It may seem that way, but no one wants to lose real money because of fines, and they gain additional meaning when combined with other measures, and I am convinced that if the case against them is won, all possible measures will be imposed due to recidivism.
Posted on Reply
#12
b1k3rdude
And its about bloody time these companies faced the music, this will be the 2nd or 3rd time these companies have pulled this kind of stunt and been prosecuted for it. Let hope the punishment this time is extremely severe, as they have seemingly not learned from the previous punishment/s.
Posted on Reply
#13
notoperable
surprise, because tthe haven't done it already 20 years ago. no, memory scarcity per pphone call
Posted on Reply
#14
Vincero
The fact that the judgement even highlights the point that Micron shut down their consumer arm alongside blocking sales to other kit makers to focus on their own sales to DC customers...

Posted on Reply
#15
maxli86
TBH this I agree, here in SG.
Regardless of DRAM brands whether Corsair, G.skill, ADATA, Klevv.
Prices are more or less the same.
Before the AI boom DRAM prices were not like this.
ADATA and Klevv used to be very cheap prices like DDR5 32GB around $200 - 300.
Since AI race started, nowadays DDR5 32GB is around $800 regardless of brand.
How is this not price fixation I do not know and prices around online are also more
or less the same with retailers.
Posted on Reply
#16
_roman_
I really wonder if any state can demand them to continue on making DRAM. Intel and AMD could make another die which supports HBM for their consumer processors.

Who states that a company has to sell to any costomers or certain customers? the micron brand earned low income and was shut down. that is just the usual business decission.

Will those states pay micron and others to change production and the losses with changing business fields? The free market, sell the highest selling product and get rid of the low income ones. Low income ones were crucial.

Micron shut donw Crucial. Something does not fit. I still see quite often Micron DRAM and nvme on sale on the best price website. I should not have seen any micron products in 2026, but i saw plenty of price deals - prices cheaper as the competitors. I even saw SATA 2.5" Micron storage quite often on sale, i think it was ddr5 desktop dimm modules also recently. all from micron.

I do not see the issue to get rid of the low income Desktop DRAM segment
coordinated production cuts starting in late 2022 and shifted capacity toward HBM
There is no money in 2x8Gib DDR4 DRAM from Crucial wiht the amazon surplus charge with 52€, which includes amazon asking for more money, shipping, tax.

or 2x16Gib DDR4 DRAM from crucial for 150€. That is not worth it to make

120gb were 49€ for crucial without considering inflation
8X 50 = 400€ -> when you consider inflation, 1tb should be 500€

i know i paid for 2tb wd m2 nvme wiht dedicated dram very fast only 250€ +10€ a few weeks ago. that is half of what it should have cost.

Low price segments need to be cut.

I could have used the higher price of 63€ for 120gb sata curcial drive from year 2017 also. which should give far more than only 500€ for 1tb.
numbers are based on my amazon purchased order from the past
Posted on Reply
#17
Vincero
_roman_Who states that a company has to sell to any costomers or certain customers? the micron brand earned low income and was shut down. that is just the usual business decission.
As per Google:
Antitrust law is a body of legislation and regulation designed to promote open market competition, prevent monopolies, and stop unfair business practices like price-fixing and cartels.

Purposely excluding certain customers without cause (e.g. poor/overdue credit), and colluding to constrain supply... Fits the bill perfectly.

They can argue the toss in court
Posted on Reply
#18
wNotyarD
DrUsmanSaleemDistrict Judge Noël Wise
Interesting surname for a judge 😂

Getting on-topic, I hope it ends with some hefty penalty for all involved, and not only some slaps in their hands.
Posted on Reply
#19
mechtech
well about time, something is better than nothing

Posted on Reply
#20
mama
Slowly but surely the screws are tightening on anti consumer AI hype opportunists. With the AI hype master himself receeding into the background, maybe some normality can be restored to industry segments.
Posted on Reply
#21
Chaitanya
lexluthermiesterExcellent! And I hope it hits them hard.
Sadly in previous instance we have Crucial being sleazeballs and playing USA card to US courts to get out of getting penalized.
Posted on Reply
#22
Athena
VinceroAs per Google:
Antitrust law is a body of legislation and regulation designed to promote open market competition, prevent monopolies, and stop unfair business practices like price-fixing and cartels.

Purposely excluding certain customers without cause (e.g. poor/overdue credit), and colluding to constrain supply... Fits the bill perfectly.

They can argue the toss in court
They need to prove collusion, that all 3 got together and said they will artificially create shortages, to force price increases, and that is not what is going on, they got buyers for anything and everything that they can make, for years

It doesn't matter that they are switching lines to make more HBM, they are following the $, and there isn't any law that limits what you can and can't make, it's up to the company that makes it, and they are going after the best decision for THEM, and if they don't do this, they could be sued by shareholders
maxli86TBH this I agree, here in SG.
Regardless of DRAM brands whether Corsair, G.skill, ADATA, Klevv.
Prices are more or less the same.
Before the AI boom DRAM prices were not like this.
ADATA and Klevv used to be very cheap prices like DDR5 32GB around $200 - 300.
Since AI race started, nowadays DDR5 32GB is around $800 regardless of brand.
How is this not price fixation I do not know and prices around online are also more
or less the same with retailers.
It's not price fixing since you got big players that are spending to buy RAM at ANY price, and all the fabs are pretty much at almost 100%, and the makers are not withholding supply

This is supply & demand at work, the same thing happened to wood, framing lumber skyrocketed to $1,500/1k feet since demand was so great
Now, since demand isn't, it's back down to under $500/1k feet

In order for it to be price fixing, then all 3 must get together and say that they are all going to charge $X, and limit production
You can clearly see that not just the big 3 but all the other makers are charging about the same price

As I said before, just stop the crazy artificial demand (they buy to have, not to use), and prices will nosedive
Posted on Reply
#23
Vincero
@Athena they'll have their day in court.
All that has to be proven is that they didn't play fair to some customers vs others, be it spot pricing irregularities being offered or telling some customers there is no capacity available whilst offering it to others.
The judge didn't throw the case out so there may be some compelling evidence in support.

If either of those are true then anti-trust all the way. The price fixing part requires more evidence but will probably be able to be proven - it was 2 decades ago and I don't think they've gotten any smarter tbh about how they manage these things.
Posted on Reply
#24
TumbleGeorge
AthenaThey need to prove collusion, that all 3 got together and said they will artificially create shortages, to force price increases, and that is not what is going on, they got buyers for anything and everything that they can make, for years

It doesn't matter that they are switching lines to make more HBM, they are following the $, and there isn't any law that limits what you can and can't make, it's up to the company that makes it, and they are going after the best decision for THEM, and if they don't do this, they could be sued by shareholders




It's not price fixing since you got big players that are spending to buy RAM at ANY price, and all the fabs are pretty much at almost 100%, and the makers are not withholding supply

This is supply & demand at work, the same thing happened to wood, framing lumber skyrocketed to $1,500/1k feet since demand was so great
Now, since demand isn't, it's back down to under $500/1k feet

In order for it to be price fixing, then all 3 must get together and say that they are all going to charge $X, and limit production
You can clearly see that not just the big 3 but all the other makers are charging about the same price

As I said before, just stop the crazy artificial demand (they buy to have, not to use), and prices will nosedive
Yes so good theory. You must be convinced that they have infinity money
Posted on Reply
#25
londiste
Vincero@Athena they'll have their day in court.
All that has to be proven is that they didn't play fair to some customers vs others, be it spot pricing irregularities being offered or telling some customers there is no capacity available whilst offering it to others.
The judge didn't throw the case out so there may be some compelling evidence in support.

If either of those are true then anti-trust all the way. The price fixing part requires more evidence but will probably be able to be proven - it was 2 decades ago and I don't think they've gotten any smarter tbh about how they manage these things.
Depends on what you mean by "they". If one manufacturer does that, it isn't an antitrust case. If multiple manufacturers do, it might be an anti-trust case. For it to surely be one, there has to be proven collusion.

I really do not see how price-fixing today could be proven, effectively everything they can make they can sell at a very high price regardless of what they do.
Posted on Reply
Add your own comment
Nov 18th, 2026 20:38 PST change timezone

New Forum Posts

Popular Reviews

TPU on YouTube

Controversial News Posts